New York-Montreal train route in peril
#1
Original Poster
Join Date: Jan 2005
Posts: 327
New York-Montreal train route in peril
A New York train-passengers group fears it might be the end of the line for Amtrak's Manhattan-Montreal train, one of the most scenic rail trips in the world and a key source of tourists for Montreal.
Since its launch in August 1974, the Albany-Montreal portion of the route has been subsidized by New York State, with current annual funding at about $5 million U.S.
But New York wants to cut that subsidy and there's only enough money to keep the train running until Sept. 30, said Bruce Becker, the Buffalo, N.Y.-based president of the Empire State Passengers Association.
http://www.montrealgazette.com/news/...502/story.html
Since its launch in August 1974, the Albany-Montreal portion of the route has been subsidized by New York State, with current annual funding at about $5 million U.S.
But New York wants to cut that subsidy and there's only enough money to keep the train running until Sept. 30, said Bruce Becker, the Buffalo, N.Y.-based president of the Empire State Passengers Association.
http://www.montrealgazette.com/news/...502/story.html
#2
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: United States
Programs: UA, AA, DL, Amtrak
Posts: 4,647
If it's such a "key source of tourists" for Montreal, why don't the Quebecois kick in a few million loonies?
#5
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: May 2001
Posts: 10,969
I wonder how many tourists the route brings to Quebec. It takes over 11 hours to go from NYP to MTR. Driving, by comparison, takes about 7 hours. For weekend trips, taking Amtrak is not feasible as the trains run during the day and take a whole day to get to the other end.
We certainly don't want to get into the Canada vs. Quebec debate here
We certainly don't want to get into the Canada vs. Quebec debate here
#6
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: DTW/FNT
Programs: Delta (nee NW), Hilton Diamond. IHG (PT)
Posts: 4,823
#7
Join Date: May 2005
Programs: BA Gold, AA PLT PRO, AGR, Strawberry (Nordic Choice), Marriott Bonvoy
Posts: 4,248
I always think this route is one of the saddest examples of US underinvestment in trains.
NYC-Montreal is 330 miles (or thereabouts).
London-Paris is 306 miles on Eurostar.
Eurostar takes 2h15 to go from London to Paris.
Amtrak takes between 10 and 12 hours to go from NYC to Montreal.
If the US could invest something in the system (and yes, I know about all the stops en route between NYC and Montreal, but leave that aside for a moment and imagine there was a true express train) imagine how this might invigorate cross-border trade and tie the economies of Quebec and NY together?
I just think it's sad. I've taken the train from NYC to Montreal. It was cheap, but very very very slow: delayed for 3hrs on the way back, and the cafe car ran out of (what was, admittedly, bad) food.
NYC-Montreal is 330 miles (or thereabouts).
London-Paris is 306 miles on Eurostar.
Eurostar takes 2h15 to go from London to Paris.
Amtrak takes between 10 and 12 hours to go from NYC to Montreal.
If the US could invest something in the system (and yes, I know about all the stops en route between NYC and Montreal, but leave that aside for a moment and imagine there was a true express train) imagine how this might invigorate cross-border trade and tie the economies of Quebec and NY together?
I just think it's sad. I've taken the train from NYC to Montreal. It was cheap, but very very very slow: delayed for 3hrs on the way back, and the cafe car ran out of (what was, admittedly, bad) food.
#8
Join Date: May 2005
Location: various cities in the USofA: NYC, BWI, IAH, ORD, CVG, NYC
Programs: Former UA 1K, National Exec. Elite
Posts: 5,485
I always think this route is one of the saddest examples of US underinvestment in trains.
NYC-Montreal is 330 miles (or thereabouts).
London-Paris is 306 miles on Eurostar.
Eurostar takes 2h15 to go from London to Paris.
Amtrak takes between 10 and 12 hours to go from NYC to Montreal.
NYC-Montreal is 330 miles (or thereabouts).
London-Paris is 306 miles on Eurostar.
Eurostar takes 2h15 to go from London to Paris.
Amtrak takes between 10 and 12 hours to go from NYC to Montreal.
I would have taken this train long ago if it went overnight (with Viewliners or similar) in at least one direction. 12 hours is fine, if it's 7PM to 7AM. In practice that's as fast (no daytime hours wasted) and economical (save a night's hotel stay) as a 3 hour daytime trip.
#9
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: United States
Programs: UA, AA, DL, Amtrak
Posts: 4,647
Easy fix: Sleeping cars. That, and viable connections to Quebec City and other places.
I would have taken this train long ago if it went overnight (with Viewliners or similar) in at least one direction. 12 hours is fine, if it's 7PM to 7AM. In practice that's as fast (no daytime hours wasted) and economical (save a night's hotel stay) as a 3 hour daytime trip.
I would have taken this train long ago if it went overnight (with Viewliners or similar) in at least one direction. 12 hours is fine, if it's 7PM to 7AM. In practice that's as fast (no daytime hours wasted) and economical (save a night's hotel stay) as a 3 hour daytime trip.
Not gonna happen on a route that's touted for its scenery.* Also, I doubt Amtrak would put sleeping cars on a route that's overnight in only one direction, because the demand would be much lower for sleepers for the daylight version of the train.
In a "perfect" world you would have a slow local on this route, for people going to smaller en-route destinations and for those who want to enjoy the scenery. And, you have have a fast, express train on this route for business travelers or other frequent travelers who value speed. In fact, if the service was good enough you could probably have multiple express trains on this route daily. But I just don't see this particular city pair being a high priority over the next 20 years.
*Obviously many western L-D trains are touted for their scenery and run through the night with sleepers. But that's on a route that takes several days from end to end, which is very different than a one-day trip.
#10
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Homebase: CAE - Formerly, YUL
Programs: US CP, UA, HH Gold, Marriott Plat, DL, AA, CO, ++
Posts: 2,187
To make it appealing to Montreal folks, you'd have to make it comparable to the Express Montreal <-> Toronto on Via. Not the fastest train the world but not bad either.
HTSC
HTSC
In a "perfect" world you would have a slow local on this route, for people going to smaller en-route destinations and for those who want to enjoy the scenery. And, you have have a fast, express train on this route for business travelers or other frequent travelers who value speed.
#11
Join Date: May 2005
Programs: BA Gold, AA PLT PRO, AGR, Strawberry (Nordic Choice), Marriott Bonvoy
Posts: 4,248
Ideally I'd like a dining car with white linen tablecloths and a chef (but I know that's unlikely). But what about some improved food? On French TGV trains I've eaten smoked salmon sandwiches on brown bread with a delicious cup of freshly brewed to order coffee made using its own individual filter. That's not a huge investment, and would be hugely better than the horrible, stale-smelling shrink-wrapped hot dogs that they serve.
And it'd be nice if the journey, however long, took the time it was meant to take. On my trip from Montreal to NYP, the 10hr trip actually took 13 (and the cafe car ran out of its, albeit nasty, food).
#12
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: United States
Programs: UA, AA, DL, Amtrak
Posts: 4,647