Chicago Pizza
#47
FlyerTalk Evangelist




Join Date: Sep 2000
Programs: BA, AA, DL, KLM, UA
Posts: 37,489
Originally Posted by brianbCID
Along these lines, where can I find the best Chicago Style pizza, in ORD during a layover?
#50
Moderator: CommunityBuzz!, OMNI, OMNI/PR, and OMNI/Games & FlyerTalk Evangelist



Join Date: Nov 2000
Location: ORD (MDW stinks)
Programs: UAMM, AAMM & ExPlat, Hyatt Globalist, Marriott lifetime Plat, IHG Plat, Hilton Diamond
Posts: 24,165
...if you're up for a change: CPOG. (Chicago Pizza and Oven Grinder Co.). Kind of unusual (they bake the pizza as a kind of "pizza pot pie" thing that is very tasty).
They're at 2121 N Clark St, and worth a try if you want some variety.
They're at 2121 N Clark St, and worth a try if you want some variety.
Let me describe the pizza pot pie. They take a small crock like bowl, the kind you would serve French onion soup in, put mediocre cheese in the bottom, then add a sauce that tastes like it is from a jar, the sausage is tiny bits and does not taste good almost like hamburger, then put the "Sicilian-style" dough w/no flavor on top of the crock, then bake. When the waiter comes out, he flips the crock upside down so that the dough is now on the bottom and the rest of the "pizza" falls into the cup shaped baked dough.
UGH! do not go to this place unless you have tried the other pizza places listed above and really want to try a self promoted w/o good reason restaurant.
There was also a Meditterenian bread served. The group choose wheat. Think large (very large) thin pita like bread w/seasonings, shaved cheese on it. Not bad but certainly did not live up to the billing on the menu that this was their most popular item.
What was terrific was the French Salad, a small size easily fed our group of 5. Farmer's cheese, lettuce, red onion, olives, tomatoes, cucumber, served with two dressings a poppyseed and a ranch. The waiter suggested that the two be mixed which I did. DELICIOUS!!! ^ ^ ^ ^
edited to add: the cheaper Chianti is a very decent wine to have.
Last edited by Sweet Willie; Oct 5, 2005 at 8:37 pm
#51
FlyerTalk Evangelist


Join Date: May 2000
Location: RDU
Programs: AA LT Gold, Breezy 2
Posts: 12,608
Hey Willie, tell us how you really feel.... 
Chicago has both stuffed pizza and deep-dish pizza. No, they are not the same. To me, stuffed is the suburban thing, and deep-dish is the city thing.
For stuffed pizza, I like Carmen's in Evanston the best. Nancy's (a local chain with many locations) is second. Giordano's is good enough but I agree with Willie's comments on an earlier page about their sauce.
For deep-dish pizza, it's Due during an off-peak time (we've had really good luck at FT gatherings going at 11:45am on a weekday). Malnatti's if I have to. I am not a fan of Geno's, and have had only bad experiences at Connie's and Aurelio's.
For thin-crust pizza, my favorite is Two Brothers From Italy in Elmhurst. When I lived in Elmhurst, I rarely ate stuffed or deep-dish as Two Brothers' thin crust was excellent.

Chicago has both stuffed pizza and deep-dish pizza. No, they are not the same. To me, stuffed is the suburban thing, and deep-dish is the city thing.
For stuffed pizza, I like Carmen's in Evanston the best. Nancy's (a local chain with many locations) is second. Giordano's is good enough but I agree with Willie's comments on an earlier page about their sauce.
For deep-dish pizza, it's Due during an off-peak time (we've had really good luck at FT gatherings going at 11:45am on a weekday). Malnatti's if I have to. I am not a fan of Geno's, and have had only bad experiences at Connie's and Aurelio's.
For thin-crust pizza, my favorite is Two Brothers From Italy in Elmhurst. When I lived in Elmhurst, I rarely ate stuffed or deep-dish as Two Brothers' thin crust was excellent.
#53
Suspended
Join Date: Jul 2005
Posts: 2,716
Just remember that deep dish crust is really more like pastry than dough. It is generally laden with fat and most likely transfats from the shortening. Unless you're good buddies with a cardiologist, I'd stick to the Italian variety.
#54
Join Date: Jun 2004
Programs: united premier exec, marriott platinum
Posts: 100
For displaced Chicagoans in the Bay Area...
Agree with original Uno and Due at the top of the list...though watch out for that sausage. I never, ever get heartburn except after eating sausage pizza there. So if you're prone, you might want to stick with veggies. Spinach is better than it sounds, too.
In college (Evanston) I got by on Giordano's often. A very, very solid option but not the best around. Ditto for Edwardo's and Connie's. Will have to try Silo next time I'm there, sounds promising.
For those Chicago expats in the Bay Area, try Zachary's in the East Bay. (Locations in Berkeley and on College Ave. in Oakland.) Best tomato sauce ever, with fresh tomatoes on top. The best Chicago pizza not located near an El stop. Crust can't match Original Uno cornmeal crust, but what can??
In college (Evanston) I got by on Giordano's often. A very, very solid option but not the best around. Ditto for Edwardo's and Connie's. Will have to try Silo next time I'm there, sounds promising.
For those Chicago expats in the Bay Area, try Zachary's in the East Bay. (Locations in Berkeley and on College Ave. in Oakland.) Best tomato sauce ever, with fresh tomatoes on top. The best Chicago pizza not located near an El stop. Crust can't match Original Uno cornmeal crust, but what can??
#56
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: YYC
Programs: AC MM
Posts: 1,410
Originally Posted by Sweet Willie
Malnati's on the other hand had very tasty sausage, tart chunky tomato sauce, CRUSTY CRUST, and a good amount of cheese that was not overwhelming.
The incredibly delicous chunky tomato sauce is unbelievable! My mouth is watering right now thinking about it.
#57
Join Date: Mar 2005
Posts: 8
Best places to eat in chicago
Pizza lou malnati's RiverNorth
Steak Gibsons on rush street or Mortons on State
General Dining Signature room on 95th Floor of hancock.
Best hotdog. Super Dawgs on north milwaukee.
Pizza lou malnati's RiverNorth
Steak Gibsons on rush street or Mortons on State
General Dining Signature room on 95th Floor of hancock.
Best hotdog. Super Dawgs on north milwaukee.
Last edited by sigprn; Oct 31, 2006 at 7:11 pm
#58
Moderator: CommunityBuzz!, OMNI, OMNI/PR, and OMNI/Games & FlyerTalk Evangelist



Join Date: Nov 2000
Location: ORD (MDW stinks)
Programs: UAMM, AAMM & ExPlat, Hyatt Globalist, Marriott lifetime Plat, IHG Plat, Hilton Diamond
Posts: 24,165
Originally Posted by sigprn
Best places to eat in chicago
Pizza lou malnati's RiverNorth.
Pizza lou malnati's RiverNorth.
Originally Posted by sigprn
Steak Gibsons on rush street or Mortons on State.
Originally Posted by sigprn
General Dining Signature room on 95th Floor of hancock.
Originally Posted by sigprn
Best hotdog. Super Dawgs on north milwaukee.
#59


Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Greater Chicagoland Area
Programs: frontier Elite, Hertz PC
Posts: 1,803
Originally Posted by Sweet Willie
There was just a FT Do at this restaurant last night. I had gone to Chicago Pizza and Oven Grinder Co when I was kid 20+ years ago, hated it then, and hated it last night.
Let me describe the pizza pot pie. They take a small crock like bowl, the kind you would serve French onion soup in, put mediocre cheese in the bottom, then add a sauce that tastes like it is from a jar, the sausage is tiny bits and does not taste good almost like hamburger, then put the "Sicilian-style" dough w/no flavor on top of the crock, then bake. When the waiter comes out, he flips the crock upside down so that the dough is now on the bottom and the rest of the "pizza" falls into the cup shaped baked dough.
UGH! do not go to this place unless you have tried the other pizza places listed above and really want to try a self promoted w/o good reason restaurant.
Let me describe the pizza pot pie. They take a small crock like bowl, the kind you would serve French onion soup in, put mediocre cheese in the bottom, then add a sauce that tastes like it is from a jar, the sausage is tiny bits and does not taste good almost like hamburger, then put the "Sicilian-style" dough w/no flavor on top of the crock, then bake. When the waiter comes out, he flips the crock upside down so that the dough is now on the bottom and the rest of the "pizza" falls into the cup shaped baked dough.
UGH! do not go to this place unless you have tried the other pizza places listed above and really want to try a self promoted w/o good reason restaurant.
I agree that the appetizer bread was good.
the pizza bowls were awful. As Willie described, it fails the taste test, and it fails my value test miserably. That pizza bowl is so small and it costs just under $20. I rather get a HUGE Giordano's pizza for that price, and it would taste infinitly better, and you get like 10X as much food.
So.. I would go farther that Willie and say avoid this place at all costs. There are so many more pizza places here in Chicago that I rather go to that this. I'd even try unknown places over this place.
#60
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Under an ORD approach path
Programs: DL PM, MM. Coffee isn't a drug, it's a vitamin.
Posts: 12,935
Originally Posted by Sweet Willie
There was just a FT Do at this restaurant last night. I had gone to Chicago Pizza and Oven Grinder Co when I was kid 20+ years ago, hated it then, and hated it last night.
I don't think I was paying a lot of attention to the culinary aspects of the joint.

