Returning on same plane
#31
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: EWR/LGA/JFK
Programs: AA - EXP, Marriott - Sil, SPG-Gold
Posts: 120
After reading about a lot of the MR deals and looking at some of the itineraries I noticed that many of them have the same plane in and out (presumably). For example, I just saw a MR discussion that was on CO from LGA-IAH-SMF and back same day. The same plane and crew will most likely be doing the IAH-SMF and SMF-IAH flights so I got to thinking, what do the FAs say to you when they see you back on the plane? Do you ever feel awkward or get questioned?
I have been kind of amused reading about all the MRs because half the destinations I would at least like to stay a night or two but maybe that defeats the purpose of a MR. The international ones are the ones that I get a kick out of the most. If I was going 10,000 miles away, I would surely like to at least experience Sydney or Singapore or Europe for a weekend or a few days. Just curious what peoples experiences have been returning on the same plane with the same crew.
I have been kind of amused reading about all the MRs because half the destinations I would at least like to stay a night or two but maybe that defeats the purpose of a MR. The international ones are the ones that I get a kick out of the most. If I was going 10,000 miles away, I would surely like to at least experience Sydney or Singapore or Europe for a weekend or a few days. Just curious what peoples experiences have been returning on the same plane with the same crew.
#32
Join Date: Dec 2010
Location: Providence, RI
Programs: United 1K, Marriott Platinum
Posts: 30
I had an weird experience once...did a PVD-IAD-RIC-ORD-RIC-IAD-PVD. Left PVD 6am...stayed in at ORD overnight, left ORD at 6am.....didn't have to worry about missing the transfers because they were all on the same CRJ-700. I had one crew from PVD-IAD-RIC-ORD, and the next morning...had the same crew....was asked if I wanted a job!
#33
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: Fairport, NY
Posts: 195
Poor man's Mimosa
I am very distinctive, old, l(ong straggly beard. In F when asked for drink choice it is always a"poor man's mimosa please." (orange juice and sprite).
For two of my talt flights to Man during the Volcano activity the outbound crew talked with the return crew at the hotel and described me. Then on each return trip had my pm mimosa ready when I sat down.
ralph
For two of my talt flights to Man during the Volcano activity the outbound crew talked with the return crew at the hotel and described me. Then on each return trip had my pm mimosa ready when I sat down.
ralph
#34
FlyerTalk Evangelist


Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: BOS/ORH
Programs: Free Agent
Posts: 18,346
I will never forget the face a FA made when she approached me after realizing I was scheduled to be on her next flight. The flights in question was PDX-ANC-SEA on the same plane. She figured it out by looking at the paperwork.
I almost always fly the same route BOS/PDX and run into the same FA's all the time. They arent shocked anymore, except when I tell them i plan on staying for a few days
I almost always fly the same route BOS/PDX and run into the same FA's all the time. They arent shocked anymore, except when I tell them i plan on staying for a few days
#35


Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: MA
Programs: DL DM/2MM Marriott Platinum, HH Diamond,
Posts: 8,917
The potential issue that can arise with any short turnaround MR is that if the outbound flights are delayed, the cutoff for checking in for the return may occur. The fact that the return flight will also be delayed is actually not a factor since the computers will base the check-in cutoff based on the scheduled departure time.
#36


Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: AUS
Programs: AA Exec Platinum/MM, DL Gold/MM, Hilton Diamond, Accor Gold, Hertz Five Star
Posts: 7,495
Good topic. On the few MRs I have done, they always have an immediate turn and it's usually on the same plane. I agree that it feels a bit awkward, but often I will have chatted with the FA in F on the outbound and will have found out whether they are returning. If so, I usually mention what I'm doing, although I have occasionally concocted reasons besides MRs. I have NEVER encountered an FA who seems clued into the concept of mileage running.
I have always been recognized when getting back on, and if an FA looks surprised I just say "your service was so good on the way out, I just had to do it again."
Not necessarily a problem on all airlines. It IS a problem on DL, which I'm guessing is who you fly. Just check in via your PDA immediately after the door closes on your outbound flight, or via delta.com during the flight.
I have always been recognized when getting back on, and if an FA looks surprised I just say "your service was so good on the way out, I just had to do it again."
The potential issue that can arise with any short turnaround MR is that if the outbound flights are delayed, the cutoff for checking in for the return may occur. The fact that the return flight will also be delayed is actually not a factor since the computers will base the check-in cutoff based on the scheduled departure time.
#37
Join Date: Nov 2010
Location: NYC
Posts: 60
Last week I did IAH-SMF-IAH 2 days in a row on the same plane.
The first day FAs were surprised to see me boarding for the return flight. One actually approached me and asked: "are you doing this for miles?"
The 2nd day when I was on the outbound flight, one of the FA recognized me immediately and said: "you are baaaaaaack!!" I was sitting in 1B, and overheard her telling other FA (who weren't on the flights the previous day) in the gallery about my itinerary.
For the returning leg I didn't get upgraded. I was sitting in my seat while others were still boarding, and one curious FA walked to me and started asking me question about MR. During the flight another FA came and chatted me up, and actually offered me a blanket and free wine though I was sitting in economy class.
The first day FAs were surprised to see me boarding for the return flight. One actually approached me and asked: "are you doing this for miles?"
The 2nd day when I was on the outbound flight, one of the FA recognized me immediately and said: "you are baaaaaaack!!" I was sitting in 1B, and overheard her telling other FA (who weren't on the flights the previous day) in the gallery about my itinerary.
For the returning leg I didn't get upgraded. I was sitting in my seat while others were still boarding, and one curious FA walked to me and started asking me question about MR. During the flight another FA came and chatted me up, and actually offered me a blanket and free wine though I was sitting in economy class.
#38




Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: CHS
Programs: Delta PM, Hilton , Lifetime Bonvoy Titanium
Posts: 185
I would like to know how you can tell if on your return it is the same ship as you were on for your outbound? The MR's I have done so far have all been different ships on the return. Knowing you are on the same ship would be a huge relief trying to get back home. Obviously I cant answer the OP question.
#39



Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: BWIADCA
Posts: 2,269
GA and FA faces are priceless when they see something strange
Few years ago I went from IAD to GSP via Kentucky, Utah and Georgia. My routing was IAD-CVG-SLC-ATL-GSP. When GA saw my routing he declared that he can put me on IAD-ATL-GSP flight which will get me to GSP about 11 hours earlier. I didn't take his offer
When I did DCA-LAS-DCA runs for the past couple of weeks I started laughing when FA got "that" look after announcing gate for connecting flights.
I was on a flight DCA-LAS and she read over PA system "Washington Reagan????? gate A7". Look on her face was priceless
I've done a lot of same aircraft returns, but sometimes with diferent crew.
I've skipped offers from GA to do RDU-DCA non-stop when I had RDU-CLT-PHL-DCA itinerary
Flying is fun
Few years ago I went from IAD to GSP via Kentucky, Utah and Georgia. My routing was IAD-CVG-SLC-ATL-GSP. When GA saw my routing he declared that he can put me on IAD-ATL-GSP flight which will get me to GSP about 11 hours earlier. I didn't take his offer
When I did DCA-LAS-DCA runs for the past couple of weeks I started laughing when FA got "that" look after announcing gate for connecting flights.
I was on a flight DCA-LAS and she read over PA system "Washington Reagan????? gate A7". Look on her face was priceless
I've done a lot of same aircraft returns, but sometimes with diferent crew.
I've skipped offers from GA to do RDU-DCA non-stop when I had RDU-CLT-PHL-DCA itinerary
Flying is fun
#41
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: xLAS
Posts: 1,362
I would like to know how you can tell if on your return it is the same ship as you were on for your outbound? The MR's I have done so far have all been different ships on the return. Knowing you are on the same ship would be a huge relief trying to get back home. Obviously I cant answer the OP question.
even easier someplace like BKK, where there's exactly 1 UA flight in and out each day.
and yes, it was nice on my MRs to SJU knowing that i would never misconnect in SJU.
on one of the runs, i missed a golden opportunity though:
had flown the LAS/SFO/ORD piece of an LAS/SFO/ORD/SJU/ORD/LAS MR. had turned off my phone while sitting in the plane in ORD, and the pilot announced that he the plane needed 2 tires changed, and we'd be delayed an hour. my thoughts were, "no worries, i can't misconnect in SJU." my thoughts should have been, "turn on your phone." a GS agent had called and left me a message saying they'd re-routed me ORD/LAS instead of ORD/SJU/ORD/LAS to make sure the mechanical issues didn't result in me making it home that night. i could've spared myself 1/2-day of travel and then asked for original routing credit... darn.
#42




Join Date: Nov 2010
Location: IAH & CMH
Programs: UA GS, UA MM, Marriott Ambassador, Hilton Diamond, Uber Platinum :)
Posts: 941
I did a double trip MR run to Hawaii 3 weeks ago (Fri-Sat and Sun-Mon). Was recognized by a flight attendant from the Fri outbound flight who was working the red eye Sunday night. She commented I'd had a quick trip - didn't have the heart to tell her that I'd actually been home on the Saturday and flown back to HNL again on the Sunday!
Was fun telling a nosy PAX at ORD who was giving me 50 questions about my trip when asked how long I'd ben in Hawaii. "An hour"... he thought for a minute, opened his mouth to ask question #51, but then shut up
Another fun part of the trip was spotting fellow MR'ers... one guy got off the plane in MKE and looked lost... 10 mins later he got on the MKE-ORD flight on the same metal he'd just flown up on. I was laughing to myself knowing what he was up to!
Was fun telling a nosy PAX at ORD who was giving me 50 questions about my trip when asked how long I'd ben in Hawaii. "An hour"... he thought for a minute, opened his mouth to ask question #51, but then shut up

Another fun part of the trip was spotting fellow MR'ers... one guy got off the plane in MKE and looked lost... 10 mins later he got on the MKE-ORD flight on the same metal he'd just flown up on. I was laughing to myself knowing what he was up to!




