FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   Germany (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/germany-626/)
-   -   obtaining german citizenship (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/germany/882396-obtaining-german-citizenship.html)

londonbound86 Oct 28, 2008 10:21 am

obtaining german citizenship
 
Hi there

My father was born in Germany back in 1946, after the war in a refugee camp. My grandfather was german and they remained there until 1949 I believe then migrated over to the US.

My father and grandfather both being born there, does that give me right to apply for dual nationality??
I know longer speak with my father, and have a feeling I would have to get his naturalisation papers?

oliver2002 Oct 28, 2008 11:19 am

You can get German citizenship based on your grandfather's status. Its a bit trickey, but usually the local consulate will help. Read the infopages of the Chicago consulate and you will know more: http://www.germany.info/Vertretung/u...tizenship.html

londonbound86 Oct 28, 2008 11:38 am

Thanks

Would it matter if my father is now an American Citizen ( naturalised)

YVR Cockroach Oct 28, 2008 12:39 pm


Originally Posted by londonbound86 (Post 10590534)
Thanks

Would it matter if my father is now an American Citizen ( naturalised)

Might depend on when he took out U.S. citizenship. I think you're pretty much SOL if he was naturalised before your birth.

In fact, the FAQ section of the Ottawa embassy's webpage confirms this:


German passports are only issued to German citizens. Having German ancestors is unfortunately not enough to attain German citizenship. Rather, your father and/or mother have to have been German citizens at the time of your birth. If you were born before 1 January 1975 and your parents were married, you only attained German citizenship if your father was German at the time of your birth or if your parents submitted a declaration by 31 December 1977 stating they wanted German citizenship for their child.
See: http://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/diplo...Vorfahren.html

londonbound86 Oct 28, 2008 12:50 pm

he did, but maintaned dual nationality.

YVR Cockroach Oct 28, 2008 12:55 pm


Originally Posted by londonbound86 (Post 10590907)
he did, but maintaned dual nationality.

That's not allowed in most cases.


How can German citizenship be lost?

A German national who applies for and receives a foreign nationality (except the nationality of one of the EU Member States or Switzerland) loses his/her German nationality. The only way of preventing the loss of German citizenship is if the applicant obtained permission to retain the nationality by the German authorities prior to acquiring the foreign nationality.

German nationals required to perform military service who voluntarily enter the forces or comparable armed groups of a country of which they are also a national without the consent of the district draft board lose their German nationality automatically.

For further advice, please contact the competent German mission covering your place of residence.
See: http://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/diplo...2-Verlust.html

flyingfkb Oct 28, 2008 1:10 pm


Originally Posted by londonbound86 (Post 10590907)
he did, but maintaned dual nationality.

The dual citizenship for German citizens taking on for example the US citizenship is I think a pretty new thing. Probably only a couple of years old, but I might be wrong.

Anyway you have to apply for dual citizenship and get the okay of the German authorities BEFORE you take on your new second citizenship. If you don't do this you will automatically loose your German citizenship and the German state is not very tolerant with people who try to get around the rule.

There were example of Turkish citizens taking in the German citizenship and giving up there Turkish citizenship but the reapplied for a Turkish passport. When the German authorities found out about it they immediately canceled the German citizenship.

oliver2002 Oct 28, 2008 3:15 pm


Originally Posted by caspritz78 (Post 10591023)
The dual citizenship for German citizens taking on for example the US citizenship is I think a pretty new thing. Probably only a couple of years old, but I might be wrong.

It is possible since 2000, but only if you apply prior to accepting the new citizenship.

idrathersail Oct 28, 2008 3:35 pm

I actually just completed this process last week with the German consulate in NY. It took about a year from application to getting a passport, but it went smoothly. Was your father Jewish? If so, then you are allowed to keep you american citizenship under a special program for anyone who's citizenship was stripped by the Nazis. You should contact your local consulate; they are very helpful. Mainly, they needed paperwork from the US; they can find all the german documentation in their meticulous archives.

The german passport is much cooler than our humble american ones! ;)

BDL-FRA Oct 30, 2008 1:17 pm


Originally Posted by caspritz78 (Post 10591023)
The dual citizenship for German citizens taking on for example the US citizenship is I think a pretty new thing. Probably only a couple of years old, but I might be wrong.

Anyway you have to apply for dual citizenship and get the okay of the German authorities BEFORE you take on your new second citizenship. If you don't do this you will automatically loose your German citizenship and the German state is not very tolerant with people who try to get around the rule.

There were example of Turkish citizens taking in the German citizenship and giving up there Turkish citizenship but the reapplied for a Turkish passport. When the German authorities found out about it they immediately canceled the German citizenship.

I work with someone who gained dual citizenship quite naturally. He was born in the US of German parents who were working there for a couple of years. The parents applied for and received the German passport for him. Years later, after they had returned to Germany, he wanted to go to school in the US, and realized that all he needed was his birth certificate. Since he was born in the US, he was automatically entitled to a US Passport. Walked into the embassy, and walked out with a passport a couple hours later.

Aviatrix Oct 31, 2008 1:26 pm


Originally Posted by BDL-FRA (Post 10603217)
I work with someone who gained dual citizenship quite naturally. He was born in the US of German parents who were working there for a couple of years. The parents applied for and received the German passport for him. Years later, after they had returned to Germany, he wanted to go to school in the US, and realized that all he needed was his birth certificate. Since he was born in the US, he was automatically entitled to a US Passport. Walked into the embassy, and walked out with a passport a couple hours later.

OK, so he has a US passport now. The question is, will he get to keep the German one?

If he applied for the US passport before 2000 he won't. If he applied for it after 2000, but without asking for permission from the German government, again - he won't. Unless, of course, he hides his US citizenship from the Germans - I know people who got away with this (and I also know someone who got away with it for many years but lost her German citizenship when they eventually found out)

superflyer99 Oct 31, 2008 1:34 pm

I miss the good old days when the ethnic German "resettlers" (Aussiedler) who settled in Eastern Europe in the 18th century could easily get citizenship.

flyingfkb Oct 31, 2008 2:04 pm


Originally Posted by BDL-FRA (Post 10603217)
I work with someone who gained dual citizenship quite naturally. He was born in the US of German parents who were working there for a couple of years. The parents applied for and received the German passport for him. Years later, after they had returned to Germany, he wanted to go to school in the US, and realized that all he needed was his birth certificate. Since he was born in the US, he was automatically entitled to a US Passport. Walked into the embassy, and walked out with a passport a couple hours later.

That's a a different story. He got the US citizenship naturally because he was born in the US. Since his parents are German he is also German. So both citizenships laws apply. The US one that grants everyone who is born in the US the US citizenship and the German law that gives you are German citizenship when your parents are German independent of where you are born.


Originally Posted by Aviatrix
If he applied for the US passport before 2000 he won't. If he applied for it after 2000, but without asking for permission from the German government, again - he won't.

Are you sure abou? this. As I said above I don't think that people who were born in the US to German parents fall under this rule.

YVR Cockroach Oct 31, 2008 2:28 pm


Originally Posted by Aviatrix (Post 10608787)
OK, so he has a US passport now. The question is, will he get to keep the German one?

If he applied for the US passport before 2000 he won't. If he applied for it after 2000, but without asking for permission from the German government, again - he won't. Unless, of course, he hides his US citizenship from the Germans - I know people who got away with this (and I also know someone who got away with it for many years but lost her German citizenship when they eventually found out)

You're forgetting applying for a passport is not equal to applying for nationality or citizenship (since the concept seems a bit foreign to those who live in the U.K. who think you have to have a passport to prove your citizenship). BDL-FRA's U.S.-born German national friend just applied for a U.S. passport, not U.S. citizenship which he was entitled to due to birth. He would have lost German citizenship if he obtained U.S. (or most other) citizenship other than through birth (geographically or through descent).

mangoMan Oct 31, 2008 3:12 pm


Originally Posted by caspritz78 (Post 10608987)
...and the German law that gives you are German citizenship when your parents are German independent of where you are born.

The interesting thing about this is that only one parent needs to be German. I was born in the US to German parents (both), however I never bothered getting a German passport until I was an adult. Shortly after I finally did get a passport (2003-4 timeframe), it was also possible for my children to get German passports because I had a German passport, even though my wife is not German. Theoretically it seems my kids can now get German passports for their kids, ad infinitum. This seems like a loophole of sorts.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 7:23 am.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.