How difficult to remove TNT (firework powder)
#1
Original Poster
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Louisville, KY, US
Programs: QF Plat - OW EMD | DL Gold / Starwood Gold
Posts: 6,106
How difficult to remove TNT (firework powder)
G'Day -
I was on the patio in my backyard on the 4th and my yard happens to back up to a decent sized park. Some folks were putting off a spectacular fireworks display that someone likely purchased across the state line (i.e. the fireworks you would see at a professional display).
During one of the spectacular displays, a chunk of unexploded firework came down and nailed me in the chest. Thankfully it wasn't burning or hot - nor was I injured; it just stung a bit; most thankfully it only hit my chest in the peck area (and not my face!).
Problem: It did leave a big brown coloured powder type stain on a good shirt. $20 says this residue will trigger an ETD or Puff Portal if not cleansed properly.
I took the shirt off and placed it in a plastic bag since it's full of a dark, chalk/powder-like residue. I have yet to wash it (still in plastic bag) as I do laundry like once every 2 weeks or so.
If I toss it in the washing machine alone, will that likely remove the residue permanently? Cold / Warm / Hot? Soak, Extra Wash cycles? Is Tide fine, or should I look at a specific detergent? Anyone have experience in this area?
I don't want this stuff to get around, contaminate other clothing or items and either cause the ETD to blow through the roof or set the puffer off. Sure, I can tell them it's just fireworks residue, but I don't want to have to deal with it. I could always just toss the shirt, but if I can get the residue removed without a lot of trouble that would be preferable.
If anyone knows much about the larger fireworks, the projectile that hit me was almost one inch by half an inch. It's a compressed powder, chalky in nature. I don't know much about the makeup of fireworks, but I'm going to guess a gunpowder or TNT of some type.
A few years ago I did alarm an ETD for checked luggage. Was told it was positive for traces of TNT. I was briefly detained while the TSA cleared the luggage and also requested all of my personal information. Was a pain in the kazoo ... I don't care to repeat.
Cheers!
SDF_Traveler
I was on the patio in my backyard on the 4th and my yard happens to back up to a decent sized park. Some folks were putting off a spectacular fireworks display that someone likely purchased across the state line (i.e. the fireworks you would see at a professional display).
During one of the spectacular displays, a chunk of unexploded firework came down and nailed me in the chest. Thankfully it wasn't burning or hot - nor was I injured; it just stung a bit; most thankfully it only hit my chest in the peck area (and not my face!).
Problem: It did leave a big brown coloured powder type stain on a good shirt. $20 says this residue will trigger an ETD or Puff Portal if not cleansed properly.
I took the shirt off and placed it in a plastic bag since it's full of a dark, chalk/powder-like residue. I have yet to wash it (still in plastic bag) as I do laundry like once every 2 weeks or so.
If I toss it in the washing machine alone, will that likely remove the residue permanently? Cold / Warm / Hot? Soak, Extra Wash cycles? Is Tide fine, or should I look at a specific detergent? Anyone have experience in this area?

I don't want this stuff to get around, contaminate other clothing or items and either cause the ETD to blow through the roof or set the puffer off. Sure, I can tell them it's just fireworks residue, but I don't want to have to deal with it. I could always just toss the shirt, but if I can get the residue removed without a lot of trouble that would be preferable.
If anyone knows much about the larger fireworks, the projectile that hit me was almost one inch by half an inch. It's a compressed powder, chalky in nature. I don't know much about the makeup of fireworks, but I'm going to guess a gunpowder or TNT of some type.
A few years ago I did alarm an ETD for checked luggage. Was told it was positive for traces of TNT. I was briefly detained while the TSA cleared the luggage and also requested all of my personal information. Was a pain in the kazoo ... I don't care to repeat.
Cheers!
SDF_Traveler
#3




Join Date: May 2005
Location: various cities in the USofA: NYC, BWI, IAH, ORD, CVG, NYC
Programs: Former UA 1K, National Exec. Elite
Posts: 5,487

It's wrong that anyone has to worry about this. Why should the OP's name, etc. have been recorded the first time around? If he actually had non-trivial amounts of TNT I would understand it, but traces? What percentage of ETD alarms are of actual concern? Is it something other than 0%?
It'd be fun to walk around a checkin area and dust 100s of peoples bags with TNT or some other agent that alarms the ETD.
#4


Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: USA
Programs: AAdvantage, MileagePlus, SkyMiles
Posts: 4,338
#5
Join Date: Dec 2004
Programs: AA, WN RR
Posts: 3,122
My grade in Organic Chemistry II was a D, so take that into account re this advice. Rubbing alcohol - isopropanol - affects quite a few chemicals. What material is your shirt? If cotton, should be no adverse reaction if you soak the area of impact with isopropanol for about 30 minutes. First test this treatment on an area of the shirt that is not visible when you are wearing it. Then rinse the shirt thoroughly in water. In fact, after the isopropanol I would soak the shirt in dishwashing detergent. After the rinse, wash the shirt as you normally would. I would let the shirt air dry, because tossing it in a dryer could set the residue.
Good luck!
Good luck!
#6
Original Poster
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Louisville, KY, US
Programs: QF Plat - OW EMD | DL Gold / Starwood Gold
Posts: 6,106
Because he wants to use his shirt? Or is the presence trivial/trace amounts of legal materials grounds for punishment by the gov't? I guess people who work with fireworks and in mines aren't allowed to fly. 
It's wrong that anyone has to worry about this. Why should the OP's name, etc. have been recorded the first time around? If he actually had non-trivial amounts of TNT I would understand it, but traces? What percentage of ETD alarms are of actual concern? Is it something other than 0%?
It'd be fun to walk around a checkin area and dust 100s of peoples bags with TNT or some other agent that alarms the ETD.

It's wrong that anyone has to worry about this. Why should the OP's name, etc. have been recorded the first time around? If he actually had non-trivial amounts of TNT I would understand it, but traces? What percentage of ETD alarms are of actual concern? Is it something other than 0%?
It'd be fun to walk around a checkin area and dust 100s of peoples bags with TNT or some other agent that alarms the ETD.
Prior to making that trip, I went to Walgreens, purchased a few items, and tossed the bag in my checked luggage. The CTX alarmed (it happens), my bag was opened, searched and swabbed. The traces of TNT were isolated to the bag.
So Walgreens gives me a plastic bag (or an item in the bag had a trace of TNT) and I'm suddenly guilty.

If setting off an ETD - which is very sensitive - is grounds to go onto the no-fly list, the state of affairs of this nation is even worse than I thought.
I don't know the first thing about TNT. If it is unlikely to come off, I'll toss the shirt - it's not the end of the world. If it washes off easily, why toss $80 out the window?
Sad thing is, as ralfp states, I shouldn't even have to worry about it -- the sad fact is I do.
#7
Moderator: Coupon Connection & S.P.A.M




Join Date: May 2000
Location: Louisville, KY
Programs: Destination Unknown, TSA Disparager Diamond (LTDD)
Posts: 58,133
The good news: there was probably no TNT on the fireworks, even from a professional display. Trinitrotolulene (TNT) is not used for any display fireworks that I am aware of. (Building demolitions in Las Vegas could be the exception.
)
The solution: wash it a couple of times and hope for the best. You might test positive for nitrates (components in many solid explosives) but you probably won't if you wash it a couple of times. I've handled a lot of fireworks on the 4th/New Years, flown soon afterwards, and never set off the puffer or ETD for nitrates.
)The solution: wash it a couple of times and hope for the best. You might test positive for nitrates (components in many solid explosives) but you probably won't if you wash it a couple of times. I've handled a lot of fireworks on the 4th/New Years, flown soon afterwards, and never set off the puffer or ETD for nitrates.
#8
FlyerTalk Evangelist


Join Date: May 2003
Location: AA Plat / UA NOTHING / Alaska 75K / Hyatt Diamond / SPG LT Plat / Marriott Gold / Priority Club Plat / Hertz Pres
Posts: 25,596
I'd take Spiff's advice and give it a couple of washes but I don't think there's anything more you'll need to do to it to make it "airport safe". I'd wash it separately only to protect the other clothing from getting stained from the residue, I wouldn't be so concerned with contaminating the other clothing with something that would set off a puffer or a swab. I think you were right to be concerned but washing should take care of it.
I say this having worked in the business for the last 12 years doing everything from setting off huge display shows to backyard fireworks to working in our retail stores. My current job is to open new retail stores and I travel every week. Being in and out of our warehouses and in contact with our product on a daily basis, I've had my share of swabs and trips thru the puffer machine and I can tell you that I have never set off either - which is scary in its own right.
I say this having worked in the business for the last 12 years doing everything from setting off huge display shows to backyard fireworks to working in our retail stores. My current job is to open new retail stores and I travel every week. Being in and out of our warehouses and in contact with our product on a daily basis, I've had my share of swabs and trips thru the puffer machine and I can tell you that I have never set off either - which is scary in its own right.
#9
Join Date: Jun 2007
Posts: 105
I say this having worked in the business for the last 12 years doing everything from setting off huge display shows to backyard fireworks to working in our retail stores. My current job is to open new retail stores and I travel every week. Being in and out of our warehouses and in contact with our product on a daily basis, I've had my share of swabs and trips thru the puffer machine and I can tell you that I have never set off either - which is scary in its own right.

#11
Join Date: Jul 2005
Posts: 861
The reason low explosives are ignored in explosive trace testing is because they require a substantial, high-strength casing (e.g., 3/8 steel pipe, etc.) in order to be explosive (i.e., there's 0% chance they're getting through x-ray or WTMD), and any device using them will be haphazard at best.
#12
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: CLT
Programs: Choice Hotels/FFOCUS
Posts: 7,259
As was said by Spiff above, ETD and ETP look for high explosives not low explosives (gunpowder, flash powder, etc.). The reason low explosives are ignored in explosive trace testing is because they require a substantial, high-strength casing (e.g., 3/8 steel pipe, etc.) in order to be explosive (i.e., there's 0% chance they're getting through x-ray or WTMD), and any device using them will be haphazard at best.
#13

Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: LAX/CWA/TOA/AUW
Programs: Mileage Plus, SW Rewards, WorldPerks, Barnes and Noble Frequent Buyers
Posts: 368
I was wondering about things like this too. My #1 son had some illegal fireworks that a friend brought into CA from AL. He put them in his messenger bag that he uses for school. I told him he's now contaminated everything that goes into that bag with black powder. Since the bag is fabric I think I'll just wash it and see if that removes the residue.
As far as the Walgreens bag, any glycerin based hand lotion that may have spilled would test positive.
ab53
As far as the Walgreens bag, any glycerin based hand lotion that may have spilled would test positive.
ab53
#14
Join Date: Jun 2007
Posts: 105
I see these articles about failed tests and I resist saying anything for fear of saying stuff I shouldn't. Look, do not feel confident about these tests done by federal inspectors. Perhaps I shouldn't reveal this, but we get heads up before these "Red Teams" come through. Having "passed" one let me assure you that they in no way could approximate the real thing. Remember, federal agencies put political correctness above everything else, including security. And please don't misunderstand this, but you must believe me when I say that the people running these tests could never come within even the periphery of the profile of a potential terrorist. Look, I'd like to maintain high levels of alertness and visual acuity at all times, but I don't. I'm selective. While I stay directed at the x-ray screen, in terms of the level of scrutiny, I make mere cursory glances at a pilot's bags and only a little higher scrutiny of the bags of let's say, a trio of middle-aged American guys with Northrup-Grumman badges. Now, when someone comes through who might have even the slightest (six degrees of separation) possibility of a connection with a terrorist (under 40, foreign national, laconic, etc.), I look over their bags like a medical doctor examining a patient's x-rays. If I see anything, anything which could, even in a MacGyver-esque way, be used in a IED, I call for ETD and bag check. And surprisingly, I'd guess that this is no more than 1% on a busy day.

