Best Cruise?
Apr 15, 2007 | 10:30 pm
#1
Original Poster
Join Date: Sep 2006
Programs: Starwood Platinum, AAdvantage, Northwest, Continental
Posts: 102
Best Cruise?
My wife has been on a cruise before! I have not.
She really wants to go on another one, does anyone have recommendations for the best cruise line and if it is really worth it?
I am more of a hotel, explore one destination kind of person.
She really wants to go on another one, does anyone have recommendations for the best cruise line and if it is really worth it?
I am more of a hotel, explore one destination kind of person.
Apr 16, 2007 | 3:12 am
#2
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: San Diego, CA
Programs: Delta SkyMiles Gold, Hilton HHonors Diamond, and Royal Caribbean Pinnacle Club
Posts: 1,009
There is no one "Best" cruise. It all depends on what YOU and YOUR WIFE want out of a vacation. Modern cruise ships are a destination in itself so think of it as your one destination that just so happen visit other places too.
If you want a great bargain, I would consider Royal Caribbean or Carnival. They are both GREAT cruise lines for the price you are paying. You may hear people bash one cruise line over the other but what it comes down to is both are really great and have a slightly different focus.... for example, the food and entertainment on Carnival is alot better than that on Royal Caribbean but on the flip side, Royal Caribbean is for the more active type as it have way more activities. The two lines are GREAT for first time cruisers as they have all the basic cruise ship offerings but offers a bit more at a great price. I think Royal Caribbean and Carnival are both great starter cruises. Just watch out and try and stay away from older ships as they do not have as much as the amenities offered on newer ships. If cabin size is important, go with Carnival as they do offer larger cabins for about the same price.
If you want to spend alittle more and go a bit more upscale, I would recommend Celebrity or Princess... Celebrity is owned by Royal Caribbean and Princess is owned by Carnival... both offer everything Carnival and Royal Caribbean offers but alittle bit more upscale.
If you want freedom to do what ever you want and stray away from tradation, there is always Noreweigin Cruise Line which specialize in "Freestyle" Cruising which allow guest to do what ever they want when ever they want. (well, not really, but more freedom than other cruise lines.)
If you want to be a bit more traditional for your cruise and visit exotic places, I would recommend Holland America and Cunard (both are owned by Carnival).
If you want the up most luxury, theres always seabourne and silversea along with other ultra luxury cruise lines.
Basically, what I am getting at is what is best for you WILL NOT BE the best for me, your friend, your neighbor, etc... There is no one unversal answer to what is the best cruise line out there, they are all best in what they cater in and every cruise line cater to different type of people. What I tell my friends when they want to go on a cruise is to list off everything they want to do on their vacation and than find out what cruise line matches the most of those, if not all.
If you need any advice, I would recommend visiting CruiseCritic.com.. its like FlyerTalk but for frequent cruisers. Just be aware that on their messageboard, everyone tend to defend the cruise line they are loyal too and bash those they prob never even been on. If you do visit cruise critic, just go in with an open mind and try and find something that both you and your wife will enjoy.
If you want a great bargain, I would consider Royal Caribbean or Carnival. They are both GREAT cruise lines for the price you are paying. You may hear people bash one cruise line over the other but what it comes down to is both are really great and have a slightly different focus.... for example, the food and entertainment on Carnival is alot better than that on Royal Caribbean but on the flip side, Royal Caribbean is for the more active type as it have way more activities. The two lines are GREAT for first time cruisers as they have all the basic cruise ship offerings but offers a bit more at a great price. I think Royal Caribbean and Carnival are both great starter cruises. Just watch out and try and stay away from older ships as they do not have as much as the amenities offered on newer ships. If cabin size is important, go with Carnival as they do offer larger cabins for about the same price.
If you want to spend alittle more and go a bit more upscale, I would recommend Celebrity or Princess... Celebrity is owned by Royal Caribbean and Princess is owned by Carnival... both offer everything Carnival and Royal Caribbean offers but alittle bit more upscale.
If you want freedom to do what ever you want and stray away from tradation, there is always Noreweigin Cruise Line which specialize in "Freestyle" Cruising which allow guest to do what ever they want when ever they want. (well, not really, but more freedom than other cruise lines.)
If you want to be a bit more traditional for your cruise and visit exotic places, I would recommend Holland America and Cunard (both are owned by Carnival).
If you want the up most luxury, theres always seabourne and silversea along with other ultra luxury cruise lines.
Basically, what I am getting at is what is best for you WILL NOT BE the best for me, your friend, your neighbor, etc... There is no one unversal answer to what is the best cruise line out there, they are all best in what they cater in and every cruise line cater to different type of people. What I tell my friends when they want to go on a cruise is to list off everything they want to do on their vacation and than find out what cruise line matches the most of those, if not all.
If you need any advice, I would recommend visiting CruiseCritic.com.. its like FlyerTalk but for frequent cruisers. Just be aware that on their messageboard, everyone tend to defend the cruise line they are loyal too and bash those they prob never even been on. If you do visit cruise critic, just go in with an open mind and try and find something that both you and your wife will enjoy.
Apr 16, 2007 | 3:18 am
#3
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: San Diego, CA
Programs: Delta SkyMiles Gold, Hilton HHonors Diamond, and Royal Caribbean Pinnacle Club
Posts: 1,009
Oh yeah, looks like you list Starwood as the perfer hotel program... based on that alone, I would recommend Celebrity Cruise Lines. 
Apr 16, 2007 | 8:57 am
#5
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: MSP (and will only fly NWA in re-routes if I HAVE to)
Programs: AA EXP (4.5MM), hotel programs as needed
Posts: 5,800
There is a forum (like FT) called www.CruiseCritic.com that can answer a lot of questions and provide similar help .. but specifically for cruises.
They are broken down by cruise line and also have general 'informational' forums.
I cruise Princess and Cunard and am trying Avalon Waterways this summer ... and have found LOADS of information on cruisecritic.
Start looking there!
They are broken down by cruise line and also have general 'informational' forums.
I cruise Princess and Cunard and am trying Avalon Waterways this summer ... and have found LOADS of information on cruisecritic.
Start looking there!
Apr 26, 2007 | 8:21 pm
#6
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: Idaho
Programs: Alaska MVP
Posts: 144
The one cruise we thought we would like the least became our favorite, ALASKA. We felt like we were the only ones on board sometimes because everyone else on the boat was so old and didn't move around much. Shore excursions were a breeze to do on your own.
Apr 30, 2007 | 7:35 pm
#7
Join Date: Jul 2006
Programs: Marriott: Platinum, AAdvantage: Gold
Posts: 99
There is a forum (like FT) called www.CruiseCritic.com that can answer a lot of questions and provide similar help .. but specifically for cruises.
They are broken down by cruise line and also have general 'informational' forums.
I cruise Princess and Cunard and am trying Avalon Waterways this summer ... and have found LOADS of information on cruisecritic.
Start looking there!
They are broken down by cruise line and also have general 'informational' forums.
I cruise Princess and Cunard and am trying Avalon Waterways this summer ... and have found LOADS of information on cruisecritic.
Start looking there!
May 11, 2007 | 12:51 pm
#8
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: NY
Programs: AA, US, DL, UA, Marriott Silver, Hilton Silver
Posts: 960
Definitely check with Cruisecritic. You will find all the information you need.
Its funny how the poster above listed Royal Caribbean and Carnival together, saying Carnival has better food. Shows how subjective it can be because I'd never sale Carnival and the food is one reason. RCCL is much better, but thats just my opinion.
Celebrity is my line of choice but it may not be a great fit for someone who prefers the Carnival experience. Only by reading up as much as you can will you be able to find the "best" cruise for you!
Its funny how the poster above listed Royal Caribbean and Carnival together, saying Carnival has better food. Shows how subjective it can be because I'd never sale Carnival and the food is one reason. RCCL is much better, but thats just my opinion.
Celebrity is my line of choice but it may not be a great fit for someone who prefers the Carnival experience. Only by reading up as much as you can will you be able to find the "best" cruise for you!