Another first-timer to China (PEK)
#16
FlyerTalk Evangelist



Join Date: Jun 2005
Posts: 38,543
Since Chinese people, as a rule, can't read maps (no idea why), I find showing a map to someone to ask the way fairly useless -- I tried several times my first couple of visits. However, I do agree with the passenger knowing the way being really useful. If one has an android phone, pre-loading an off-line map, with places of interest marked is absolutely invaluable, and doesn't require a data plan.
tb
tb
#17
Ambassador: China
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Malibu Inferno Ground Zero
Programs: UA AA CO
Posts: 4,836
Peter Hesslers "Country Driving"
Chinese Cant Read Maps
These early Chinese maps were well drawn, but the fundamental approach was narrowly practical rather than scientific. They relied heavily on words rather than symbols. Landscapes were warped to emphasize whatever happened to be of prime interest.
It wasnt surprising that rural people had little understanding of maps, but this was also true for educated Chinese. Even professional drivers with years of experience could be hopelessly confused by a simple atlas. Maps simply arent part of modern culture, despite the fact that the Chinese have an impressive ancient history of cartography.
In China, its not such a terrible thing to be lost, because nobody else knows exactly where theyre going, either.
http://stibrigade.blogspot.com/2011/...s-on-maps.html
Chinese Cant Read Maps
These early Chinese maps were well drawn, but the fundamental approach was narrowly practical rather than scientific. They relied heavily on words rather than symbols. Landscapes were warped to emphasize whatever happened to be of prime interest.
It wasnt surprising that rural people had little understanding of maps, but this was also true for educated Chinese. Even professional drivers with years of experience could be hopelessly confused by a simple atlas. Maps simply arent part of modern culture, despite the fact that the Chinese have an impressive ancient history of cartography.
In China, its not such a terrible thing to be lost, because nobody else knows exactly where theyre going, either.
http://stibrigade.blogspot.com/2011/...s-on-maps.html
#19
FlyerTalk Evangelist



Join Date: Jun 2005
Posts: 38,543
#20
A FlyerTalk Posting Legend




Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: Shanghai
Posts: 46,306
Back on topic, when I made the map suggestion earlier in this thread, I had already considered the counterargument that gave rise to our current tangent (which I knew was bound to occur). Basically, if you have a map with your destination circled, even if the driver doesn't know how to get there based on the map, he should at least recognize the name of the locale... no different than the name of a hotel written on a business card.
#23



Join Date: May 2009
Location: Washington, DC
Programs: UA Plat & 1MM, AA, DL
Posts: 8,687
One would think . . . .although I have had more trouble providing a map with the destination clearly named than a simple card. It's as if the map confuses anything else printed on the page.
#24


Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Bay Area
Programs: BA - Blue
Posts: 4,720
Agree that we should try to veer back on-topic.
However, OP has not returned to thread, and is probably steeling himself for the journey ahead -- it's possible the routing was to ensure making EXP for 2012 -- a sort of MR with holiday tagged on. Having just done a mammoth work trip myself, which involved an even longer routing (but unavoidable in my case, unlike the OP), I can understand why...
Hope they managed to glean something useful from the thread: if nothing else, that China is not a scary place to be: yes, it can be disorientating to be illiterate again with some signs/menus etc, but for the tourist trail (and in general!), it's pretty visitor friendly.
tb
However, OP has not returned to thread, and is probably steeling himself for the journey ahead -- it's possible the routing was to ensure making EXP for 2012 -- a sort of MR with holiday tagged on. Having just done a mammoth work trip myself, which involved an even longer routing (but unavoidable in my case, unlike the OP), I can understand why...
Hope they managed to glean something useful from the thread: if nothing else, that China is not a scary place to be: yes, it can be disorientating to be illiterate again with some signs/menus etc, but for the tourist trail (and in general!), it's pretty visitor friendly.
tb
#25
Original Poster
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: GSO
Programs: AA-PLT/Lifetime
Posts: 1,187
Agree that we should try to veer back on-topic.
However, OP has not returned to thread, and is probably steeling himself for the journey ahead -- it's possible the routing was to ensure making EXP for 2012 -- a sort of MR with holiday tagged on. Having just done a mammoth work trip myself, which involved an even longer routing (but unavoidable in my case, unlike the OP), I can understand why...
Hope they managed to glean something useful from the thread: if nothing else, that China is not a scary place to be: yes, it can be disorientating to be illiterate again with some signs/menus etc, but for the tourist trail (and in general!), it's pretty visitor friendly.
tb
However, OP has not returned to thread, and is probably steeling himself for the journey ahead -- it's possible the routing was to ensure making EXP for 2012 -- a sort of MR with holiday tagged on. Having just done a mammoth work trip myself, which involved an even longer routing (but unavoidable in my case, unlike the OP), I can understand why...
Hope they managed to glean something useful from the thread: if nothing else, that China is not a scary place to be: yes, it can be disorientating to be illiterate again with some signs/menus etc, but for the tourist trail (and in general!), it's pretty visitor friendly.
tb
As far as the routing, well, I realize it's pretty insane. As a PLT flyer, I'm unable to earn SWUs and so, when I hit 2MM and received four of them, I decided I was going to get as much mileage (literally and figuratively) out of them as possible before their Feb. 2013 expiration.
The routing was the best we could get from FRA to PEK on AA metal. Except for the TATL segments for which we're still on the upgrade list, we're flying in F, something else I rarely get to enjoy when flying TATL.
Yes, we're spending beaucoup bucks for those free SWUs but, given our jobs and family situations, we don't think there will be another opportunity to visit China in the foreseeable future.
Unfortunately, with return flights scheduled for the next calendar year, my wife and I are unable to gain status as trueblu thought might be the case.
The thread has provided useful information and, for that, I'm very appreciative. I have a few additional questions as well as responses/clarifications that I'll make in separate replies.
Thank you all.
#26
Original Poster
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: GSO
Programs: AA-PLT/Lifetime
Posts: 1,187
On what -- for lack of a better word -- evidence, does she base this assumption? I honestly feel more at ease in China than any other country in the world. Granted, I speak the language and have spent 10+ years in country, but I host guests from abroad all the time, and have never heard a single complaint. Believe it or not, people born after 1980 who live in BJ, SH, and even Xi'an tend to speak decent English, pretty much as a rule... especially true for the well dressed set, which is easy to spot.
If you've read many of my other posts related to this topic, you'll know I feel about guided tours both in general, and with respect to the sites you've mentioned. But, I hate beating a dead horse.
Insofar as your side trip is concerned, check out the XIY airport wiki in order to get a feel for what's out there:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xi'an_X...tional_Airport
Basically, you can get from almost all of those cities back to Beijing, so XIY is your limiting factor (assuming you don't scrap Xi'an from your plans, of course). Bangkok could be a decent bet; just don't try to cram too much in because it would be a shame if 6 of your 13 days were spent in airports and on airplanes.
If you've read many of my other posts related to this topic, you'll know I feel about guided tours both in general, and with respect to the sites you've mentioned. But, I hate beating a dead horse.
Insofar as your side trip is concerned, check out the XIY airport wiki in order to get a feel for what's out there:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xi'an_X...tional_Airport
Basically, you can get from almost all of those cities back to Beijing, so XIY is your limiting factor (assuming you don't scrap Xi'an from your plans, of course). Bangkok could be a decent bet; just don't try to cram too much in because it would be a shame if 6 of your 13 days were spent in airports and on airplanes.
My wife had spoken with friends who had apparently lived in China for a few years. She was told that we should have a local escort whenever we leave the hotel to guide us because of the language barriers, among other things. She also heard group tours are herded through souvenir shops and can't get to the intended site until everyone buys something. Plus, she was told we have to register with the local police upon arrival.
Even if all that were true, and if we could afford the private escort, where's the fun in that? I'm for the adventure in exploring a little bit of China, even if it means getting lost now and then.
I understand my wife's concerns, and I need to be mindful of not dismissing them outright based on the information provided by, in her words, "strangers on an Internet forum," as I want many more years happily living with her. But you all are experts in one way or another here and I feel I your suggestions and advice are to our benefit. But that's me; unless my wife hears it from someone directly....
We're going to skip making a side trip outside of China; you and drewguy are right, there's no point in spending more time than necessary getting to and from airports and on planes. We still need to arrange the visit to Xi'an and the Terracotta Warriors; I'll see if I can do that without having to go through the Hilton.
Thanks very much for the advice!
#27
A FlyerTalk Posting Legend




Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: Shanghai
Posts: 46,306
I must say that I'm a bit surprised by your wife's friends' paranoia because that certainly doesn't reflect the sentiments of any people I know. Perhaps they lived in a diplomatic compound, and didn't get out much?
#28
Original Poster
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: GSO
Programs: AA-PLT/Lifetime
Posts: 1,187
Yo! I just booked my trip with a lot of input from people here. I did choose Hilton Beijing at first but switched over to Hilton Wangfujing. I thought the price difference was huge at first, but turns out its really not much different. Its much closer to all the things you listed.
Hilton Beijing is an easier trip to / from PEK though. If you can swing it, I might suggest swaping over to that hotel.
How do you plan on getting to your hotel?
Hilton Beijing is an easier trip to / from PEK though. If you can swing it, I might suggest swaping over to that hotel.
How do you plan on getting to your hotel?
In re. to getting to/from the airport, we've made prepaid (voucher) arrangements for shuttle transportation. It should be interesting as the flight arrives in PEK at 23h30, with customs and immigration procedures following, so the time we actually get to the vehicle will be well after that time.
Regards,
#29
A FlyerTalk Posting Legend




Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: Shanghai
Posts: 46,306
#30
Original Poster
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: GSO
Programs: AA-PLT/Lifetime
Posts: 1,187
If you're staying at hotels, you don't have to worry about this because they'll register you. If you're staying with friends, registration is easy enough (they should no which PSB is responsible for them), but I usually don't stress this issue (call me crazy... no problems yet apart from a mild scolding once during the course of 12 years).
I must say that I'm a bit surprised by your wife's friends' paranoia because that certainly doesn't reflect the sentiments of any people I know. Perhaps they lived in a diplomatic compound, and didn't get out much?
I must say that I'm a bit surprised by your wife's friends' paranoia because that certainly doesn't reflect the sentiments of any people I know. Perhaps they lived in a diplomatic compound, and didn't get out much?
I'm not sure of the circumstances under which my wife's friends were living, and why they strongly made the escort/guide recommendation, but I'm pretty sure they were living in China as regular civilians (as opposed to DoD or diplomatic employees).
Two quick questions while I'm thinking of them --
+ We'd like to update friends and family with photos and notes -- is Facebook available or is that restricted?
+ As mentioned in my reply to tiblot, we arrive late but arranged prepaid shuttle transportation. Unless necessary to do otherwise in your opinion, we'll arrive without Chinese currency but will exchange USD the next day. Would I be better off having at least have some money in hand upon arrival? If so, I'll look to exchange at DFW or ORD.
Thank you again for the advice -- and patience.


