FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   Cathay Pacific | Cathay (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/cathay-pacific-cathay-487/)
-   -   HKG Pier dining — what a let down! (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/cathay-pacific-cathay/1964231-hkg-pier-dining-what-let-down.html)

dodgeflyer Apr 26, 2019 2:42 pm


Originally Posted by thatflyer (Post 31040158)
T

wooohh. Hold on here.

Whilst i too complained about the F CX lounge in HK let’s not get to the point to say it is not worth going to.

If you would spend any time in any lounge my choice would always be in a CX lounge (with perhaps Sydney Qantas F lounge the exception - but generally CX is my place of choice).

It is miles better than any BA lounge.

In fact given the choice I would pick a Gatwick CX business lounge over any lounge in Gatwick or Heathrow business or first. I actually prefer the CX business lounge in gatwick over the first!

So please do go to it. The food is still good (not as good as before but still good) selection of drinks is good and the showers are great!

CX doesn’t have a lounge at LGW.

I notice on this thread lots of vocal people about cx f lounges who list their card status yet doesn’t give them access to an F lounge.

DeathSlam Apr 26, 2019 4:29 pm


Originally Posted by Visconti (Post 31040480)
They warned me, but I didn't think it would be that spicy! No, never been, but have had the cuisine, of course.

This reminds me of an experience of a dish in a Sichuan restaurant on the far outskirts of Beijing (recommended by a local). Oh, that's pretty what are the green things? Peppers. The red things? Peppers. The white things? Peppers. And they added good handfuls of mouth numbing Sichuan pepper to presumably help with the experience. What happened to the fish is another story...

DeathSlam Apr 26, 2019 4:43 pm


Originally Posted by dodgeflyer (Post 31040649)
CI notice on this thread lots of vocal people about cx f lounges who list their card status yet doesn’t give them access to an F lounge.

You don't have to be OWE to access F lounges.
Paid F
Reward F
Upgraded to F
Guested to F lounge
I have done all but the first. I'm not megarich or a sky warrior, I only fly a few times a year but enjoy maximising my experience which is why I enjoy learning from the knowledgeable folks here and trying to share if I can. Negative comments on other contributors seems a little Grinch-like, please try to provide positive advice.

Visconti Apr 26, 2019 5:17 pm


Originally Posted by DeathSlam (Post 31040910)
This reminds me of an experience of a dish in a Sichuan restaurant on the far outskirts of Beijing (recommended by a local). Oh, that's pretty what are the green things? Peppers. The red things? Peppers. The white things? Peppers. And they added good handfuls of mouth numbing Sichuan pepper to presumably help with the experience. What happened to the fish is another story...

When they warned me, I just thought, "no sweat, have had spicy food all over the world." Well, had no idea and never occurred to me that "tongue numbing" was part of the experience.

kaka Apr 26, 2019 7:01 pm


Originally Posted by Visconti (Post 31040480)
They warned me, but I didn't think it would be that spicy! No, never been, but have had the cuisine, of course.

im glad they made it as how its meant to be like (ive ordered it too). as everyone here know im not the biggest fan of china, but i disagree with appropriating food recipes categorically.

the biggest gripe i have for the lounge is the appropriateness of speed. in EVERY aspect, esp in the dining room

Cambo Apr 26, 2019 11:26 pm


Originally Posted by Visconti (Post 31040480)
They warned me, but I didn't think it would be that spicy! No, never been, but have had the cuisine, of course.

Looks to me, the lounge staff did have a nice day out. You probably weren't the only one who "ignored" the warning :D

Which lounge did you manage to get the spicy Sichuan fish ? I would like to try to, or got it western-adapted since then, due to "complaints" ?

thomas164 Apr 27, 2019 1:49 am

Thanks everyone! I have been reading a lot these weeks regarding Sodexo lounges and I thought the level is close to unacceptable. I guess it’s probably just the food, or otherwise the whole experience is still above many other lounges. Anyways, can’t wait for a lounge hop the day after. Cheers!

QRC3288 Apr 27, 2019 2:13 am


Originally Posted by thomas164 (Post 31041807)
Thanks everyone! I have been reading a lot these weeks regarding Sodexo lounges and I thought the level is close to unacceptable. I guess it’s probably just the food, or otherwise the whole experience is still above many other lounges. Anyways, can’t wait for a lounge hop the day after. Cheers!

Yea, probably best to just stop reading about it and look forward to whatever comes.

There is an interesting phenomenon with so much info out there, a lot of magic is lost by the obsessive blog (and FT, to be fair) reading. Of course there is good info too, especially on FT, and why I am faithfully loyal to the forum here but have far less enthusiasm for the blogs. I specifically point my finger at the blogs on all those "reviews" which really lower peoples enjoyment of real life experiences. Of course, the reviewers love traveling in premium classes so will justify the reviews as for the greater good. (ha ha). The truth is it activates some type of addictive, compulsive behavior in people which seems very hard to turn off, almost like an addiction. There is something about expectations being elevated, the magic of surprise and the unexpected being lost, when people obsessively consume information about travel before stepping on the plane or arriving at the destination.

Anyway, the Pier is perfectly fine. It is difficult to reconcile my own issues with the Pier with my recommendation to just "have a good time and enjoy it!" But that's my advice, as two faced as it may be;). I'll write something nice in a follow up post.

I will add, a general observation I have is at least a decent amount of whinging comes from some folks, not completely regulars here, who are flying award tickets or el cheapo tickets of some type. I find that an amusing element to this whole business. It's all subjective and anecdotal of course, but it seems to me some people who complain the most and are relentless on compensation et cetera are the ones who may not be paying much at all for their tickets;).

QRC3288 Apr 27, 2019 2:21 am

Good experience the other day
 
I've been to the Pier F too many to count, so this is less about the food and more about service.

I had a superlative experience in the Pier the other day. Midday, a very aggressive (in a good way) perhaps Middle Eastern or SE Asian gentleman. I could be getting the heritage wrong here, but hoping someone else knows who I'm talking about? He has a darker complexion but speaks English flawlessly without an accent, I couldn't nail down where he was from. Or maybe southern Mediterranean? Anyway, this guy was doing a fantastic job of checking up on everyone, making sure orders were expedited properly, essentially making sure service was on point. I think I've seen him before and he manages a few of the lounges. Somebody give this guy a raise or keep him around please because the whole drumbeat of the lounge was on point with him in there working hard. Another lady, this one either African or Middle Eastern, was my server and was just excellent. I think she is evenings normally. The food was "fine", I thought my main the chana masala was lovely although I'm not probably a very good judge, but to be honest I don't expect Michelin starred dining in the airport anyway. Kudos to the poster above who brought that up. But hey my appetizer arrived first and a few minutes after ordering, my main arrived a few minutes after I finished my appetizer, my drink came out promptly and was refilled promptly, smiling friendly staff asking if I needed anything else, just everything was on the mark. I don't make a pilgrimage out to the Pier F very often, but this time the service made a real impression on me in a good way.

The whole experience reminded me that when service is on point, it really is a lovely facility. And how much poor service (or just "clueless service") can spoil things.

Now, the wine is still utterly dreadful except for the Champagne. But we all know we can blame CX squarely for the crap wine, not Sodexo. That is definitely a budget item specifically approved by CX if not picked out by them. I've flown CX too long to expect anything out of lounge wines, even in F.

Visconti Apr 27, 2019 9:36 am


Originally Posted by Cambo (Post 31041622)
Looks to me, the lounge staff did have a nice day out. You probably weren't the only one who "ignored" the warning :D

Which lounge did you manage to get the spicy Sichuan fish ? I would like to try to, or got it western-adapted since then, due to "complaints" ?

Pier F.

I always choose the latest flights, since I never know when I may have last minute dinner engagements, and it was probably around 9 pm? So, a little tired, and really didn't appreciate "the extent" of the warning. I mean, they did say it was "really" spicy. From reading the posts here, it appears the "authentic" Sichuan cuisine I've had in NA perhaps wasn't really that authentic, at least to the level of spicy aspect.

I mean, this dish was spicy! The PF Chang menus' Sichuan dishes use 3 peppers to denote most spicy--this thing would have been 10! LOL

PS - OT, but since we're on CX cuisine, the best airplane dinner I've had was on the 2nd leg of HKG - JFK. On the YVR - JFK leg, I was the only returning pax on F, and, for whatever reason, the filet was high quality (tasted like a 1% usda prime) & actually cooked at the right medium rare, on the rare side. This FA was probably the best I've ever experienced.

Visconti Apr 27, 2019 9:49 am


Originally Posted by QRC3288 (Post 31041849)
The whole experience reminded me that when service is on point, it really is a lovely facility. And how much poor service (or just "clueless service") can spoil things.

Aside from food considerations, all things equal, the Pier lounges are my favorite of any airport to pass the time. For me it has the perfect lighting, ambience, and comfortable seating where I can find an area, stretch out, and be assured I won't be disturbed. And, unlike other lounges I've been to, it has a pleasant scent (whatever they use). It really is an elegant facility. Though in the same area, I prefer the Pier over the Cent lounge, even though I have access to all of its areas. Unfortunately, most of my flights seem to depart from Gates 1 - 4 (have worked in HK long enough to dislike it when I get Gate 4), so the Wing is more convenient, but I really do prefer the Pier.

PS - The food is fine. I'd even say it's good, unless we compare it to world class Michelin rated restaurants, which seems kind of unrealistic, in my view.

jagmeets Apr 27, 2019 10:29 am


Originally Posted by QRC3288 (Post 31041849)
Another lady, this one either African or Middle Eastern, was my server and was just excellent. I think she is evenings normally.

Congo-nese, I believe. Very enthusiastic and a delight to chat with at the bar.

While not not quite a Simon (I just got to get an Amex Centurion!), she does make a mean cocktail.

SullyofDoha Apr 27, 2019 11:16 am

It’s still hands above QR’s Al Safwa first lounge.

747jetter Apr 27, 2019 12:27 pm


Originally Posted by SullyofDoha (Post 31042919)
It’s still hands above QR’s Al Safwa first lounge.

Al Safwa disappointed me a bit in terms of catering but it is way ahead of CX F lounges. OWE in Y or J restricted access and "hotel rooms" are great. I think these lounges cant be really compared.

londonexpert Apr 27, 2019 7:48 pm


Originally Posted by 747jetter (Post 31043079)
Al Safwa disappointed me a bit in terms of catering but it is way ahead of CX F lounges. OWE in Y or J restricted access and "hotel rooms" are great. I think these lounges cant be really compared.

I do agree the sleeping rooms are the best, as it has a proper bed and full privacy room.
however aesthetic wise the AS is just too big and I felt I am sitting in a hotel lobby most of the time compared to the more intimate feel of the CX pier

however AS is only f class access or extra payment for J class pax.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 4:52 am.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.