FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   DiningBuzz (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/diningbuzz-371/)
-   -   Consolidated "Scotch - Best & Worst, recommendations, questions" thread (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/diningbuzz/584612-consolidated-scotch-best-worst-recommendations-questions-thread.html)

zitsky Mar 4, 2018 8:26 am


Originally Posted by Duke787 (Post 29482959)
Good night for the right shade of blue (Duke) tonight. Celebrated by killing my Hibiki 21 (finally - bought it 3 years ago and have been savoring it) and enjoying some Hibiki 17 (thankfully reloaded in December in Tokyo) and Yoichi Miyagikyo 12 (sadly almost out of a bottle I bought pre-price spike).

Can say with certainty that Hibiki 17 remains my favorite and I actually give the nod to the Yoichi 12 over the Hibiki 21.

Too bad it's all gotten so expensive. The "Japanese Whisky" price premium on everything these days sucks for those of us who actually enjoy drinking it (rather than just flipping it).

Next goal is to find things that are similar but in the old Japanese Whisky price range.

What sort of price hike are we talking about? I've always wanted to try it.

EuropeanPete Mar 8, 2018 5:37 am

Hibiki 17 (and 30) are old favorites of mine too, but unfortunately their value has increased more rapidly than my income over the last decade, so I rarely get a chance to drink them now. Obviously not the same as Japanese whisky, but I'm finding good Irish whiskey to be very fairly priced and lovely to drink. Check out the Teeling special releases, the nicer Redbreast, or Green/ Red Spot as examples. I would not be surprised if Irish whiskey undergoes the same increase in price in 5-10 years, so it might be best to get your fill of it in now.

BamaVol Mar 9, 2018 8:14 am

With a return to winter-like temperatures this week, I wasn't in the mood for a cold beer. Rummaging around the back of the liquor cabinet I found an unopened bottle of Glenfarclas 12 year. I gave it a couple tries but my impression was "meh". Not particularly smoky or peaty, maybe a little on the sweet side, but not particularly anything. I returned it to the back of the cabinet.

Larrude Mar 9, 2018 8:23 am


Originally Posted by BamaVol (Post 29504327)
With a return to winter-like temperatures this week, I wasn't in the mood for a cold beer. Rummaging around the back of the liquor cabinet I found an unopened bottle of Glenfarclas 12 year. I gave it a couple tries but my impression was "meh". Not particularly smoky or peaty, maybe a little on the sweet side, but not particularly anything. I returned it to the back of the cabinet.

BamaVol, you did a great job of describing this Speyside whisky. I also find it a little on the sweet side and certainly not overpowering, but it has the attributes that I expect from a whisky from that area.
I rarely find a peaty profile unless I'm tasting something from Islay or the Islands. Yes, there are others, but not so much in Speyside or even the Highlands.

Personally, I've never met a bottle of Laphroaig that I didn't like :)

Pa Kettle Mar 22, 2018 1:42 pm


Originally Posted by Larrude (Post 29504351)
BamaVol, you did a great job of describing this Speyside whisky. I also find it a little on the sweet side and certainly not overpowering, but it has the attributes that I expect from a whisky from that area...

Sounds similar to another Speyside product - Glen Fohdry Dublaich.

Pa Kettle Mar 22, 2018 2:02 pm

Had the opportunity to recently attend a Glenmorangie Scotch tasting at a local Total Wine store. It was hosted by Brendan McCarran, Head of Maturing Stocks at the distillery. Kudos to him for staying up past midnight to lead it.

We went through 5 variations: Glenmorangie Original; Sherry Cask Lasanta, Quinta Ruban Port Cask; Extremely Rare 18; and Spios Private Edition #9 .

He said that they pull from Glenmorangie Original (10 year) to produce the others. Lasanta spends an additional 2 years in either Pedro Ximenez or Oloroso sherry casks. It won Highland Single malt Scotch of the year last year. Quinta Ruban spends an additional 2 years in Ruby Port casks. The Extremely Rare 18 is aged to 15 years then spends another 3 years in either Pedro Ximenez or Oloroso sherry casks. Spios is their 9th edition special distillation. It is fully matured in former American rye whiskey casks. While Spios translates as "spicy", I didn't find it overly so. Our host said he was skeptical at first at what they might end up with using rye whskey casks, but once fully matured, he was won over. I believe Whiskey.com gives it a 90 out of 100 rating.

I think my favorite was the Extremely Rare 18, but I found the Spios to be very interesting and actually bought a bottle for the liquor cabinet.

CMK10 Mar 27, 2018 7:00 pm

I've decided this year to branch out and try new bottles for my nightly cocktail. Here's my first purchase. I like it, a little on the peety side but that doesn't turn me off. Love the color too

https://photos.smugmug.com/Travel/Fl...732599_n-L.jpg

zitsky Mar 27, 2018 7:37 pm


Originally Posted by CMK10 (Post 29574717)
I've decided this year to branch out and try new bottles for my nightly cocktail. Here's my first purchase. I like it, a little on the peety side but that doesn't turn me off. Love the color too

Did you pick that up in an NC ABC (alcohol) store, or at a duty free shop on one of your trips?

gfunkdave Mar 27, 2018 7:42 pm


Originally Posted by CMK10 (Post 29574717)
I've decided this year to branch out and try new bottles for my nightly cocktail. Here's my first purchase. I like it, a little on the peety side but that doesn't turn me off. Love the color too

https://photos.smugmug.com/Travel/Fl...732599_n-L.jpg

Too much ice!!

CMK10 Mar 27, 2018 8:01 pm


Originally Posted by zitsky (Post 29574811)
Did you pick that up in an NC ABC (alcohol) store, or at a duty free shop on one of your trips?

The ABC Store near my house actually (NC-55 in south Durham). They had some good deals on scotches and a better selection than I'm used to.


Originally Posted by gfunkdave (Post 29574822)
Too much ice!!

I love a lot of ice. Whether I'm "supposed to" or not, it's my drink and it's how I take it.

exerda Mar 29, 2018 7:43 pm


Originally Posted by zitsky (Post 29574811)
Did you pick that up in an NC ABC (alcohol) store, or at a duty free shop on one of your trips?

I'm curious what it runs in NC. VA ABC charges around $105. I got my current bottle at a Costco in Seaside, CA, for $45 (it was normally $65 but was on sale).

tentseller Mar 30, 2018 12:24 am


Originally Posted by exerda (Post 29582543)
I'm curious what it runs in NC. VA ABC charges around $105. I got my current bottle at a Costco in Seaside, CA, for $45 (it was normally $65 but was on sale).

L16 standard price at CA Costco is $64.99. Lowest in US including many duty-frees.
There and HKG/SIN duty-free is where I replenish my go to, L16.

MaxBuck Mar 30, 2018 8:03 pm


Originally Posted by CMK10 (Post 29574717)
I've decided this year to branch out and try new bottles for my nightly cocktail. Here's my first purchase. I like it, a little on the peety side but that doesn't turn me off. Love the color too

https://photos.smugmug.com/Travel/Fl...732599_n-L.jpg

As I've said elsewhere, Lagavulin is a sledgehammer of a drink. But sometimes a sledgehammer is just the tool for the job.

HomerJay Mar 30, 2018 8:42 pm


Originally Posted by MaxBuck (Post 29586085)
As I've said elsewhere, Lagavulin is a sledgehammer of a drink. But sometimes a sledgehammer is just the tool for the job.

The first time I ever tasted Lagavulin, I immediately realized it might not be perfect, but it was perfect for me and for my taste.
It is my water of life. I can't completely explain it. I just love it.

gfunkdave Apr 1, 2018 12:36 pm

I really wish I could get into the smoky peaty scotches. I just don't like them. :(


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 3:04 pm.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.