Reaching late night w/family - options
#1
Original Poster
Join Date: Aug 2016
Location: Canada
Posts: 15
Reaching late night w/family - options
Hi,
Flyertalk noob here.
I am visiting my home country for a month with my wife and 5 yo son. On-route from Canada, we are planning to detour via HKG and SIN for 4 days each.
We’ll have 2 check-in baggage (20kb/45lb) and 2 cabin baggage (7kg/15lb). The current flight I am seeing takes me to HKG at 10:30 PM. Others flights are expensive.
How much time does it take me to get from the gate to outside? I have to go through immigration, etc. and collect the luggage so I am guessing, it would be 1.5-2 hours when we are outside the airport. I haven’t booked hotel, but I am thinking somewhere in Kowloon.
We are planning Disneyland 1 day/360 Ngong 1 day/ Kowloon & HK Island – 1.5 days.
What are my options to get to the hotel at that hour (say midnight) -
1) Wait at HKG lounge overnight, try to get some sleep and then take the airport express in the morning. I have Priority Pass lounge passes that I can make use of.
o Is there a limit on time? Are there comfortable couches to get sleep? I would have done 25 hour journey at this time.
o In the morning, check in luggage at the hotel and go for light sightseeing (I understand we’ll be tired that day)
o Here, I will save money on 1 hotel night (that’s not my purpose, but its just happening in this option)
2) Try to make it to Airport Express to Kowloon and then take taxi from Kowloon. Last train is at 00:48. Do I have enough time to catch it in time?
o Is it easy for us to carry the luggage and lil one through the Airport Express? I am used to crowds/transit and have general agility.
o Taxis at Kowloon: Is it safe at that hour and available easily?
3) If I happen to miss the Airport Express, then take the N11, get down somewhere in Kowloon - 80 (N11) + 40(taxi) = 120 HK$
o If N11 takes to the hotel, well and good. If not, take taxi to hotel. Are they easily available?
4) Take taxi directly to hotel – 300 HK$
Flyertalk noob here.
I am visiting my home country for a month with my wife and 5 yo son. On-route from Canada, we are planning to detour via HKG and SIN for 4 days each.
We’ll have 2 check-in baggage (20kb/45lb) and 2 cabin baggage (7kg/15lb). The current flight I am seeing takes me to HKG at 10:30 PM. Others flights are expensive.
How much time does it take me to get from the gate to outside? I have to go through immigration, etc. and collect the luggage so I am guessing, it would be 1.5-2 hours when we are outside the airport. I haven’t booked hotel, but I am thinking somewhere in Kowloon.
We are planning Disneyland 1 day/360 Ngong 1 day/ Kowloon & HK Island – 1.5 days.
What are my options to get to the hotel at that hour (say midnight) -
1) Wait at HKG lounge overnight, try to get some sleep and then take the airport express in the morning. I have Priority Pass lounge passes that I can make use of.
o Is there a limit on time? Are there comfortable couches to get sleep? I would have done 25 hour journey at this time.
o In the morning, check in luggage at the hotel and go for light sightseeing (I understand we’ll be tired that day)
o Here, I will save money on 1 hotel night (that’s not my purpose, but its just happening in this option)
2) Try to make it to Airport Express to Kowloon and then take taxi from Kowloon. Last train is at 00:48. Do I have enough time to catch it in time?
o Is it easy for us to carry the luggage and lil one through the Airport Express? I am used to crowds/transit and have general agility.
o Taxis at Kowloon: Is it safe at that hour and available easily?
3) If I happen to miss the Airport Express, then take the N11, get down somewhere in Kowloon - 80 (N11) + 40(taxi) = 120 HK$
o If N11 takes to the hotel, well and good. If not, take taxi to hotel. Are they easily available?
4) Take taxi directly to hotel – 300 HK$
#2
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Oct 2001
Location: Falkirk, Scotland,VS Red, BA Gold, HH Diamond,UK Amex Plat
Programs: Master of the Privy Purse des Muccis
Posts: 17,912
Hi,
Personally I would think you will have passed immigration and collected your bags and be landside within 1 hour from leaving the aircraft ( and probably a bit quicker) as immigration and baggage reclaim at HKG is quick in my experience.
With 3 people ( not sure if there are child discounts) on the Airport Express I would probably just take a taxi to Kowloon.
You could take the AE to Kowloon but then you would have to carry your suitcases to the taxi rank ( there were trolleys at Kowloon when we passed through last month.)
Regards
TBS
Personally I would think you will have passed immigration and collected your bags and be landside within 1 hour from leaving the aircraft ( and probably a bit quicker) as immigration and baggage reclaim at HKG is quick in my experience.
With 3 people ( not sure if there are child discounts) on the Airport Express I would probably just take a taxi to Kowloon.
You could take the AE to Kowloon but then you would have to carry your suitcases to the taxi rank ( there were trolleys at Kowloon when we passed through last month.)
Regards
TBS
#3
Suspended
Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: Hong Kong
Programs: None any more
Posts: 11,017
You can expect to be landside with bags in 45-50 minutes; 60-65 on a bad day, so you will be in plenty of time unless your flight is seriously delayed. You can take the luggage trolleys from the baggage carousel to the train door, and from the train door in Kowloon or HK stations to the taxis, which are safe and readily available.
In general you can't wait at a lounge because they are in the departure area and you are arriving. The two areas are separate. The only option is the Plaza Premium arrivals lounge, for which Priority Pass gives you a maximum 3 hour stay. I can't see a scenario in which that would be helpful.
Taxis should be no problem in most areas of Kowloon around midnight. You should be able to catch the regular airport buses unless your flight is delayed - the last A20 and A21 are at 00:00. If you miss them then you want N21 to Kowloon, not N11.
So basically if your flight's on time you'll be fine with the airport express and then a taxi to your hotel. Or the A21 (most likely) if it happens to go near your hotel.
And if you're too late for the airport express then I'd say just get a cab.
In fact as the previous reply said, with 3 people, the airport express option won't be cheaper than a cab direct. So if money is tight take the bus; otherwise just take a cab.
In general you can't wait at a lounge because they are in the departure area and you are arriving. The two areas are separate. The only option is the Plaza Premium arrivals lounge, for which Priority Pass gives you a maximum 3 hour stay. I can't see a scenario in which that would be helpful.
Taxis should be no problem in most areas of Kowloon around midnight. You should be able to catch the regular airport buses unless your flight is delayed - the last A20 and A21 are at 00:00. If you miss them then you want N21 to Kowloon, not N11.
So basically if your flight's on time you'll be fine with the airport express and then a taxi to your hotel. Or the A21 (most likely) if it happens to go near your hotel.
And if you're too late for the airport express then I'd say just get a cab.
In fact as the previous reply said, with 3 people, the airport express option won't be cheaper than a cab direct. So if money is tight take the bus; otherwise just take a cab.
#4
Original Poster
Join Date: Aug 2016
Location: Canada
Posts: 15
I was planning on getting the AE pass but looks like the 2 ride pass doesnt save anything over the 1 ride pass. So I guess I will just toss between bus and taxi based on how stressed we are at that point. Thanks guys.
#5
Join Date: Dec 2010
Location: YYZ
Programs: AMEX AC CX UA AA DL
Posts: 3,008
There is round the clock public transit from airport... taxi, night bus, hotel coach (which might be upgraded to sedan for free at the coach company's discretion if no one else is going to that area at that time)
#6
Join Date: Sep 2012
Location: NW London and NW Sydney
Programs: BA Diamond, Hilton Bronze, A3 Diamond, IHG *G
Posts: 6,344
A 5-year-old needs to pay the child fare, which is $50 each way on a child Octopus card.
An adult round trip ticket is $117 on Klook, that is $58.50 each way and there is a free bus from the station to many hotels
An adult round trip ticket is $117 on Klook, that is $58.50 each way and there is a free bus from the station to many hotels
#7
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: ZOA, SFO, HKG
Programs: UA 1K 0.9MM, Marriott Gold, HHonors Gold, Hertz PC, SBux Gold, TSA Pre✓
Posts: 13,811
OP - simply choose taxi and leave the rest behind.
Lounge is not really a good place for a child to stay, especially the lounge could be crowded during that time. Airport Express can be expensive in your case. Even available, you may require additional transportation. Bus option is even worse, when the cash you have will be large bills and you may not be able to get an Octopus card.
Taxi, although being the most expensive option, has the least concerns.
Lounge is not really a good place for a child to stay, especially the lounge could be crowded during that time. Airport Express can be expensive in your case. Even available, you may require additional transportation. Bus option is even worse, when the cash you have will be large bills and you may not be able to get an Octopus card.
Taxi, although being the most expensive option, has the least concerns.
#8
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: LAX
Posts: 10,909
As noted 30-60 min to get out depending on gate lines etc. Take a taxi - dont make your life miserable to save a few $.
Since you plan to go to disneyland you may consider splitting your stay and staying a couple nights at airport marriott that will make going to disneyland much easier and save time on arrival
Since you plan to go to disneyland you may consider splitting your stay and staying a couple nights at airport marriott that will make going to disneyland much easier and save time on arrival
#9
Suspended
Join Date: May 2006
Location: HKG
Programs: A3, TK *G; JL JGC; SPG,Hilton Gold
Posts: 9,952
Or take an uber
whatever the government says, ubers are safer than cabbies.
and passengers do not take the legal risk of taking an uber.
whatever the government says, ubers are safer than cabbies.
and passengers do not take the legal risk of taking an uber.
Ure less likely to run into scams too.
in any case, if u take a taxi, you’d be given a paper slip by the airport staff at the taxi rank. That paper is FOR YOU TO KEEP. If the taxi driver wants the paper, its massive alarm bells for scammers. You keep the paper, and tell him to mind his own business.
in any case, if u take a taxi, you’d be given a paper slip by the airport staff at the taxi rank. That paper is FOR YOU TO KEEP. If the taxi driver wants the paper, its massive alarm bells for scammers. You keep the paper, and tell him to mind his own business.
#10
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: ZOA, SFO, HKG
Programs: UA 1K 0.9MM, Marriott Gold, HHonors Gold, Hertz PC, SBux Gold, TSA Pre✓
Posts: 13,811
#11
Join Date: Feb 2013
Location: Hilton, Hyatt House, Del Taco
Posts: 5,378
I agree that taxi would generally be the easiest choice, given the OP's situation.
BUT... HKG taxi drivers can be a bit crazy. One time we were in a similar situation, arriving really late (like 11pm) with little kids. So we decided to cab it. Scariest cab ride ever. The driver kept falling half-asleep behind the wheel! He was swerving from lane to lane. We shouted at him repeatedly, he'd wake up again, and he'd say "okay okay" with a smile. Then a minute later, he looks half-sleep. We asked him if he was okay, shouldn't he pull over, etc, etc. He kept saying "okay, okay" and kept driving. That's the last time I've taken a night-time taxi from HKIA into town. This fall, we'll be landing late again and this time we're staying at the airport hotel and taking the train into town in the morning. I know this experience was an outlier, but still.
BUT... HKG taxi drivers can be a bit crazy. One time we were in a similar situation, arriving really late (like 11pm) with little kids. So we decided to cab it. Scariest cab ride ever. The driver kept falling half-asleep behind the wheel! He was swerving from lane to lane. We shouted at him repeatedly, he'd wake up again, and he'd say "okay okay" with a smile. Then a minute later, he looks half-sleep. We asked him if he was okay, shouldn't he pull over, etc, etc. He kept saying "okay, okay" and kept driving. That's the last time I've taken a night-time taxi from HKIA into town. This fall, we'll be landing late again and this time we're staying at the airport hotel and taking the train into town in the morning. I know this experience was an outlier, but still.
#12
Join Date: Oct 2014
Location: HKG
Posts: 1,053
I agree that taxi would generally be the easiest choice, given the OP's situation.
BUT... HKG taxi drivers can be a bit crazy. One time we were in a similar situation, arriving really late (like 11pm) with little kids. So we decided to cab it. Scariest cab ride ever. The driver kept falling half-asleep behind the wheel! He was swerving from lane to lane. We shouted at him repeatedly, he'd wake up again, and he'd say "okay okay" with a smile. Then a minute later, he looks half-sleep. We asked him if he was okay, shouldn't he pull over, etc, etc. He kept saying "okay, okay" and kept driving. That's the last time I've taken a night-time taxi from HKIA into town. This fall, we'll be landing late again and this time we're staying at the airport hotel and taking the train into town in the morning. I know this experience was an outlier, but still.
BUT... HKG taxi drivers can be a bit crazy. One time we were in a similar situation, arriving really late (like 11pm) with little kids. So we decided to cab it. Scariest cab ride ever. The driver kept falling half-asleep behind the wheel! He was swerving from lane to lane. We shouted at him repeatedly, he'd wake up again, and he'd say "okay okay" with a smile. Then a minute later, he looks half-sleep. We asked him if he was okay, shouldn't he pull over, etc, etc. He kept saying "okay, okay" and kept driving. That's the last time I've taken a night-time taxi from HKIA into town. This fall, we'll be landing late again and this time we're staying at the airport hotel and taking the train into town in the morning. I know this experience was an outlier, but still.
On the other hand, had to change my young Uber driver's tire on the shoulder of the Lantau highway once, so stuff happens
Would still recommend a taxi to the OP. Take a look at the driver and request a different one if you don't feel comfortable.
#14
Suspended
Join Date: May 2006
Location: HKG
Programs: A3, TK *G; JL JGC; SPG,Hilton Gold
Posts: 9,952
I agree that taxi would generally be the easiest choice, given the OP's situation.
BUT... HKG taxi drivers can be a bit crazy. One time we were in a similar situation, arriving really late (like 11pm) with little kids. So we decided to cab it. Scariest cab ride ever. The driver kept falling half-asleep behind the wheel! He was swerving from lane to lane. We shouted at him repeatedly, he'd wake up again, and he'd say "okay okay" with a smile. Then a minute later, he looks half-sleep. We asked him if he was okay, shouldn't he pull over, etc, etc. He kept saying "okay, okay" and kept driving. That's the last time I've taken a night-time taxi from HKIA into town. This fall, we'll be landing late again and this time we're staying at the airport hotel and taking the train into town in the morning. I know this experience was an outlier, but still.
BUT... HKG taxi drivers can be a bit crazy. One time we were in a similar situation, arriving really late (like 11pm) with little kids. So we decided to cab it. Scariest cab ride ever. The driver kept falling half-asleep behind the wheel! He was swerving from lane to lane. We shouted at him repeatedly, he'd wake up again, and he'd say "okay okay" with a smile. Then a minute later, he looks half-sleep. We asked him if he was okay, shouldn't he pull over, etc, etc. He kept saying "okay, okay" and kept driving. That's the last time I've taken a night-time taxi from HKIA into town. This fall, we'll be landing late again and this time we're staying at the airport hotel and taking the train into town in the morning. I know this experience was an outlier, but still.
PS: the cabbie problem in hong kong is a systematic one, so i dont think looking at one in the eye and decide would change much. taking the train would defo avoid the gpia situation
Last edited by kaka; Jun 6, 2018 at 3:49 am
#15
Suspended
Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: Hong Kong
Programs: None any more
Posts: 11,017
I feel kaka exaggerates the situation dramatically. Granted I don't take taxis from the airport, but in 20 years of taking them regularly around town I can think of only one occasion where the driver tried to take a "scenic" route, plus a couple where there wouldn't go cross-harbour when asked.
However, there are two blackspots: taxis hanging around at the lower Peak Tram station seem quite often to be scammers, and there is the problem of taxis at Lan Kwai Fong late on a Friday and Saturday night declining short rides (or demanding high fixed prices). A standard rule of taxis anywhere is "you pick the taxi, don't take a taxi that picks you". The luggage fees are part of the standard regulated published fare, they aren't a scam.
I'd far, far rather use a HK taxi than take a ride in some unknown, unlicensed and uninsured person's private vehicle. Uber drivers are just as likely to fall asleep (or have a heart attack and die while driving, killing other people, as happened recently) as taxi drivers.
However, there are two blackspots: taxis hanging around at the lower Peak Tram station seem quite often to be scammers, and there is the problem of taxis at Lan Kwai Fong late on a Friday and Saturday night declining short rides (or demanding high fixed prices). A standard rule of taxis anywhere is "you pick the taxi, don't take a taxi that picks you". The luggage fees are part of the standard regulated published fare, they aren't a scam.
I'd far, far rather use a HK taxi than take a ride in some unknown, unlicensed and uninsured person's private vehicle. Uber drivers are just as likely to fall asleep (or have a heart attack and die while driving, killing other people, as happened recently) as taxi drivers.