FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   DiningBuzz (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/diningbuzz-371/)
-   -   Consolidated "Scotch - Best & Worst, recommendations, questions" thread (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/diningbuzz/584612-consolidated-scotch-best-worst-recommendations-questions-thread.html)

zitsky Apr 25, 2018 5:12 pm


Originally Posted by EuropeanPete (Post 29683711)
It depends what kind of Speyside you're considering, but Teeling Small Batch might be worth a try in case you like your Macallan and other sherry type casked bottles. I'd also say that Green Spot or Yellow Spot might be up your alley.

Thanks, I will look for those. I do like Macallan.

OldVines Apr 25, 2018 6:53 pm

I saw this thread, started to read, and couldn't help drifting to the drinks cabinet for a small glass of Highland Park. Possibly a mistake with lots of work still to do today!

exerda Apr 27, 2018 7:06 pm


Originally Posted by EuropeanPete (Post 29683711)
It depends what kind of Speyside you're considering, but Teeling Small Batch might be worth a try in case you like your Macallan and other sherry type casked bottles. I'd also say that Green Spot or Yellow Spot might be up your alley.

I second the Yellow Spot, particularly if you like the sherry cask-type stuff.

Dingle's Single Pot Still whiskey is very Speyside-esque IMHO, but probably a tough bottle to find (I got the bartender at a Dingle Distillery bar in Dublin to sell me one; none of the shops had any on hand). There's also some Bushmill's 16-year sherry cask I've had which would be a nice comparison, albeit again very hard.

zitsky Apr 27, 2018 7:20 pm

I hate being in NC where you have to go to the state store. They dont have a good selection. Couldn't even find Johnnie Walker black, just double black. Don't laugh, I like it.

iceblueshoes Apr 27, 2018 9:04 pm

I'm sure many will laugh, but I finally got to try Chivas tonight (Chivas 18) at a Scotch tasting and really enjoyed it!

Also tried the Nadurra which was incredibly complex but also VERY smooth. The alcohol feels much lower than it actually is.

EuropeanPete Apr 28, 2018 4:57 am


Originally Posted by exerda (Post 29691687)
Dingle's Single Pot Still whiskey is very Speyside-esque IMHO, but probably a tough bottle to find (I got the bartender at a Dingle Distillery bar in Dublin to sell me one; none of the shops had any on hand).

I've recently spent about 10 weekends hanging out in Dublin's cocktail bars, but I can't remember ever having seen that!

zitsky Apr 28, 2018 8:24 am


Originally Posted by iceblueshoes (Post 29691910)
I'm sure many will laugh, but I finally got to try Chivas tonight (Chivas 18) at a Scotch tasting and really enjoyed it!

Also tried the Nadurra which was incredibly complex but also VERY smooth. The alcohol feels much lower than it actually is.

I did not know until recently that Chivas is from Speyside. I have tried it before. It's ok.

gfunkdave Apr 28, 2018 3:28 pm


Originally Posted by zitsky (Post 29692889)
I did not know until recently that Chivas is from Speyside. I have tried it before. It's ok.

It's a blend. Are you saying all its components are from Speyside? THat's interesting.

I like Chivas - it's my favorite cheap blended scotch.

zitsky Apr 28, 2018 8:01 pm


Originally Posted by gfunkdave (Post 29694006)
It's a blend. Are you saying all its components are from Speyside? THat's interesting.

I like Chivas - it's my favorite cheap blended scotch.

Yes it's a blend. From speyside according to google.

exerda Apr 29, 2018 5:11 pm


Originally Posted by EuropeanPete (Post 29692528)
I've recently spent about 10 weekends hanging out in Dublin's cocktail bars, but I can't remember ever having seen that!

IIRC, the bartender said there were only a few hundred bottles produced from that release. Dingle Distillery is a pretty small operation; we toured it in late 2016 before they'd aged anything enough to legally release as Irish whiskey. I wish I'd been able to find a bottle of their cask strength single malt; I tried some in Dublin and loved it.



Originally Posted by exerda (Post 29691687)
There's also some Bushmill's 16-year sherry cask I've had which would be a nice comparison, albeit again very hard.

Funny that I should mention that one. Picked up a bottle at a VA ABC store yesterday ($99). It's definitely a solid dram if you like cask finishes (it's actually 3-wood, not just sherry; I was mistaken on that point. Sherry & bourbon for the primary aging, then finished in port casks I believe).

CMK10 May 20, 2018 8:46 pm

https://photos.smugmug.com/Travel/Fl...699008_n-L.jpg

Picked this up this week, my first time seeing it at the Durham ABC stores. It's not bad and a fun change of pace from my usual brands but nothing I think I'll buy again. Still, for $67, why the hell not?

mandolino May 22, 2018 3:35 am

We're fortunate here ABZ town in that there are at least two bars that specialise in whisky and the bar staff are experts.
(Those two would be The Grill and CASC - IMO, YMMV)

That raises the "bar" for all the other places so you have a pretty good likelihood of someone at least moderately well-informed serving you in most pubs.
It's a great town for sampling whisky but unfortunately no cheaper than anywhere else because the price is mostly tax .

And Aberdeen drams are notoriously smaller than Glasgow drams, being traditionally 1/6 gill by the old measure whereas Glasgow were 1/5 or 1/4. Now pubs have generally moved to 25ml (Aberdeen and the North) and 35 ml (Glasgow and the South/Central)
Gills to mils

By the way, I live a short walk from the original Chivas Brothers premises in Aberdeen and not too long a drive from their current flagship at Strathisla , Keith.

From Keith, you can take a short Heritage Railway trip to Dufftown where it's a short walk to Glenfiddich visitor centre, and Balvenie and others.

Then you can walk along the River Fiddich to reach the Spey at Craigellachie and on to Aberlour if you wish. It's quite doable moderate hike - I've done it with kids and a small dog. A good Speyside whisky tour in very scenic country

Anyway, taking a visiting whisky-loving colleague on a tour of local bars, I discovered that I quite liked Ledaig, a bit sweet for a peaty island malt, made at Mull's only distillery Tobermory.
I also learned that it's pronounced Le-jig. Somehow it had slipped under my radar, although I've seen it around

CMK10 May 29, 2018 11:56 am

SJU Duty Free has a sale on Johnny Walker Blue today, two 750 ML bottles for $309. My local ABC stores in North Carolina sell them for $250 a bottle. Hell of a deal.

zitsky May 29, 2018 12:25 pm


Originally Posted by CMK10 (Post 29805785)
SJU Duty Free has a sale on Johnny Walker Blue today, two 750 ML bottles for $309. My local ABC stores in North Carolina sell them for $250 a bottle. Hell of a deal.

Is Blue still blended scotch? I drink black never had blue.

EuropeanPete May 30, 2018 3:30 am


Originally Posted by CMK10 (Post 29805785)
SJU Duty Free has a sale on Johnny Walker Blue today, two 750 ML bottles for $309. My local ABC stores in North Carolina sell them for $250 a bottle. Hell of a deal.

I was at the Caresse Resort in Bodrum, Turkey yesterday and a 40ml serve Johnny Walker Black was about $18US. A serve of JW Gold was the same... as was a serve of JW Blue.

I do it enjoy it when people running a bar don't know how to calculate GP's properly and leave fun little sweet spots on the spirits menu.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 4:58 pm.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.