FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   DiningBuzz (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/diningbuzz-371/)
-   -   Consolidated "Bagels" thread (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/diningbuzz/557025-consolidated-bagels-thread.html)

chgoeditor Aug 20, 2021 9:29 pm


Originally Posted by JBord (Post 33506315)
I guess I'm no bagel aficionado. I love Montreal bagels and NYC bagels are good too. But the best ones we have here in Chicago are comparable enough for me. We prefer the Once Upon bagels, which I believe are now also available at Kitsch'n on Roscoe, if that's closer to you. Although they're probably more than a few hours old there.

I love bagels but don't seek them out. For example, decades ago I lived down the street from D&D in Evanston. They got bagels delivered daily, and they were warm when D&D opened. I bought one every day. When Jacob's Brothers existed, I also bought one every day because it a blocked from my office. We now live within 2 miles of New York bagel and bialy, and after standing in line to buy once, I would never do it again. So I may have opinions about what is a good or bad bagel, but I also don't stand in line for more than 10 minutes for a great bagel.

ILuvParis Sep 14, 2021 10:13 pm

Jacobs Brothers. Those were the days.

TWA884 May 1, 2026 2:30 pm

Chef, cookbook author and KCRW Good Food host Evan Kleinman:

Bagels of Today

To me, a bagel is a smallish, round (saying this because someone might make a square one in some kind of weird mold), savory bread with a chewy, somewhat dense, and resistant texture. It’s the reason I try to avoid a bagel with no discernible hole in the middle. The hole allows the crumb of the bagel to cook more evenly to the proper texture. I remember the first time I had a soft-ish bagel. I spit it out, thinking something was wrong. I walked back into the bagel shop and asked what had changed. Turns out they had stopped boiling their bagels before baking them. I said, “You should call them rolls,” and walked out.

In her recent article for
The New York Times,“Big Money is Coming for Bagels,” Julia Moskin says, “Not all the offerings are strictly traditional, but the tangy interiors, chewy-crisp crusts and plentiful toppings are a major improvement on the puffy, pale bagels that have long ruled American strip malls.” Yeah, those pale, too soft bagel simulacrums have had their day.

ILuvParis May 1, 2026 2:42 pm

We were just talking about planning a trip to Montreal to meet some friends from London (who refuse to come to the U.S. until after the problem is eliminated) this fall. And, I immediately thought of bagels. I log on and lo and behold, this thread has been bumped!

FlyingChuck May 3, 2026 1:15 pm

Smiled when I saw this thread. Recommending a couple LA spots:

Maury's
Courage Bagels

Eastbay1K May 3, 2026 2:04 pm


Originally Posted by ILuvParis (Post 37732284)
We were just talking about planning a trip to Montreal to meet some friends from London (who refuse to come to the U.S. until after the problem is eliminated) this fall. And, I immediately thought of bagels. I log on and lo and behold, this thread has been bumped!

Ah yes, your post has me fondly remembering Beauty's Bagels on Oakland. Not the same since Wise Sons took it over.

Meanwhile I had a delicious Hella Bagel for lunch. Better than the NYT loving Boichick. But grateful to have both nearby
https://sf.eater.com/dining-report/2...-bagels-review

gaobest May 3, 2026 3:33 pm

I still love bagels. Wise sons / beauty, boichik, yum. But those aren’t cheap - boichik is $3.25 each for just a single bagel.

once upon a bagel in highland park might now be $1.50 each in comparison.

TWA884 May 4, 2026 5:01 pm


Originally Posted by FlyingChuck (Post 37734910)
Smiled when I saw this thread. Recommending a couple LA spots:

Maury's
Courage Bagels

Courage is my favorite. I also like Hank's. I'm not familiar with Maury's, but I'll give it a try the next time when I'm headed downtown on the 101.

Meanwhile, here are KCRW Good Food recommendations:

9 of LA's Best New Bagel Shops

CLASSIC

Pops
... the bagels at Pop’s hit the Venn diagram of texture — they’re both chewy and soft.

H&H
The bagels are solid: not too thick, not too thin, with a nice amount of chew. They make for excellent breakfast sandwiches.

Boichik
... is perfect for those who don’t love a fluffy bagel. Their bagels are a bit sturdier and more dense.

RIP-AND-DIP

PopUp Bagels
They’re known for smaller and puffier bagels... The shape and size is well-suited to the way the founders insist the bagels be eaten: ripped and dipped.

Calic Bagel
All of their bagels are made using tangzhong, a Japanese bread-making method that results in soft, fluffy, chewy bagels.

SOURDOUGH

Courage Bagels
... made from dough that has been fermented for 72 hours. This is how the bagels are able to remain so crisp on the outside with a thin, glassine crust while maintaining a soft, chewy interior.

Mustard’s Bagels
... also uses a 72-hour fermented sourdough to make their bagels. Like Courage, there is often a line out the door...

Layla Bagels
Like Courage and Mustard’s, their bagel has a nice chew with a crisp crust.


A STYLE COMPLETELY ITS OWN

Miopane
These bagels are unlike any others in Los Angeles. You can watch bakers pipe thick lines of cream cheese onto different flavors of bagel dough before they roll them up, shape them into rings, and bake them. The result is a fluffy bagel that arrives filled with cream cheese.


NoWorkAllTravel May 5, 2026 7:31 pm

Bagels seem to be a thing in Japan. The last time I tried them there was 2002; no good memories remain.

In addition to random pop-ups and vendors throughout the big cities, I walked by "NEW YORK CLUB THE BAGEL CAFE and BEER STAND" in Tokyo's Akasaka neighborhood. (why beer?) However, given that local bakeries and patisseries do so many other carbs well, I didn't bother giving them a whirl. Their take-out menu also screams SPERAD instead of SPREAD (as in, jams/marmalades), but that's a horse of a different color.

https://cimg8.ibsrv.net/gimg/www.fly...612faf6eb3.jpg

FlyingChuck May 6, 2026 10:50 am


Originally Posted by NoWorkAllTravel (Post 37738796)
Bagels seem to be a thing in Japan. The last time I tried them there was 2002; no good memories remain.

Recently read that it's also a thing in Singapore.

============

Found it (paywalled): https://www.bloomberg.com/news/artic...anese-fillings

gaobest May 11, 2026 10:35 am

Wise Sons had or has a Japan shop for their deli and bagels joy.

I got boichik bagels for Mother’s Day - it was easier to use DoorDash as I had already bought the lox, onion, and tomato at Trader Joe’s on Saturday. Then my family started their bagel joy while I was trying to print documents for my son’s school activity and by the time I came downstairs, they had finished their bagels and lamented that they finished up the single 4-oz package of lox. Oh if only they had looked underneath the lox package and then they’d have seen a bag with two more 4-oz lox packages. As if I’d only have 4 ounces of lox …


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 5:52 am.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.