TD Ameritrade system caught up?
#17
Original Member




Join Date: May 1998
Posts: 2,513
I opened an account with TD ameritrade on 8/15/06 to get some miles. I put in $25k and immediately bought Airline stocks (AMR, LCC, LUV) with all $25k. On 9/25/06 I sold all my airline stocks now valued at $32k taking a profit of $7k. I subsequently invested in PHK fund which has rewarded me in interest and dividends of over $1000 for the past 4 months. So, while I wait for the last few days of my 6 months to get my other half of my SPG miles (10k) I will have profited over $8k AND got my 20k in miles. Not a bad return on my money and miles. FWIW, after the 6 months I will pull out my money, as I am not an stock market investor (contrary to my success).
Jim
Jim
#18


Join Date: Dec 2004
Posts: 8,224
Today, I tried to open a new account with TD Ameritrade for a bonus using SPG offer. In the past, I was able to open multiple accounts with different offers. However, this time, I got a message saying that I already have an account open and hence wouldn't get the new account bonus. Anybody else experienced the same thing?
I opened my account years ago with no bonus. Last fall TD Ameritrade offered to give me the spg bonus if I just increased my account balance. Instead of opening a new account with $25k, add $25k to what you have.
#19
Join Date: Jul 2002
Location: chicago, IL
Posts: 122
I have couple of questions about this deal.
How long would it take to get bonus miles (United) to be posted into my UAL account? It shows within 6 weeks but I want to know more realistic time-frame. In case of Fidelity (which shows same 6-week), it only takes 3-5 business days.
Also, regarding "Account must remain open with minimum funding for 9 months, or TD AMERITRADE may charge the account for the cost of the miles," what exactly mean by "minimum funding"? I don't think it refers to the initial funding amount. But, according to this thread, most people believe initial funding need to be kept in Ameritrade for 9 month. I want to know if this is true. I couldn't find anything about "minimum funding" (I might call to ask). In Fidelity, I can withdraw the money (not even a minimum funding) at any time.
How long would it take to get bonus miles (United) to be posted into my UAL account? It shows within 6 weeks but I want to know more realistic time-frame. In case of Fidelity (which shows same 6-week), it only takes 3-5 business days.
Also, regarding "Account must remain open with minimum funding for 9 months, or TD AMERITRADE may charge the account for the cost of the miles," what exactly mean by "minimum funding"? I don't think it refers to the initial funding amount. But, according to this thread, most people believe initial funding need to be kept in Ameritrade for 9 month. I want to know if this is true. I couldn't find anything about "minimum funding" (I might call to ask). In Fidelity, I can withdraw the money (not even a minimum funding) at any time.
#20


Join Date: Dec 2004
Posts: 8,224
In case it helps, I did the Starwood promotion and TD Waterhouse posted my points within 1 week, despite what the T&C say.
#21

Join Date: Mar 2008
Posts: 67
Also, regarding "Account must remain open with minimum funding for 9 months, or TD AMERITRADE may charge the account for the cost of the miles," what exactly mean by "minimum funding"? I don't think it refers to the initial funding amount. But, according to this thread, most people believe initial funding need to be kept in Ameritrade for 9 month. I want to know if this is true. I couldn't find anything about "minimum funding" (I might call to ask). In Fidelity, I can withdraw the money (not even a minimum funding) at any time.
#26
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: SFO/SJC, CA
Posts: 630
I am wondering if anyone has experience to share for joint account bonus since I heard different stories from different CSRs.
1. Yes, each join account with different "title" can get new account bonus.
2. No. TD Ameritrade trace this by primary account holder's SSN. (So if both A and B got bonus before, A+B won't get bonus)
Also, it is still unclear if you need to keep the money for 9 months to get second half. I read some posts in different forum that even they don't keep the money they still get the bonus. Anyone fail to get the bonus under this condition?
Thanks for anwser.
1. Yes, each join account with different "title" can get new account bonus.
2. No. TD Ameritrade trace this by primary account holder's SSN. (So if both A and B got bonus before, A+B won't get bonus)
Also, it is still unclear if you need to keep the money for 9 months to get second half. I read some posts in different forum that even they don't keep the money they still get the bonus. Anyone fail to get the bonus under this condition?
Thanks for anwser.


