Some Notes RE: DL/CO and the Future of OnePass
#1
Original Poster
Suspended
Join Date: Apr 1999
Location: Promoted to Chairman of the Most Wonderful Continental Airlines Highly Valuable OnePass Program Security and Ideological Purity Bureau
Posts: 4,129
Some Notes RE: DL/CO and the Future of OnePass
Yesterday, I had the opportunity to speak at length with a representative of the OPSC regarding the DL/CO alliance. Here's the info. that I was given:
1. Delta segments will NOT count towards elite status, as CO/NW segments currently do.
2. COers will earn 100% actual mileage for all Delta flights.
3. Flights taken on Delta L/U/T fares will be credited at 50% in regards to Elite qualification miles.
4. Delta flights booked in full Y/F will be credited at over 100% in regards to Elite qualification miles.
5. Gold/Platinum Elites will receive a 100% Elite bonus on Delta flights, whereas Silver Elites will receive 25%.
The agent also dropped a few hints on what aspects of the Elite program might change starting either on 01/01/04 or the 2004 Elite year(03/01/04):
1. Elite upgrades on the lowest CO/NW fares (i.e., the fares currently non-UGable by non-Elites) will be upgradeable on the DAY OF DEPARTURE only. EUA will only run for fares above a certain level; everyone else must take their chances at the airport.
2. CO will institute an Elite qualification scheme that is a combination between the NW and DL programs. Qualification will be based on either miles traveled x fare multiplier or segments flown in higher fare classes.
3. Unlimited upgrades WILL continue, at all fare levels. The agent had no comment as to whether they will be complimentary at all fares, however.
------------------
Thank you for choosing Continental Airlines, a proud member of the SkyTeam Alliance.
[This message has been edited by avek00 (edited 05-14-2003).]
1. Delta segments will NOT count towards elite status, as CO/NW segments currently do.
2. COers will earn 100% actual mileage for all Delta flights.
3. Flights taken on Delta L/U/T fares will be credited at 50% in regards to Elite qualification miles.
4. Delta flights booked in full Y/F will be credited at over 100% in regards to Elite qualification miles.
5. Gold/Platinum Elites will receive a 100% Elite bonus on Delta flights, whereas Silver Elites will receive 25%.
The agent also dropped a few hints on what aspects of the Elite program might change starting either on 01/01/04 or the 2004 Elite year(03/01/04):
1. Elite upgrades on the lowest CO/NW fares (i.e., the fares currently non-UGable by non-Elites) will be upgradeable on the DAY OF DEPARTURE only. EUA will only run for fares above a certain level; everyone else must take their chances at the airport.
2. CO will institute an Elite qualification scheme that is a combination between the NW and DL programs. Qualification will be based on either miles traveled x fare multiplier or segments flown in higher fare classes.
3. Unlimited upgrades WILL continue, at all fare levels. The agent had no comment as to whether they will be complimentary at all fares, however.
------------------
Thank you for choosing Continental Airlines, a proud member of the SkyTeam Alliance.
[This message has been edited by avek00 (edited 05-14-2003).]
#2
Join Date: Jul 2002
Posts: 242

Well, I guess if lower fares aren't going to be EUA-able, this time it works to my advantage that I live in a market where I can't get lower than a V to most places....
[This message has been edited by platflyer (edited 05-14-2003).]
#3


Join Date: May 2002
Location: Moreland Hills (CLE)
Programs: Over-entitled UA 1.3MM Gold, AA Gold, Hilton Diamond, Marriott L-T Plat, Hertz PC
Posts: 5,526
<font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">Originally posted by avek00:
The agent also dropped a few hints on what aspects of the Elite program might change starting either on 01/01/04 or the 2004 Elite year(03/01/04):
1. Elite upgrades on the lowest CO/NW fares (i.e., the fares currently non-UGable by non-Elites) will be upgradeable on the DAY OF DEPARTURE only. EUA will only run for fares above a certain level; everyone else must take their chances at the airport.
2. CO will institute an Elite qualification scheme that is a combination between the NW and DL programs. Qualification will be based on either miles traveled x fare multiplier or segments flown in higher fare classes.
3. Unlimited upgrades WILL continue, at all fare levels. The agent had no comment as to whether they will be complimentary at all fares, however.</font>
The agent also dropped a few hints on what aspects of the Elite program might change starting either on 01/01/04 or the 2004 Elite year(03/01/04):
1. Elite upgrades on the lowest CO/NW fares (i.e., the fares currently non-UGable by non-Elites) will be upgradeable on the DAY OF DEPARTURE only. EUA will only run for fares above a certain level; everyone else must take their chances at the airport.
2. CO will institute an Elite qualification scheme that is a combination between the NW and DL programs. Qualification will be based on either miles traveled x fare multiplier or segments flown in higher fare classes.
3. Unlimited upgrades WILL continue, at all fare levels. The agent had no comment as to whether they will be complimentary at all fares, however.</font>
The actual miles are almost worthless, it's the status that's important.
So far this year I've flown 38 segments netting only 24,712 miles. This came from 11 itineraries. The highest fare was $406 and the average is $221.
Last year I made gold with 66 segments and 36,658 miles. (Included 2 8-segment runs from CLE to BNA on NW. Each cost less than $150.)
------------------
CO treats me like a king, Rodney King
#4
A FlyerTalk Posting Legend




Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: LAX/TPE
Programs: United 1K, JAL Sapphire, SPG Lifetime Platinum, National Executive Elite, Hertz PC, Avis PC
Posts: 47,205
<font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">Originally posted by avek00:
Yesterday, I had the opportunity to speak at length with a representative of the OPSC regarding the DL/CO alliance. Here's the info. that I was given:
no disrespect intended, but it is hard to believe that an agent, or even a manager knows what changes are coming for the OP program...probably only the most senior marketing managers have any idea how they will change the program this far ahead, and what those changes will be. I would give little thought to what this customer service person is speculating.
1. Delta segments will NOT count towards elite status, as CO/NW segments currently do.
I think that is speculation, but possible, since DL no longer counts segments for its own poor program.
2. COers will earn 100% actual mileage for all Delta flights.
of course they would, or there would be absolutely zero incentive to fly DL and sit in their third-world coach cabin
3. Flights taken on Delta L/U/T fares will be credited at 50% in regards to Elite qualification miles.
speculation, but probable.
4. Delta flights booked in full Y/F will be credited at over 100% in regards to Elite qualification miles.
speculation but possible, certainly for paid "F"...but for paid "Y"? not sure about that
5. Gold/Platinum Elites will receive a 100% Elite bonus on Delta flights, whereas Silver Elites will receive 25%.
speculation; if my bonus on DL is only 100%, why should I fly on them, when I can earn 125% on CO/NW as a Platinum,?
The agent also dropped a few hints on what aspects of the Elite program might change starting either on 01/01/04 or the 2004 Elite year(03/01/04):
1. Elite upgrades on the lowest CO/NW fares (i.e., the fares currently non-UGable by non-Elites) will be upgradeable on the DAY OF DEPARTURE only. EUA will only run for fares above a certain level; everyone else must take their chances at the airport.
Pure speculation!! The only possible way I see this happening is for Silver Elites on the lowest fares only...this would drive a huge amount of business away, if it was brought on Golds and Platinums. The lowest non-QT fare in my flying markets is $400++! I am NOT going to pay $400 to get a CHANCE at an EUA upgrade, where I can pay "K" class on DL if the Platinum benefits are restored over there, and upgrade at booking for $240...or, I can pay $200 and fly on AA and buy u/g stickets for another $100. This would be a DUMB move.
2. CO will institute an Elite qualification scheme that is a combination between the NW and DL programs. Qualification will be based on either miles traveled x fare multiplier or segments flown in higher fare classes.
Given the uproar at DL resulting from their Skymiles elite qualification "scheme" (or scam), I find it highly unlikely that CO would roll out such a dumb idea after watching the fallout at DL, and given that business is starting to firm up. I also dont see NW going along with any of these program changes listed.
3. Unlimited upgrades WILL continue, at all fare levels. The agent had no comment as to whether they will be complimentary at all fares, however.
more speculation
[/B]</font>
Yesterday, I had the opportunity to speak at length with a representative of the OPSC regarding the DL/CO alliance. Here's the info. that I was given:
no disrespect intended, but it is hard to believe that an agent, or even a manager knows what changes are coming for the OP program...probably only the most senior marketing managers have any idea how they will change the program this far ahead, and what those changes will be. I would give little thought to what this customer service person is speculating.
1. Delta segments will NOT count towards elite status, as CO/NW segments currently do.
I think that is speculation, but possible, since DL no longer counts segments for its own poor program.
2. COers will earn 100% actual mileage for all Delta flights.
of course they would, or there would be absolutely zero incentive to fly DL and sit in their third-world coach cabin
3. Flights taken on Delta L/U/T fares will be credited at 50% in regards to Elite qualification miles.
speculation, but probable.
4. Delta flights booked in full Y/F will be credited at over 100% in regards to Elite qualification miles.
speculation but possible, certainly for paid "F"...but for paid "Y"? not sure about that
5. Gold/Platinum Elites will receive a 100% Elite bonus on Delta flights, whereas Silver Elites will receive 25%.
speculation; if my bonus on DL is only 100%, why should I fly on them, when I can earn 125% on CO/NW as a Platinum,?
The agent also dropped a few hints on what aspects of the Elite program might change starting either on 01/01/04 or the 2004 Elite year(03/01/04):
1. Elite upgrades on the lowest CO/NW fares (i.e., the fares currently non-UGable by non-Elites) will be upgradeable on the DAY OF DEPARTURE only. EUA will only run for fares above a certain level; everyone else must take their chances at the airport.
Pure speculation!! The only possible way I see this happening is for Silver Elites on the lowest fares only...this would drive a huge amount of business away, if it was brought on Golds and Platinums. The lowest non-QT fare in my flying markets is $400++! I am NOT going to pay $400 to get a CHANCE at an EUA upgrade, where I can pay "K" class on DL if the Platinum benefits are restored over there, and upgrade at booking for $240...or, I can pay $200 and fly on AA and buy u/g stickets for another $100. This would be a DUMB move.
2. CO will institute an Elite qualification scheme that is a combination between the NW and DL programs. Qualification will be based on either miles traveled x fare multiplier or segments flown in higher fare classes.
Given the uproar at DL resulting from their Skymiles elite qualification "scheme" (or scam), I find it highly unlikely that CO would roll out such a dumb idea after watching the fallout at DL, and given that business is starting to firm up. I also dont see NW going along with any of these program changes listed.
3. Unlimited upgrades WILL continue, at all fare levels. The agent had no comment as to whether they will be complimentary at all fares, however.
more speculation
[/B]</font>
Let's not all get too bent out of shape on this topic until there is some real confirmation from a source in a very senior position. As business is starting to firm up, I dont see any incentive for CO to reduce the benefits in their program. It would be extremely stupid.
[This message has been edited by bocastephen (edited 05-14-2003).]
#5
Original Poster
Suspended
Join Date: Apr 1999
Location: Promoted to Chairman of the Most Wonderful Continental Airlines Highly Valuable OnePass Program Security and Ideological Purity Bureau
Posts: 4,129
1. The fact that an agent knows about some of the possible changes tells me that CO will likely implement at least a couple of the enhancements.
2. RE: Skymiles-like changes, I wouldn't put too much stock in the belief that some disgruntled FlyerTalkers are representative of the SkyMiles Medallion membership.
------------------
Thank you for choosing Continental Airlines, a proud member of the SkyTeam Alliance.
2. RE: Skymiles-like changes, I wouldn't put too much stock in the belief that some disgruntled FlyerTalkers are representative of the SkyMiles Medallion membership.
------------------
Thank you for choosing Continental Airlines, a proud member of the SkyTeam Alliance.
#6
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Durham, NC USA
Posts: 9
Wow, I WAS (past tense) actually excited about the CO/DL alliance. I moved (Jan 1) from DL to CO. I agree with the previous post it is the status (segments, etc) that matters NOT the miles.
Note to CO: Please listen to customers and don't follow the bad parts of the DL FF program.
Note to CO: Please listen to customers and don't follow the bad parts of the DL FF program.
#7
Join Date: Dec 1999
Location: Northeast MA, USA.
Programs: HHonors Diamond, DL Silver, TSA Harassee
Posts: 3,657
The first half about the DL Code-Share is more than likely accurate. It mirrors what a RELIABLE source at NW indicated.
The second half about next years program is PURE SPECULATION. There is NO WAY that a OPSC Representative knows what the changes are going to be for next years program.
The second half about next years program is PURE SPECULATION. There is NO WAY that a OPSC Representative knows what the changes are going to be for next years program.
#8
Join Date: Aug 2002
Location: SJC
Programs: AA EXP
Posts: 3,686
Sadly, I tend to believe that most all of this would be true, primarily because the CO belief system (as professed, for example, by Gordon Bethune's comments about "(paraphrase)if people need to get from EWR to SFO, they'll pay whatever it takes..."
Summed up, it's the "what have you done for me lately?" method of managing customer loyalty -- in other words, you don't believe that customer loyalty is a significant issue. Which works if you've got either a product people can't live without, or a total stranglehold.
Truth is, CO doesn't really have either. And with the barriers to entry so low in the airline business right now, what little they have can be eroded as fast as billboards can go up and commercials aired on television.
It's been said that the loss of a major airline would be good for the industry as a whole. I salute CO for stepping forth to accept that role
Steve
[This message has been edited by sllevin (edited 05-14-2003).]
Summed up, it's the "what have you done for me lately?" method of managing customer loyalty -- in other words, you don't believe that customer loyalty is a significant issue. Which works if you've got either a product people can't live without, or a total stranglehold.
Truth is, CO doesn't really have either. And with the barriers to entry so low in the airline business right now, what little they have can be eroded as fast as billboards can go up and commercials aired on television.
It's been said that the loss of a major airline would be good for the industry as a whole. I salute CO for stepping forth to accept that role

Steve
[This message has been edited by sllevin (edited 05-14-2003).]
#9
Original Poster
Suspended
Join Date: Apr 1999
Location: Promoted to Chairman of the Most Wonderful Continental Airlines Highly Valuable OnePass Program Security and Ideological Purity Bureau
Posts: 4,129
<font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">Originally posted by CameraGuy:
The first half about the DL Code-Share is more than likely accurate. It mirrors what a RELIABLE source at NW indicated.
The second half about next years program is PURE SPECULATION. There is NO WAY that a OPSC Representative knows what the changes are going to be for next years program.</font>
The first half about the DL Code-Share is more than likely accurate. It mirrors what a RELIABLE source at NW indicated.
The second half about next years program is PURE SPECULATION. There is NO WAY that a OPSC Representative knows what the changes are going to be for next years program.</font>
Though the OPSC rep. said that the possible changes to the program are by no means final, it would make sense for the reps. to be somewhat informed about them now, as CO would (hopefully) give plenty of advance notice about such sweeping program modifications.
------------------
Thank you for choosing Continental Airlines, a proud member of the SkyTeam Alliance.
[This message has been edited by avek00 (edited 05-14-2003).]
#10
A FlyerTalk Posting Legend




Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: LAX/TPE
Programs: United 1K, JAL Sapphire, SPG Lifetime Platinum, National Executive Elite, Hertz PC, Avis PC
Posts: 47,205
I hope they give plenty of advance notice on the changes, so I can schedule my AA Platinum Challenge
#11
Join Date: Jul 2000
Location: Commuting around the mid-atlantic and rust-belt on any number of RJs
Programs: TSA Random Selectee Platinum, * Gold, SPG/HH/MR mid-tier, and a tiny bag of pretzels.
Posts: 9,255
<font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">Originally posted by avek00:
Though the OPSC rep. said that the possible changes to the program are by no means final, it would make sense for the reps. to be somewhat informed about them now, as CO would (hopefully) give plenty of advance notice about such sweeping program modifications.</font>
Though the OPSC rep. said that the possible changes to the program are by no means final, it would make sense for the reps. to be somewhat informed about them now, as CO would (hopefully) give plenty of advance notice about such sweeping program modifications.</font>
CO, like all other airlines, has to throw this stuff out at point which will afford the least amount of disgruntled folks the smallest window to react to the changes (Eg, pissing off corporate contract customers, and the like).
------------------
Saving the world, one clue at a time.
#12
Suspended
Join Date: Dec 2001
Location: new york, ny, usa
Posts: 13,536
<font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">Originally posted by PalmFLYING:
Note to CO: Please listen to customers </font>
Note to CO: Please listen to customers </font>
#13
Join Date: Nov 2001
Location: IAH
Programs: CO Plat. SPG Plat
Posts: 179
IMHO, the only significant aspect of CO's program that sets it apart is its RELATIVELY generous Elite upgrade policies. If they slice this as stated above, then in my mind OP will have no distinquishing advantages for me.
If they largely deny the front cabin to Elite's who don't pay F or Y, they better compete fare-wise with WN and AT every day, in every direct and indirect market.
If they largely deny the front cabin to Elite's who don't pay F or Y, they better compete fare-wise with WN and AT every day, in every direct and indirect market.
#14

Join Date: Mar 2001
Location: Sugar Land, Tx
Posts: 518
After a gradual increase over the last five years to plat the last two years I didn't achieve any status for this year. CO comped me to silver unasked for this year. With these possible changes they have no chance of me requalifying for next year.
#15


Join Date: May 2001
Location: IAD
Posts: 6,453
<font face="Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="2">Originally posted by iah-plat:
If they largely deny the front cabin to Elite's who don't pay F or Y, they better compete fare-wise with WN and AT every day, in every direct and indirect market.</font>
If they largely deny the front cabin to Elite's who don't pay F or Y, they better compete fare-wise with WN and AT every day, in every direct and indirect market.</font>
AT= Royal Air Maroc (who btw have decent F/J fares)
Air Tran is FL
ATA is TZ

