FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   Japan (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/japan-509/)
-   -   Typhoon Hagibis (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/japan/1990457-typhoon-hagibis.html)

PointsPanda Oct 10, 2019 10:40 pm


Originally Posted by RichardInSF (Post 31615282)
Lots and lots of people were stranded at NRT by ANA about 3 weeks ago when the last typhoon passed through. I have direct experience of this. Note that they stranded everyone, paid and award tickets both. ANA didn't even help with a hotel reservation in Narita town or (after those all filled up) transport back to Tokyo. ANA simply didn't care, period. Ironically, people who had booked the exact same ANA flights through a United codeshare were all automatically rebooked by United.

In my case, I happened to have enough miles to book an available award on UA the next day. My ANA award booked through Virgin Atlantic (which also refused to help but at least answered the phone) at least did promptly refund the points and fees.

My recommendation is to not book anything through ANA if it is during storm season. Then at least you'll only get screwed over if there is an earthquake.

I started a thread on this in the ANA forum and the consensus of the ANA fans there was that it was the way Japanese culture worked and I should just suck it up. I don't agree.

^^^^ Quite surprising because I was so excited to take this ANA flight after hearing such good things about their service and finally being able to skip the USA security theatre on the way to asia (i'm american but live in CDMX).

If I had to guess its more about the laws and types of compensation the airlines need to provide in case of cancellations are much weaker in other countries than in North America and Europe. So its probably less about one culture vs another than simply a large corporation that gives doesn't give a ... trying to give as little service and compensation as legally allowed under the law in their countries.

Yeah I was shocked at how ambivalent they were about rebooking me and went out of there way to make it clear that if the flight was cancelled or I got stuck in Tokyo they wouldn't pay a dime. People complain a lot about US carriers but they are not nearly as bad when it comes to complications to at least be sympathetic.
For example one time I booked a Turkish award with United, although the award got messed up (the ticket was "booked, but not issued" or something like this), I had tons of trouble boarding my flights from Africa back to Atlanta via Istanbul. Turkish lost all my bags, then the bag arrived to Mexico 2 weeks later completely ruined. Turkish wouldn't pay me a dime and gave me the run-around for week (I promised i would never fly them again in my life). United, however, was very sympathetic and gave me 50k miles compensation.

Some of these airlines with very good business class and reputation have very very BAD customer service when the s*t hits the fan. I've learned that non-US airlines really just don't care when you have some kind of problem, even when flying in biz.

Anyways my flight tomorrow is delayed 4 hours so it appears it is going to fly, and my connection in bangkok is that night so seems like everything is gonna be ok. MEX--> NRT is a super vital artery for star alliance passengers all over south america trying to get to Asia without needing a US visa so for them to miss the flight 2 days in a row is going to cause much more chaos for them then some shorter flights in asia where there are many more options. Plus the flight from NRT tonight is taking off, so now there are gonna be 2 787's sitting in CDMX, they need to get their plane's home. No way they are going to have THREE of them sitting here in CDMX by Monday.

RE: Booking ANA on United, oof that is expensive, but perhaps you have miles from flying but not great use of chase points, they charge about the same one way as Virgin and ANA charge for roundtrip! I'd save my United miles for South America on Avianca and Copa those are the best deals. Avianca also offers much better deals if you only need one way, including sometiomes i've seen first class on ANA for 70k miles from chicago or similar to tokyo (not sure if those deals still around)

You probably already knew all these things but thought i'd mention.

evergrn Oct 10, 2019 11:24 pm


Originally Posted by 5khours (Post 31611533)
but the eyewall hit the airport just as we were about to land. Knocked the plane two runway widths sideways in the blink of eye.

That sounds extremely dangerous, unless I'm not imagining things correctly. Good thing your plane was knocked horizontally and not blown down towards the ground. Seems crazy to take a chance on trying to land a plane with such tight margin for error.

5khours Oct 11, 2019 12:04 am


Originally Posted by evergrn (Post 31615384)
That sounds extremely dangerous, unless I'm not imagining things correctly. Good thing your plane was knocked horizontally and not blown down towards the ground. Seems crazy to take a chance on trying to land a plane with such tight margin for error.

That was my impression at the time. I was assuming they had no choice because after such a long flight they were low on fuel but after the pilot pulled up, he announced they still had five hours of fuel left. Nigel Lawson (then Chancellor of the Exchequer) was also on the flight and was livid that they wouldn't land the plane in Narita as he didn't want to miss his lunch appointment. :rolleyes:

Topcare Oct 11, 2019 12:26 am

Anyone know if HND has had any issue with flooding? Just wondering if rain and storm surge could cause issues like we saw at KIX. Have a friend scheduled to go NRT to Moscow on Sundau morning.

Any value is staying in Narita tomorrow night, assuming one can get there.

Do they also suspend the Narita Express? Guess he could try to go early tomorrow.

CPH-Flyer Oct 11, 2019 1:01 am


Originally Posted by Topcare (Post 31615504)
Anyone know if HND has had any issue with flooding? Just wondering if rain and storm surge could cause issues like we saw at KIX. Have a friend scheduled to go NRT to Moscow on Sundau morning.

Any value is staying in Narita tomorrow night, assuming one can get there.

Do they also suspend the Narita Express? Guess he could try to go early tomorrow.

Flooding is less likely at Haneda than at KIX. HND is higher above sea level.

I would guess there is a better chance of going early Sunday morning than Saturday evening.

LapLap Oct 11, 2019 1:34 am


Originally Posted by PointsPanda (Post 31615321)
^^^^ Quite surprising because I was so excited to take this ANA flight after hearing such good things about their service and finally being able to skip the USA security theatre on the way to asia (i'm american but live in CDMX).

To help squash this fantasy of an ANA ideal I’ll recount the only time I took ANA business flights (paid). Just before returning to London I had had kidney stones and was given some heat sensitive pain medication to help with getting back to the U.K. All I needed was assistance in keeping them cool (cabins can be very warm). Nope! ANA were not interested at all. Thankfully there was an Eastern European cabin crew on board, like a minnow darting around the big fish. He discretely got involved and rigged up a cup and ice solution for me. I’m still thankful to him personally, but I feel I have a much clearer view of what ANA actually is after that experience, which has been helpful (in its own way).

Dambus Oct 11, 2019 3:29 am


Originally Posted by AlwaysAisle (Post 31613431)
If I were you, I will change Shin Osaka -Hakata to Friday or cancel the trip to Hakata.

Managed to get to Shin-Osaka on Friday morning and reserve seats on on one of the trains leaving Friday afternoon (some were already fully reserved).

Looking at the edges of the storm system here now 500km West in Fukuoka (pitch black clouds and wind is picking up) I can only imagine how grim things are going to get on the East Coast. Stay safe.

AlwaysAisle Oct 11, 2019 7:06 am


Originally Posted by PointsPanda (Post 31615321)
I've learned that non-US airlines really just don't care when you have some kind of problem, even when flying in biz.

I will not put such pretty picture about US airlines. It is true that when weather condition is developing, such as hurricanes and storms, airlines in the U.S. will issue weather advisory and regardless of a flight is cancelled or not if your flight is on a date mentioned on an advisory and travel through an airport which is mentioned on an advisory then airline will allow you to change your flights without penalty. However, those cases airlines will rebook you on their own flights only, airlines will not rebook you on another airlines with different routing.

I live at Boston and winter snow disruption is annual event and every time local news will have passengers stuck not able to leave Boston because all the flights for next few days are totally booked solid because of mass cancellation by a storm. When hurricane hit it is usual occurrence that tourists on Caribbean islands are stuck for few days not able to get back home because there simply no flight available with open seats.

If you read FlyerTalk post then you will see that today it is common practice by US airlines that airlines will not waive non-refundable or non-changeable restriction if a medical condition prevented from taking flights (even with a doctor's note) or there was a death of immediate family (even with a death certificate). When you bought a ticket, condition is there and there is a travel insurance to provide monetary compensation in case of irregular events.

I do understand situation is frustrating, I have been flying internationally for more than few decades (show my age :p ), and especially with internet today we will hear other people's story which sounds like they were treated better. But often the reality is other side always look greener, but...

jashsu Oct 11, 2019 7:46 am


Originally Posted by AlwaysAisle (Post 31616382)
I will not put such pretty picture about US airlines. It is true that when weather condition is developing, such as hurricanes and storms, airlines in the U.S. will issue weather advisory and regardless of a flight is cancelled or not if your flight is on a date mentioned on an advisory and travel through an airport which is mentioned on an advisory then airline will allow you to change your flights without penalty. However, those cases airlines will rebook you on their own flights only, airlines will not rebook you on another airlines with different routing.

I had a ZRH-ATL-SFO on 9/12/2017. Due to Hurricane Irma, the ZRH-ATL sector was severely delayed/cancelled. Delta rebooked me onto a direct ZRH-SFO Swiss flight, landing earlier than my original scheduled arrival. So it was different carrier, different alliance, different routing. Later I requested ORC and got credit on both UA and DL.

Point is, US airlines definitely can make things work during IRROPS.

Mizunara Oct 11, 2019 8:06 am


Originally Posted by Topcare (Post 31615504)
Anyone know if HND has had any issue with flooding? Just wondering if rain and storm surge could cause issues like we saw at KIX. Have a friend scheduled to go NRT to Moscow on Sundau morning.

Any value is staying in Narita tomorrow night, assuming one can get there.

Do they also suspend the Narita Express? Guess he could try to go early tomorrow.

Tomorrow (Saturday night) is gonna be the worst of it. Assuming you can get there, I think the Narita might be back up and running by noon Sunday, though with a healthy number of delays and cancellations. If he's still trying to get out there, keep in mind that JR East is gonna start suspending services at 9am in a rolling pattern based on where the lines are in relation to the storm -- ones that are further south and close to the coasts will be shuttered first. The Narita Line, which the Narita Express runs on, is scheduled to begin stopping service just after 10am tomorrow.

AlwaysAisle Oct 11, 2019 9:01 am


Originally Posted by Topcare (Post 31615504)
Anyone know if HND has had any issue with flooding? Just wondering if rain and storm surge could cause issues like we saw at KIX. Have a friend scheduled to go NRT to Moscow on Sundau morning.

Any value is staying in Narita tomorrow night, assuming one can get there.

Do they also suspend the Narita Express? Guess he could try to go early tomorrow.

It looks like if your friend want to get to Narita on Saturday night then only option will be drive on own, all public transportation will not be running on Saturday night. Sunday morning will be also big question, as JR East has already said suspension of service will continue least till Sunday noon.

LapLap Oct 11, 2019 12:24 pm

The forecast for Saturday looks grim in Tokyo, and particularly so for farmers in Chiba (still reeling from last month’s assault by Typhoon Faxai).

https://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/20.../#.XaDF7S_TWhA
“ In a rather unusual step, major chain Ito Yokado said it will close 124 outlets in Tokyo, Kanagawa, Chiba, Saitama, Ibaraki, Gifu, Shizuoka and Aichi prefectures throughout Saturday. Department store Isetan Mitsukoshi Holdings announced the same day that its Shinjuku, Ginza and Ebisu stores in Tokyo will close on Saturday as well.

Theme parks are no exception either. Tokyo Disneyland and Tokyo DisneySea will close on Saturday for the first time since the Great East Japan Earthquake struck in 2011, operator Oriental Land Co. said. Universal Studios Japan said its Osaka facility will do the same.”

I understand that the venerable Ameya Yokochou shopping area in Ueno will temporarily close as a precaution and that it’s the only time it has done so in response to a weather threat for at least 70 years.

—-
In contrast, a typhoon that was predicted to hit Tokyo hard back in October 2002 did not provoke these levels of cautionary measures. I missed the worst of it safely ensconced within the Makuhari Messe in Chiba (the now Emperor was there too). It turned out that that typhoon wasn’t as bad as predicted, but even so, nobody was particularly anxious before it arrived.
That particular typhoon is covered in the “making of” documentary that accompanies the Lost In Translation movie.

CPH-Flyer Oct 11, 2019 6:18 pm

Quite hilarious to observe non Jaoanese people shopping this morning at Seijo Ishi, what are the changes that someone will eat 5 packs of psrma ham before the shops reopen tomorrow? Let's just buy everything we can carry that contains calories and don't require heating. I really had to restrain myself not to burst out laughing.

Maybe all of the 7--11 truck racing around the streets right now should hint that we are not facing food shortages....

Askartus Oct 11, 2019 6:33 pm

Greetings from Narita, T1
 
Hi there, we are currently sitting in NRT T1. Since we have an award J ticket for tomorrows flight to SIN via BKK with TG 641 departing at 10:50.

We do not know, if we are on the waiting list and if so, we do not have high hopes to get to BKK anytime before Hagibis hits the area. Hotels in the area are fully booked. Train and bus transport to the airport will end with the last NEX leaving Tokyo Station at 11:03 am.

Since this is our first disruption and might be our first sleep-over at an airport: Any hints, tips, ideas?

CPH-Flyer Oct 11, 2019 6:45 pm


Originally Posted by Askartus (Post 31619079)
Hi there, we are currently sitting in NRT T1. Since we have an award J ticket for tomorrows flight to SIN via BKK with TG 641 departing at 10:50.

We do not know, if we are on the waiting list and if so, we do not have high hopes to get to BKK anytime before Hagibis hits the area. Hotels in the area are fully booked. Train and bus transport to the airport will end with the last NEX leaving Tokyo Station at 11:03 am.

Since this is our first disruption and might be our first sleep-over at an airport: Any hints, tips, ideas?

If you hold a confirmed ticket for the flight on the 13th, then you are on the flight now worries. As long as it operates..

Current outlook is that the Kanto region should be clear of the Typhoon during the night, there is good reason to assume that the inbound flight from Bangkok will operate and land Sunday morning.

Might be tricky for a lot of customers to get to the airport though. Which should work to your advantage if you are indeed on the wairlist.

smetz224 Oct 11, 2019 6:45 pm

AA/JAL Saturday flight home from Tokyo to NYC was cancelled, AA wanted to rebook to Thursday with no compensation offered, still waiting on hold with JAL. Anyone have any tips or advice here?

Askartus Oct 11, 2019 7:06 pm


Originally Posted by CPH-Flyer (Post 31619092)
Might be tricky for a lot of customers to get to the airport though. Which should work to your advantage if you are indeed on the wairlist.

Just found out, that we were not on the stand-by. Which doesn't matter now, since the flight is overbooked as the afternoon flight was cancelled. These people will have priority.
Ours for tomorrow morning is not cancelled yet, so let's hope for the best.

Had a short power outage already in T1, so the typhoon is getting nearer.

Is anyone here as well?

CPH-Flyer Oct 11, 2019 8:22 pm


Originally Posted by Askartus (Post 31619138)
Just found out, that we were not on the stand-by. Which doesn't matter now, since the flight is overbooked as the afternoon flight was cancelled. These people will have priority.
Ours for tomorrow morning is not cancelled yet, so let's hope for the best.

Had a short power outage already in T1, so the typhoon is getting nearer.

Is anyone here as well?

The people with confirmed bookings for tomorrow's flight have priority for that one. People from the cancelled flight will only get on to the extend that seats are available.

CPH-Flyer Oct 11, 2019 8:28 pm

Sitting here on the 14th floor looking my Tokyo view, so far no weather that would have required a single train or flight cancellation. While I am sure it will come, the complete shut down of domestic flights today from Haneda has clearly been absurd.

rustykettel Oct 11, 2019 8:29 pm


Originally Posted by smetz224 (Post 31619094)
AA/JAL Saturday flight home from Tokyo to NYC was cancelled, AA wanted to rebook to Thursday with no compensation offered, still waiting on hold with JAL. Anyone have any tips or advice here?

Welcome to FlyerTalk! Look for alternate routings and supply those to the agent. An AA agent is probably going to be more flexible that JAL with alternate routings. Focus on getting to a US gateway, particularly with trying to standby on earlier flights. It's likely to be easier to get onward flights from there, although your total travel time could be higher.

Compensation is very unlikely for weather events.

CPH-Flyer Oct 11, 2019 8:35 pm

Narita is still operating, Haneda is closed. According to the activities on flightradar24

https://cimg5.ibsrv.net/gimg/www.fly...7adc74099d.jpg
https://cimg7.ibsrv.net/gimg/www.fly...d48a53620b.jpg

rustykettel Oct 11, 2019 8:51 pm

Shibuya crossing livestream


Very light, but looks like (some?) buses are still operating.

Mizunara Oct 11, 2019 9:17 pm

It's starting to really pour now down here in Kanagawa. Wind's picking up as well. So far I've been biding the time with coffee and lots of books. I don't envy anyone trying to deal with the airports today or tomorrow morning.

ainternational Oct 11, 2019 9:20 pm


Originally Posted by rustykettel (Post 31619335)
Shibuya crossing livestream

https://youtu.be/q5U4AEiLt5U

Very light, but looks like (some?) buses are still operating.

Great post. Cool to check this out even though I am also in Tokyo.

Scheduled to depart on LX161 to Zurich tomorrow morning from Narita. We shall see what transpires.....

Topcare Oct 11, 2019 9:21 pm


Originally Posted by CPH-Flyer (Post 31615583)
Flooding is less likely at Haneda than at KIX. HND is higher above sea level.

I would guess there is a better chance of going early Sunday morning than Saturday evening.

More thinking storm surge and hi tide.

rustykettel Oct 11, 2019 9:54 pm


Originally Posted by ainternational (Post 31619374)
Great post. Cool to check this out even though I am also in Tokyo.

Scheduled to depart on LX161 to Zurich tomorrow morning from Narita. We shall see what transpires.....

Another livecam


This one is bouncing around a bit more in the wind. Monorail and some trains are running.

Askartus Oct 11, 2019 10:21 pm

Narita is now closed for inbound flights until further notice.

https://www.narita-airport.jp/en/news/201910_emergency

Greetings from a rather uncomfy seat in T1 South ...

CPH-Flyer Oct 11, 2019 10:29 pm


Originally Posted by Topcare (Post 31619376)
More thinking storm surge and hi tide.

That does not really change the fact that Haneda is higher elevated, and most of the buildings further from the seawall than at Kansai.

Aymeric Nicaudie Oct 11, 2019 10:37 pm

cancelled flight
 
Anyone knows my flight has been cancelled it was due on saturday night with Air Asia to sunday night . And i would like to know if Air asia have to pay for my hostel night ?
They let me know one day before so i had to pay for a pretty expensive hostel and i hope to get it refund if possible ?
Anyone knows or had a similar experience?

From what i know the city is pretty much shutdown by now

CPH-Flyer Oct 11, 2019 10:41 pm


Originally Posted by Aymeric Nicaudie (Post 31619505)
Anyone knows my flight has been cancelled it was due on saturday night with Air Asia to sunday night . And i would like to know if Air asia have to pay for my hostel night ?
They let me know one day before so i had to pay for a pretty expensive hostel and i hope to get it refund if possible ?
Anyone knows or had a similar experience?

From what i know the city is pretty much shutdown by now

There is no legal obligation for Air Asia to provide a room, as this is weather related. And being a low cost carrier, you should probably expect to look at your travel insurance.

Mwenenzi Oct 11, 2019 10:56 pm


Originally Posted by Aymeric Nicaudie (Post 31619505)
Anyone knows my flight has been cancelled it was due on Saturday night with Air Asia to Sunday night . And i would like to know if Air Asia have to pay for my hostel night ?
They let me know one day before so I had to pay for a pretty expensive hostel and I hope to get it refund if possible ?
Anyone knows or had a similar experience?

From what I know the city is pretty much shutdown by now

Air Asia flight from where to where?
If related to Typhoon Hagibis check with your travel insurance

Topcare Oct 11, 2019 11:08 pm

Wind and rains starting to get stronger in Shinjuku.

latenightlaundry Oct 11, 2019 11:25 pm

I have a flight on AC Monday evening, from HND to Toronto (ticketed as a codeshare on ANA). The storm should be well on its way out by then, but should I be worried about the cascading effects from cancellations and delays over the weekend? I worry that the inbound aircraft may not make it/there may be shortages of landing or takeoff slots/there will be damage at HND.

Are my odds of getting out on time Monday evening any good? And is there anything that I can do to protect myself? (I have status on AC but not NH)

BuildingMyBento Oct 11, 2019 11:39 pm

I'm in Asakusa now, looking to wander a bit to the Sumida River...any takers?

Otherwise, perhaps we could just meet up to chat...I'm by the Don Quixote in 2chome.

/ennui

ainternational Oct 11, 2019 11:46 pm


Originally Posted by BuildingMyBento (Post 31619606)
I'm in Asakusa now, looking to wander a bit to the Sumida River...any takers?

Otherwise, perhaps we could just meet up to chat...I'm by the Don Quixote in 2chome.

/ennui

I’m in Mita. You could come by...

CPH-Flyer Oct 12, 2019 12:00 am


Originally Posted by ainternational (Post 31619619)
I’m in Mita. You could come by...

I am in Mita looking at the rain. Winds don't look too bad yet.

BuildingMyBento Oct 12, 2019 12:05 am


Originally Posted by ainternational (Post 31619619)
I’m in Mita. You could come by...

Nice of you to offer, but don't think it would be possible to get back to the room later on in the day.

Topcare Oct 12, 2019 12:51 am


Originally Posted by CPH-Flyer (Post 31619493)
That does not really change the fact that Haneda is higher elevated, and most of the buildings further from the seawall than at Kansai.

I hope you are right.

ainternational Oct 12, 2019 1:21 am


Originally Posted by CPH-Flyer (Post 31619637)
I am in Mita looking at the rain. Winds don't look too bad yet.

Small world. Looks like just another dreary day. Shame that everything is closed.

LapLap Oct 12, 2019 1:55 am

Shelter for foreign tourists next to Ueno Station
 
From NHK:
“ The Tokyo Metropolitan government has opened a temporary space for foreign tourists who have been stranded by disruptions to public transportation.

The facility is in the Tokyo Bunka Kaikan building in Ueno district in Taito Ward.

It will remain open from 1 p.m. on Saturday to 9 a.m. on Sunday, but the hours could change depending on the severity of the typhoon.”

The shelter is right next to the Ueno Station Park Entrance



All times are GMT -6. The time now is 9:16 am.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.