FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   Delta Air Lines | SkyMiles (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/delta-air-lines-skymiles-665/)
-   -   Guaranteed First Class (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/delta-air-lines-skymiles/1164810-guaranteed-first-class.html)

businesstraveller2 Dec 27, 2010 6:22 pm


Originally Posted by GBadger (Post 15533183)
I agree...
So you're talking about two different groups of people, and that guy could have bought a F ticket on UA just as easily as he did on DL.

I think the issue is getting back to the OP - how they sell the F cabin. UA these days is mostly 1K, 1P etc on UDUs in the F cabin, and paid F. I have not seen much upsell passengers at least based on the lack of cheap upsell tickets on UA and the long list of people waiting for UDUs. Also the conversation around me tends to be suggest there are alot of FFs on upgrades of paid F.
If you read the UDU stats you wil see 1K is about 83% and I believe 1P is over 50% at least for those reporting from flyertalk. They start UDUs for 1Ks at 100 hours out. We are all kind of waiting to see what happens after the merger.

avidflyer Dec 27, 2010 6:22 pm


Originally Posted by businesstraveller2 (Post 15533186)
The forum strikes me as very male and I often get confused for a male because of my forum name.

You would be suprised how many women are on FT. I hate to say this because I am not picking on YOU but an all-too-common line of thinking, but you just did it again. You assume this is a male orientated forum and you have no way of knowing that (except I can tell you I am a male).

GBadger Dec 27, 2010 6:23 pm

Out of my 60+ segments on DL this year, I've seen 1 flight that was offering upsells. And, as indicated below, as a Platinum, I'm 30/50 on upgrades, meaning that on the flights I've been on, the F cabin has been filled mainly with upper level PMs, DMs and paid F.

businesstraveller2 Dec 27, 2010 6:24 pm


Originally Posted by avidflyer (Post 15533236)
You would be suprised how many women are on FT. I hate to say this because I am not picking on YOU but a all-too-common line of thinking, but you just did it again. You assume this is a male orientated forum and you have no way of knowing that (except I can tell you I am a male).

Sorry avid this is experience. A bunch of times I've had FTers write back to me clearly assuming I was male based on the comments - not a stereotype but actual experience. They did apologize however after I explained I was female.

Orange County Commuter Dec 27, 2010 6:28 pm


Originally Posted by jtatlanta (Post 15532603)
Hi all I just found this site and joined. I hope my first post doesn't offend too many........

I am based in Atlanta and fly on average 120k a year with a combination of international (atl-london) and cross country (atl-sea, lax). I have always purchased first class but recently people sitting next to me are telling me to buy the cheapest level tickets and just get easy upgrades (especially internal flights).

My question is related to travel in the US: is there a specifc level flight I can buy to guarantee an upgrade (Y or M) or can I instead just buy a changeable cheaper ticket level and pay to upgrade if an upgrade doesn't come thru in my window (I am PM)? My number one goal is to not play gate roulette or risk getting stuck in economy. I would be happy to risk buying an M or B ticket on every flight and then just pay for an upgrade to FC if I didn't get one for free if its possible.

I am in the lucky position of working for a company that pays for FC so its not my money but am getting fed up with sitting consistantly next to people telling me they have paid squat for their ticket etc. I am beginning to feel like I am being made a fool of by Delta for actually paying for a FC ticket..........

Not sure where you fly.... but.... No, you can't always buy a cheap ticket and pay to upgrade. You can always buy at First Class ticket and get the upgrade, but I fly ATL to the Southern California area two to three times a month and there are NEVER any upgrades for sale on my flights. And as PM flying cheap fares I am less then 50% on the upgrades.

(And my last rude drunk was a reality show "celebrity" who told everyone that "he paid for this seat and could "XXXX" curse if he wanted to and we could "XXXX" off)

avidflyer Dec 27, 2010 6:29 pm


Originally Posted by businesstraveller2 (Post 15533246)
Sorry avid this is experience. A bunch of times I've had FTers write back to me clearly assuming I was male based on the comments - not a stereotype but actual experience. They did apologize however after I explained I was female.


There is a woman here that I know through acquaintance who is always addressed as a male. Most here still thinks she is...there are many of them that I know of. The question is why does it matter? I have worked for women many times over my career and some of the best managers and decision makers I know are women. I am not sure what that matters in travel but I get your point if somebody was rude to you BECAUSE you are a woman.

CJKatl Dec 27, 2010 6:29 pm


Originally Posted by businesstraveller2 (Post 15533246)
Sorry avid this is experience. A bunch of times I've had FTers write back to me clearly assuming I was male based on the comments - not a stereotype but actual experience. They did apologize however after I explained I was female.

The garbage about there being a profile for who should or should not be in F is what I found offensive. People are individuals, not profiles. If you don't see the problem there then I fell very sorry for you. What in the name of all that is good this has to do with whether you are male or female confounds me. What any of that had to do with DL, as opposed to UA, is even more confusing.

avidflyer - thanks for sharing the great story!

businesstraveller2 Dec 27, 2010 6:39 pm


Originally Posted by avidflyer (Post 15533270)
I am not sure what that matters in travel but I get your point if somebody was rude to you BECAUSE you are a woman.

Yes that was precisely what happened. The language he was using was definitively directed at the two of us a women in a very derogatory way. Sorry about all the confusion! We should get back to OP I never meant to hijack or offend. I did not think that it was offensive to say that drunk swearing rude passengers were not the F profile. Nothing about social economic class in fact the guy looked rather well off if you ask me. He was well-dressed and wearing a suit it was his actions that were the problem. So by "F profile" I was thinking non-swearing, non-rude and non-offensive but apparently it did not come across that way earlier in the thread.
Again apologies all around if you were offended by my comments in ways I did not mean them. FWIW I am often not fitting the "F cabin" stereotype in terms of dress etc and would never think of that as an issue.

jtatlanta Dec 27, 2010 8:48 pm


Originally Posted by OrangeCountyCommuter (Post 15533264)
Not sure where you fly.... but.... No, you can't always buy a cheap ticket and pay to upgrade. You can always buy at First Class ticket and get the upgrade, but I fly ATL to the Southern California area two to three times a month and there are NEVER any upgrades for sale on my flights. And as PM flying cheap fares I am less then 50% on the upgrades.

(And my last rude drunk was a reality show "celebrity" who told everyone that "he paid for this seat and could "XXXX" curse if he wanted to and we could "XXXX" off)

Often I change flight date last minute on ATL-SEA and ATL-LAX. I guess my question is for example:

Normal FC ATL-SEA is $1400, B ticket is $800, if at the 5 day window I don't get an upgrade I can then just go online and change B ticket to another flight the same day as FC and pay the $600 difference. This would seem to be a way to take the risk out if I don't get an upgrade.

I guess I could also start to use some SWU if they would work.

avidflyer Dec 27, 2010 8:53 pm


Originally Posted by jtatlanta (Post 15533928)
I guess I could also start to use some SWU if they would work.

They do and they are very easy. I have used a few domestically and it has never been a problem.

Spicy B Dec 27, 2010 9:09 pm

OP: Don't forget, if you start buying B & M fares, that 50% MQM Class of Service bonus would probably bump you over to DM, thus increasing your chances later of an UG from lower fares.

BonzoESC Dec 27, 2010 10:35 pm


Originally Posted by Spicy B (Post 15534040)
OP: Don't forget, if you start buying B & M fares, that 50% MQM Class of Service bonus would probably bump you over to DM, thus increasing your chances later of an UG from lower fares.

It's such a game though; do I pay the premium for guaranteed first-class cabin, or risk the uncomfortable cabin for short people?

eheinz Dec 27, 2010 11:23 pm


Originally Posted by jtatlanta (Post 15532713)
I am lucky as my company goes on trust (very old fashioned no receipts)....

That's very nice for you, but your company should be aware that the IRS does not go on trust and so it will need receipts to substantiate those business expenses! ;)

Anyway, if you fly BIS 120k a year, then I would start out with a status match to DL (if you're not already there; sorry I can't see your profile there), maybe buy some A tickets at first but once you reach DM (which you should be able to do BIS based on occasional premium fare purchases), most of the time you should buy the cheapest available coach fare or at least something fairly cheap like a K. That should net you >95% upgrades if you also invest in a tool like expertflyer or KVS to give you a sense of how wide open F is when you buy your ticket. Obviously on DM-heavy routes like long-hauls out of ATL or JFK to SFO/LAX you may not want to risk it and instead buy first outright. But most of the time on a T fare as a DM you'll snag the upgrade.

Klm is Dead - Long Live KLM Dec 27, 2010 11:50 pm


Originally Posted by avidflyer (Post 15533041)
I gotta tell ya, reading your post makes me think you are NOT a frequent flyer. "The profile" ...huh? You may not think I fit "the profile" but I fly 200+k a year and am a senior executive with a large company.

One of my best encounters was a while back on a transcon. I was in 1B and two DYKWIA's were in 2A/B blathering on about how much they spend to sit up front, how big the deal they are GOING to close is, how they cannot be productive if they are not comfy, and how free upgrades are degrading the service...blah, blah, blahditty blah. I had to have a look at these DB's because they were loud and obnoxious so coming back from the lav I did. They gave me a look as if to say "you are not in our league”. I am relatively young, I travel in nice cloths but not suits. Anyone who flies every week and is not going straight to a meeting knows that there is no reason to over dress for a flight unless you have to. That apparently was enough for them to think I do not fit “the profile”. Fast forward to the next day. I have several providers coming in to see me for the final round of an RFQ worth $25 Million USD. 6 finalists….GUESS WHO WALKS IN. They saw me, they knew it (though they pretended they did not) and they felt like crap. It was all over their faces the entire 5 HOUR meeting. As it turns out they lost based on other factors because I would never let something like that impact how I manage my companies business…but I guarantee you these guys do not “profile” anyone any longer.

There is no “profile”. There are only over active egos who think there is.

One of the best posts I have read on FT for quite some time. ^
Thanks for sharing!

CJKatl Dec 28, 2010 12:05 am


Originally Posted by eheinz (Post 15534488)
That's very nice for you, but your company should be aware that the IRS does not go on trust and so it will need receipts to substantiate those business expenses! ;)

I work for a very large company. (Fortune 100) We also do not need to provide receipts for airline travel, nor do we need receipts for any expense below $100, provided the expenses are charged to our corporate credit cards. Any cash expense over $20 requires a receipt, and all hotel stays require receipts. It makes expense reporting quite easy.

Once every few years, a couple of my expense reports are audited to ensure compliance with corporate standards. There are also certain expenses that will flag an automatic audit and/or higher level approval, including any airfare over $500 o/w or $800 r/t. None of my expenses have ever been questioned, although I respect the trust and always follow our purchasing guidelines.

While I don't know the accounting end, so I don't know how they would substantiate the expenses, somehow they do.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 4:27 am.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.