Last edit by: KARFA
This thread focuses on experiences and reactions for the implementation of buy on board for shorthaul, mainly led by impressions taken from flying on board British Airways' shorthaul services.
An information thread exists for your questions, particularly if they are on factual matters, here:
Buy on board: Information guide for BA shorthaul economy services
If you have an opinion about the concept of Buy on Board, the right thread is:
Buy on board: Implemented on BA short haul - opinions on the concept
Photos of current BoB menu (September 2018) post #125 in information thread
An information thread exists for your questions, particularly if they are on factual matters, here:
Buy on board: Information guide for BA shorthaul economy services
If you have an opinion about the concept of Buy on Board, the right thread is:
Buy on board: Implemented on BA short haul - opinions on the concept
Photos of current BoB menu (September 2018) post #125 in information thread
Buy on board: Experiences and reactions from BA's shorthaul economy service
#1471
Join Date: Sep 2012
Location: NW London and NW Sydney
Programs: BA Diamond, Hilton Bronze, A3 Diamond, IHG *G
Posts: 6,344
I would imagine it's not too common , I have three older relatives that still fly but don't have credit or debit cards! They are still very cash and cheque based. I wonder how they manage, but they seem to. It would be embarrassing all round if you ordered then could only provide cash , although I can see other fellow passengers helping out.
Can any FR/U2 flyers report how common cash payments are over card? I think they take both GBP and EUR cash, is that right?
#1472
Join Date: Jul 2014
Location: Wedged somewhere between BTS and VIE ✈
Programs: Star Alliance Gold (A3 Gold), Oneworld Emerald (BA Gold), Hilton Diamond
Posts: 6,338
LHR - BLQ yesterday, girl in front missed the service as she was asleep, asked for a sandwich and crisps which were brought for her. Unfortunately her card didn't want to work and she didn't have another one so had to hand back the food. Felt uncomfortable for her and the FA judging by expressions
Think i would have chomped into the sandwich in the time it took. Would they have still asked for it back?
Think i would have chomped into the sandwich in the time it took. Would they have still asked for it back?
#1473
Join Date: Dec 2015
Posts: 410
I'd say more people pay with cash than with card.
#1474
Ambassador: Emirates Airlines
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: Manchester, UK
Posts: 18,613
Not sure, but on U2, they sometimes announce that only the exact amount is allowed, as they have no change.
#1475
Join Date: May 2010
Location: Dublin
Programs: EI AC Silver, BAEC Gold
Posts: 369
For comparison and in my estimation on EI it is well over 50% who pay with cash. On a flight this week it was 100% cash as the POS machines were non functional. Payments could be made in €,$ or £.
#1479
Join Date: Jul 2014
Location: Wedged somewhere between BTS and VIE ✈
Programs: Star Alliance Gold (A3 Gold), Oneworld Emerald (BA Gold), Hilton Diamond
Posts: 6,338
In the last week I had 2 flights with BA, one was a redemption from TXL and the other, to VIE, was booked before the introduction of BoB.
Although the first flight was rather lightly loaded the service seemed to be very slow. This was despite the fact that one of the crew from the CE cabin was taking orders from the back of the aircraft and collecting the products from the galley there. The service certainly wasn't helped by passengers needing to go to the toilet. They did complete but this flight was probably about 60% full (only 2 of us in row 12 for example). I had flown into Berlin from Bratislava on an 8 EUR Ryanair ticket and couldn't help thinking that with the BA flight I'd been ripped off.
The second flight, to VIE, I would say had a more experienced crew. One of the female crew members told me that she usually does longhaul and the others all seemed to be very relaxed whilst doing their duties. I was sat in 12A and a family of 4 had the rest of row 12. The CSM announced that 2 of the sandwich items from the menu were not available but had been substituted with something else. The service got off to a reasonable start but then the transactions seemed to slow them down. I nodded off for a while but was woken by the family adjacent opening and closing the overhead lockers several times while rummaging around for their food that they'd bought before boarding. With that and all the paper and packaging rustling I couldn't fall asleep. I don't begrudge them for bringing their food, but this is exactly why I hate BoB. Before, the crew would effortlessly go through the cabin, everybody ate at the same time, rubbish was cleared, and you could doze off for an hour or so.
There was an issue with an order on the other side of the cabin. It looked like a passenger had ordered a hot item from the menu. There was a tray taken to the passenger's seat but when they tried to collect the payment her card wasn't accepted. Then they took the tray away! It then looked like another passenger in that row had offered to pay using her card...that too was not accepted. By the time all this happened we were somewhere between Prague and Brno and minutes away from descent. What a shambles.
I was against BoB in principal anyway, but I thought it would have bedded in by now. 3 months later it's still a complete mess and I can't help but thinking that they must be upsetting people now on every flight.
Incidentally, the cabins were not without issue either. On the TXL flight the overhead monitor kept opening and shutting - even during the safety briefing. On the VIE flight the 'mood lighting' at the front of the cabin kept flickering, thank goodness nobody had an epileptic seizure. That, together with the BoB service, and I kept thinking for a British Airways Holiday booking Faulty Towers would be well suited!
Although the first flight was rather lightly loaded the service seemed to be very slow. This was despite the fact that one of the crew from the CE cabin was taking orders from the back of the aircraft and collecting the products from the galley there. The service certainly wasn't helped by passengers needing to go to the toilet. They did complete but this flight was probably about 60% full (only 2 of us in row 12 for example). I had flown into Berlin from Bratislava on an 8 EUR Ryanair ticket and couldn't help thinking that with the BA flight I'd been ripped off.
The second flight, to VIE, I would say had a more experienced crew. One of the female crew members told me that she usually does longhaul and the others all seemed to be very relaxed whilst doing their duties. I was sat in 12A and a family of 4 had the rest of row 12. The CSM announced that 2 of the sandwich items from the menu were not available but had been substituted with something else. The service got off to a reasonable start but then the transactions seemed to slow them down. I nodded off for a while but was woken by the family adjacent opening and closing the overhead lockers several times while rummaging around for their food that they'd bought before boarding. With that and all the paper and packaging rustling I couldn't fall asleep. I don't begrudge them for bringing their food, but this is exactly why I hate BoB. Before, the crew would effortlessly go through the cabin, everybody ate at the same time, rubbish was cleared, and you could doze off for an hour or so.
There was an issue with an order on the other side of the cabin. It looked like a passenger had ordered a hot item from the menu. There was a tray taken to the passenger's seat but when they tried to collect the payment her card wasn't accepted. Then they took the tray away! It then looked like another passenger in that row had offered to pay using her card...that too was not accepted. By the time all this happened we were somewhere between Prague and Brno and minutes away from descent. What a shambles.
I was against BoB in principal anyway, but I thought it would have bedded in by now. 3 months later it's still a complete mess and I can't help but thinking that they must be upsetting people now on every flight.
Incidentally, the cabins were not without issue either. On the TXL flight the overhead monitor kept opening and shutting - even during the safety briefing. On the VIE flight the 'mood lighting' at the front of the cabin kept flickering, thank goodness nobody had an epileptic seizure. That, together with the BoB service, and I kept thinking for a British Airways Holiday booking Faulty Towers would be well suited!
Last edited by headingwest; Apr 17, 2017 at 3:07 pm Reason: typo
#1480
Join Date: Feb 2013
Location: UK
Programs: I go wherever the content takes me.
Posts: 5,698
My most recent flight was HAM-LHR, and I was, as usual, ensconced in 23F on the A319 - empty row and no ugly wing in the way of the view, you see.
Anyway we were over Walton-on-the-Naze before I was met by the trolley! Chap serving was very polite. I'd resolved long ago to spend precisely £0 with BA on BoB, so declined service. Got the Gold welcome. He was sincere but I vented about the direction BA is going. He sympathised.
And so, it is resolved - that's it. I'm not going to book a single flight more with BA; they're dumped. I'll take my upcoming premium flights for the rest of 2017, then with the Avios earned, splurge on a CX F redemption.
Star Alliance and budget airlines beckon.
Anyway we were over Walton-on-the-Naze before I was met by the trolley! Chap serving was very polite. I'd resolved long ago to spend precisely £0 with BA on BoB, so declined service. Got the Gold welcome. He was sincere but I vented about the direction BA is going. He sympathised.
And so, it is resolved - that's it. I'm not going to book a single flight more with BA; they're dumped. I'll take my upcoming premium flights for the rest of 2017, then with the Avios earned, splurge on a CX F redemption.
Star Alliance and budget airlines beckon.
#1481
Join Date: May 2010
Location: UK
Posts: 5,380
My most recent flight was HAM-LHR, and I was, as usual, ensconced in 23F on the A319 - empty row and no ugly wing in the way of the view, you see.
Anyway we were over Walton-on-the-Naze before I was met by the trolley! Chap serving was very polite. I'd resolved long ago to spend precisely £0 with BA on BoB, so declined service. Got the Gold welcome. He was sincere but I vented about the direction BA is going. He sympathised.
And so, it is resolved - that's it. I'm not going to book a single flight more with BA; they're dumped. I'll take my upcoming premium flights for the rest of 2017, then with the Avios earned, splurge on a CX F redemption.
Star Alliance and budget airlines beckon.
Anyway we were over Walton-on-the-Naze before I was met by the trolley! Chap serving was very polite. I'd resolved long ago to spend precisely £0 with BA on BoB, so declined service. Got the Gold welcome. He was sincere but I vented about the direction BA is going. He sympathised.
And so, it is resolved - that's it. I'm not going to book a single flight more with BA; they're dumped. I'll take my upcoming premium flights for the rest of 2017, then with the Avios earned, splurge on a CX F redemption.
Star Alliance and budget airlines beckon.
#1482
Join Date: Apr 2017
Posts: 516
#1483
Join Date: Feb 2013
Location: UK
Programs: I go wherever the content takes me.
Posts: 5,698
There are a few reasons.
Selfish:
1) I'm a bit bored.
2) I don't want viewers to get bored of the same old stuff.
Non-selfish (and altogether carrying far more weight):
1) BoB is not a bad concept in and of itself. But it's poorly executed. I won't ever buy anything on board an airline; I'd rather self-cater. The execution is the latest in a long line of poorly-executed rollouts which make me think BA isn't too concerned about quality at a corporate level. BoB does however place me at the same level as a LCC customer. Why can't I even get a bottle of water? AA managed to give me some Pringles and a Coke last year in Y. I'm not BA's most valuable customer but equally I'm not counting every penny per Tier Point. (I've a CIV of 76 doncha know? )
2) BAEC has lost a considerable amount of shine over the last few years. Gold extra Y redemption availability is a very good perk, but apart from that, what does my Gold status actually mean? Not much, in the grand scheme of things. I value the lounge access most, because it gives me a place to charge my gear and chill out, so PriorityPass here I come. £200 for a year seems fine.
3) I can foresee the withdrawal of F in the next 5-10 years on BA - just a feeling in my bones.
4) Continued evisceration of Club Europe on short routes makes it unviable (though a recent trip from AGP - a longer route - was very pleasant).
5) Just a general feel of a lack of quality across the operation. There's really only two things I think BA are market leaders in, and that's their app, and their internal CRM. It's hard to quantify, but it's kind of like closing the boot of a new car and hearing it makes a funny sound - it works, and the whole car is still there and working, but it belies a lack of quality.
6) Insincere communications. The dreaded "enhancement" is insulting to regular customers. Honestly, I can handle bad news, and I dare say most of BA's GCHs will be able to understand a business sometimes needs to make tough decisions. But don't dress up obvious downgrades as enhancements. PS: I want my amuse bouche back when I travel in July.
So, it's not a poison pen letter to Cruz. He is ultimately fulfilling the brief given to him by Walsh.
I wish BA good luck in their mission to reinvent themselves as a pseudo-LCC, pseudo-premium carrier. I think that's a tricky game. But, they have lost me as a customer. Perhaps they will gain new customers from the LCCs.
#1484
Suspended
Join Date: Jul 2007
Posts: 4,477
BA should have chosen the middle road of BOB: that is the SK way of free water, coffee and tea. Everything else pay. That would be more friendly and may get better feedback. But they decide to go for the Vueling way. I hope them good luck.
Now I book BA purely on price in order to requalify my AA elite membership.
#1485
Join Date: May 2016
Location: London
Programs: BA Gold, Accor Gold
Posts: 1,429
Very amusing CC announcement on my return from Jersey on Sunday, welcoming us onboard this flying Marks & Spencer
Then proceeded to tell us all as we'd landed that the First Officer had just been voted dishiest BA staff member and would be off on a photoshoot to model M&S swimming trunks in the summer. The poor FO was at the door cringing as we disembarked, but the ladies were paying him particular attention.
(PS I was in CE so have no comment on the BoB, other than the CC put out a call in the climb that if anyone wanted anything they should press their call bell and they'd endeavour to get around to everyone on the short flight.)
Then proceeded to tell us all as we'd landed that the First Officer had just been voted dishiest BA staff member and would be off on a photoshoot to model M&S swimming trunks in the summer. The poor FO was at the door cringing as we disembarked, but the ladies were paying him particular attention.
(PS I was in CE so have no comment on the BoB, other than the CC put out a call in the climb that if anyone wanted anything they should press their call bell and they'd endeavour to get around to everyone on the short flight.)