FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   Emirates | Skywards (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/emirates-skywards-490/)
-   -   Involuntary Downgrade (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/emirates-skywards/575770-involuntary-downgrade.html)

sonomawine Feb 10, 2015 1:35 pm

I had American Express that issued the tickets call Emirates. They too were amazed at the lack of customer service or responsibility accepted for a downgrade. After the AMEX rep was transferred several times they were eventually told that I should ask for a voucher when I check-in for the flight, but couldn't provide any details about the voucher.

I did check to see if it was just a one day equipment change, but unfortunately it is a permanent change.

Thank you all for your input. I will let you know how the voucher plays out, if at all.

Dave Noble Feb 10, 2015 1:43 pm

I am not sure why American Express is amazed

You really have the choices to

Accept the downgrade
Rebook for a day when there is availability
Cancel

If you cancel , the airline is not going to charge you any penalty ( and if it was to do so, then AMEX would be able to assist in that service purchased wouldnt match supplied )

I would be surprised if you got much of a voucher if at all given that the fare would almost certainly not be any cheaper

m3red Jul 13, 2016 10:35 pm


Originally Posted by Dave Noble (Post 24316086)
Did you make the change to go via MUC or not? It is a bit unclear

The regulation is pretty simple in that if a passenger is downgraded on a flight where the regulation is applicable then 75% of the fare is due to be reimbursed to the passenger

It also seems that EK will not pay up without a fight

Unfortunately the one person I have seen who has posted having tried to take it to court seems to have failed after failing to turn up to present their claim ; apparantly EK sent no one from its side to defend it

The more recent poster ( in this thread ) never did come back with information on the outcome of his claim

Unfortunately for you in your specific case , the flight which has been downgraded ( DXB-ATH on Emirates ) is not one which is covered by the regulation , so you would have no claim in this case

If it was an ATH-DXB sector, then that would be covered


In order for a flight to be one under which EC261 applies , in simple terms has to either be

A flight departing from an airport in Europe - on any airline
or
A flight departing from an airport outside Europe to Europe - on a European airline

( it is slightly more complicated than that but is close enough for most purposes :) )

Dave,

Does this mean that a connecting flight from Dubai is not covered?

For example, LGW DXB then 3 hour connection DXB PEK is downgraded to a 2 class that would not fall under 261?

I've booked the above but am slightly concerned about them swapping the 77w. If they do I'm going to court if I'm covered under 261, enough of EK customer affairs!

Saltire74 Jul 13, 2016 11:11 pm


Originally Posted by m3red (Post 26913965)
Dave,

Does this mean that a connecting flight from Dubai is not covered?

For example, LGW DXB then 3 hour connection DXB PEK is downgraded to a 2 class that would not fall under 261?

I've booked the above but am slightly concerned about them swapping the 77w. If they do I'm going to court if I'm covered under 261, enough of EK customer affairs!

I think you would be highly unlucky m3red for this to happen. There has been 1 downguaged equipment using the 77W on the DXB-PEK route since the beginning of June.

Hopefully you won't have any issues with your flight.

http://www.theeksource.com/routetracker.html

SAfe & Happy Travels

S

Dave Noble Jul 14, 2016 12:09 am


Originally Posted by m3red (Post 26913965)
Dave,

Does this mean that a connecting flight from Dubai is not covered?

For example, LGW DXB then 3 hour connection DXB PEK is downgraded to a 2 class that would not fall under 261?

I've booked the above but am slightly concerned about them swapping the 77w. If they do I'm going to court if I'm covered under 261, enough of EK customer affairs!

You would not be covered since the DXB-PEK is not departing from the EU

youvesaiditall Nov 14, 2016 10:40 am

Aircraft Downgrade Flight 102 (MXP>DXB)
 
I had booked a trip in First using JAL Rewards in First class. The leg from MXP to DXB was to be in a 3 class 777-300. In checking my reservation, the aircraft was downgraded to a 2-Class 773 and my seat is now business class.

Dealing with JAL to update to a different flight has been a pain. Any thoughts on a different way to remedy? Am I owed any compensation (be it by EK or JAL) should they be unable to accommodate?

Sorry if this has been asked before--a search yielded no results. Thanks in advance for your assistance!

eternaltransit Nov 14, 2016 10:58 am


Originally Posted by youvesaiditall (Post 27478746)
I had booked a trip in First using JAL Rewards in First class. The leg from MXP to DXB was to be in a 3 class 777-300. In checking my reservation, the aircraft was downgraded to a 2-Class 773 and my seat is now business class.

Dealing with JAL to update to a different flight has been a pain. Any thoughts on a different way to remedy? Am I owed any compensation (be it by EK or JAL) should they be unable to accommodate?

Sorry if this has been asked before--a search yielded no results. Thanks in advance for your assistance!

I'm afraid only JAL can help you as the flight will be on JL stock.

An F ticket entitles you to a seat in the highest cabin of service - JL will claim no compensation is payable.

As reward tickets are usually fully flexible if the cabin is more important than the timetable, would recommend changing the date, but there may be partner award availability.

youvesaiditall Nov 14, 2016 11:08 am


Originally Posted by eternaltransit (Post 27478842)
I'm afraid only JAL can help you as the flight will be on JL stock.

An F ticket entitles you to a seat in the highest cabin of service - JL will claim no compensation is payable.

As reward tickets are usually fully flexible if the cabin is more important than the timetable, would recommend changing the date, but there may be partner award availability.


Thanks for the reply. I did go back to JAL once more and changing the date did the trick.

scotclif Nov 15, 2016 2:41 pm


Originally Posted by youvesaiditall (Post 27478904)
Thanks for the reply. I did go back to JAL once more and changing the date did the trick.

fingers crossed the aircraft is not changed again.

HKprince Nov 15, 2016 3:29 pm

I suggest you switch to EK205 or EK91 for peace of mind. This is my regular route and EK101 is the only one that gets swapped out for the 2 class. Others are highly unlikely to be swapped out as both are A380 with EK205 even less likely as it continues on to JFK.

wilsonnyc Aug 14, 2017 6:13 am

Bumping this thread again as I have a very similar situation and had a few q's for the experts (I seldom fly EK, so not sure how this should work and what I should expect/not expect)

The basics: Have a multi-leg trip upcoming all booked and ticketed in F using JAL miles (JFK>DXB>SEZ>DXB>ATH>EWR, with stops in DXB, SEZ, and ATH. A few weeks ago I got a downgrade email on the DXB>ATH leg (equip change from 3 cabin to 2 cabin 777). I have spoken to both EK and JAL and because there is currently not F upgrade space on the earlier flight from DXB>ATH (which actually would be preferable timing, as we arrive early on a redeye from SEZ), they cannot change our flights. They also noted that they could easily change it if space opens up between now and the flight. Nothing abnormal there, have EF alerts set, 4 F seats are still avail on the earlier flight to ATH.

My two main questions:

1) If upgrade space does NOT open up, but F remains with open seats, can anyone on the ground make a day-of change to the 3-class/earlier flight, given we were involuntarily downgraded? Is there some sort of process for getting on a standby list once we are on the ground?

2) If the answer to question 1 is "no, they can't make such a day-of change given it was a partner award" (which is the vibe I am getting), can we still access the First Class lounge in DXB for our almost 11 hr layover? Would be kind of a bummer if that answer is also "no", given we were initially ticketed in F and were vaguely looking fwd to a nice layover in the First class lounge in DXB.

Understood that some of these requests may be at the discretion of the DXB ground team, but was hoping someone with a similar experience might have some real-world insight and advice on how to handle, if we can't make the change ahead of checking in.

Beecharmer Dec 12, 2017 1:27 pm

Evening all. Apologies for raising this topic but I’ve been fortunate up til now. I’ve been downgraded due to an equipment swap from F to J from DXB into the UK. Am I right in thinking the EU compensation laws don’t apply here? And also, am I entitled to a proportionate refund and what is the best way to go about it? Any experiences and advice will be welcomed;

skywardhunter Dec 12, 2017 1:38 pm


Originally Posted by Beecharmer (Post 29166143)
Evening all. Apologies for raising this topic but I’ve been fortunate up til now. I’ve been downgraded due to an equipment swap from F to J from DXB into the UK. Am I right in thinking the EU compensation laws don’t apply here? And also, am I entitled to a proportionate refund and what is the best way to go about it? Any experiences and advice will be welcomed;

Yes, No EC261. It'll be a battle. How did you pay? You should of course get a refund but your calculation will likely differ from EKs

Beecharmer Dec 12, 2017 1:52 pm


Originally Posted by skywardhunter (Post 29166183)
Yes, No EC261. It'll be a battle. How did you pay? You should of course get a refund but your calculation will likely differ from EKs

Thanks for the clarification, I feared as much. Did pay with the MBNA Emirates AMEX but am thinking they will use flight prices now for J rather than when I booked months ago. Didn’t screen-shot those of course :(

DYKWIA Dec 12, 2017 4:09 pm


Originally Posted by Beecharmer (Post 29166239)


Thanks for the clarification, I feared as much. Did pay with the MBNA Emirates AMEX but am thinking they will use flight prices now for J rather than when I booked months ago. Didn’t screen-shot those of course :(

One option may be to change your flight. What is the route? If it's MAN, then there are normally 2 flights a day with F, plus one 2 class. So, you may be able to shift your flight.

m3red Dec 12, 2017 8:38 pm


Originally Posted by DYKWIA (Post 29166783)
One option may be to change your flight. What is the route? If it's MAN, then there are normally 2 flights a day with F, plus one 2 class. So, you may be able to shift your flight.

you can 100% move you flight if it works for you...

Beecharmer Dec 13, 2017 10:31 am

Thanks both, jip it's one of the MAN flights swapped to a 2 class. Have never found the call centre too helpful so figured it was easier to swap to the later flight rather than fight for a partial refund. Emirates works well most of the time but not when the matter is irrops! But then, their flight frequencies can't be beaten when that's the case.

skywardhunter Dec 13, 2017 10:35 am


Originally Posted by Beecharmer (Post 29169792)
Thanks both, jip it's one of the MAN flights swapped to a 2 class. Have never found the call centre too helpful so figured it was easier to swap to the later flight rather than fight for a partial refund. Emirates works well most of the time but not when the matter is irrops! But then, their flight frequencies can't be beaten when that's the case.

Aircraft swap ahead of time isn't IRROPS

m3red Dec 13, 2017 11:59 am

You will be disappointed with what refund you get! Defo swap

Lavezzi Dec 20, 2017 6:08 pm

edited

DrAlex Mar 31, 2018 11:53 am

I wanted to share a positive experience since I was pretty dejected after reading this thread. I had an aircraft change that led to a downgrade from F to J (773 to 772) later in the year. I called several times and mostly got the standard ‘you must pay the fare difference for a different routing’. I politely said I would check into my schedule and get back to them. On the 4th call I finally felt like I had purchased a F ticket! Extremely nice, polite, and helpful agent changed my ticket routing through SFO instead of SEA - no up fare. This yet again proves that if you don’t like the first response (or three) HUCA may eventually get the desired result.

XXTSGR Mar 31, 2018 12:02 pm


Originally Posted by dralex (Post 29587731)
i wanted to share a positive experience since i was pretty dejected after reading this thread. I had an aircraft change that led to a downgrade from f to j (773 to 772) later in the year. I called several times and mostly got the standard ‘you must pay the fare difference for a different routing’. I politely said i would check into my schedule and get back to them. On the 4th call i finally felt like i had purchased a f ticket! Extremely nice, polite, and helpful agent changed my ticket routing through sfo instead of sea - no up fare. This yet again proves that if you don’t like the first response (or three) huca may eventually get the desired result.

👍
​​​​​​​

ioto1902 Mar 31, 2018 2:50 pm

Just out of curiosity. How many times maximum were you ready to try ?
As for me, three times is a max.

DrAlex Mar 31, 2018 10:39 pm


Originally Posted by ioto1902 (Post 29588203)
Just out of curiosity. How many times maximum were you ready to try ?
As for me, three times is a max.

Well, as many as it took or until it was escalated to a supervisor or upper level person. Plus, I’ve got 6 months until the flight, so I was ready for a long battle. Almost all North American airlines would change without too much resistance, so I felt pretty slighted by finding out EK wants to up charge for the fare difference with a routing change.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 11:29 am.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.