FlyerTalk Forums

FlyerTalk Forums (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/index.php)
-   American Airlines | AAdvantage (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/american-airlines-aadvantage-733/)
-   -   Longest award ticket routings from Japan to EU? (https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/american-airlines-aadvantage/1909374-longest-award-ticket-routings-japan-eu.html)

mster May 14, 2018 8:06 pm

Longest award ticket routings from Japan to EU?
 
What would the longest ticket-able one-way award ticket routings from Japan to the EU look like?

A few ticketable routings:
TYO-SIN-HEL-LHR
TYO-SIN-MAD-LHR
TYO-HKG-SIN-MAD-LHR

A few unlikely, but not entirely implausible routings:
TYO-SIN-HKG-MAD-LHR (quasi-backtrack SIN-HKG)
TYO-SIN-HKG-DOH-LHR (transit Asia 2 & Doha "third regions")
TYO-SIN-HEL-DOH-LHR (transit Asia 2 & Doha "third regions" & backtrack HEL-DOH)

platbrownguy May 14, 2018 8:25 pm

The backtracking on tyo-sin-hkg-mad-lhr wouldn't be a problem, but you might hit an MPM problem.

Rules allow Asia 1 to Europe via Asia 2 or via DOH (if flights both into and out of DOH are on QR), but I don't think both. YMMV though.

mster May 14, 2018 8:38 pm


Originally Posted by platbrownguy (Post 29754303)
Rules allow Asia 1 to Europe via Asia 2 or via DOH (if flights both into and out of DOH are on QR), but I don't think both. YMMV though.

That's how I read the routing rules as well. With that in mind the longest routing I've found so far that looks solid is TYO-SIN-HKG-DUB-HEL at 12,262. MPM +25 for TYO-HEL is 14,525.

See anything longer / closer to maxing out TYO-EU MPM +25?

shd9 May 14, 2018 8:46 pm


Originally Posted by mster (Post 29754334)
That's how I read the routing rules as well. With that in mind the longest routing I've found so far that looks solid is TYO-SIN-HKG-DUB-HEL at 12,262. MPM +25 for TYO-HEL is 14,525.

See anything longer / closer to maxing out TYO-EU MPM +25?

I don't see why we are doing this... But if you swap SIN with CGK it is a little bit longer.

Dave Noble May 15, 2018 2:49 pm


Originally Posted by mster (Post 29754334)
That's how I read the routing rules as well. With that in mind the longest routing I've found so far that looks solid is TYO-SIN-HKG-DUB-HEL at 12,262. MPM +25 for TYO-HEL is 14,525.

See anything longer / closer to maxing out TYO-EU MPM +25?

I cannot see that any of thse are valid MPM by BA, JL and AY is 7456 miles and CX 9812

TYO-SIN-HKG-DOH-LHR - QR only permits TYO-DOH-LHR
TYO-SIN-HEL-DOH-LHR - trying to go Europe-Middle East - Europe
TYO-SIN-HEL-LHR - exceeds AY's MPM
TYO-SIN-MAD-LHR and TYO-HKG-SIN-MAD-LHR - no valid airline for SIN-LHR

This one looks unlikely to be able to be ticketed but the only one that has any viability
TYO-SIN-HKG-MAD-LHR

mster May 17, 2018 11:48 pm


Originally Posted by Dave Noble (Post 29757623)
I cannot see that any of thse are valid MPM by BA, JL and AY is 7456 miles and CX 9812

TYO-SIN-HKG-DOH-LHR - QR only permits TYO-DOH-LHR
TYO-SIN-HEL-DOH-LHR - trying to go Europe-Middle East - Europe
TYO-SIN-HEL-LHR - exceeds AY's MPM
TYO-SIN-MAD-LHR and TYO-HKG-SIN-MAD-LHR - no valid airline for SIN-LHR

This one looks unlikely to be able to be ticketed but the only one that has any viability
TYO-SIN-HKG-MAD-LHR

Why are you listing AY/CX MPM numbers? Isn't AA's MPM the only relevant one for awards ticketed using AA miles?

JJeffrey May 18, 2018 6:28 am


Originally Posted by mster (Post 29767121)
Why are you listing AY/CX MPM numbers? Isn't AA's MPM the only relevant one for awards ticketed using AA miles?

No, if you use AY or CX for the long haul segment between Asia and Europe then it is the routing rules or MPM of the AY or CX fares that will "govern" the award.

The AA MPM for an AA metal fare between TYO and LHR is irrelevant.

Dave Noble May 18, 2018 6:32 am


Originally Posted by mster (Post 29767121)
Why are you listing AY/CX MPM numbers? Isn't AA's MPM the only relevant one for awards ticketed using AA miles?

Nope - what matters is the routing rules of the governing carrier

JDiver May 18, 2018 6:47 am

https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/amer...aster-thd.html.

mster May 18, 2018 8:46 pm

Wouldn't the relevant AY MPM for Asia 1 to Europe via Asia 2 be the AY "MPM EH" of 9812 (ie. TYO-HKG/SIN/BKK-HEL-LHR with HKG/SIN/BKK-HEL on AY)? That would make MPM +25 11197 which would even allow for TYO-SIN-HKG-HEL-LHR at 10,892.

The "MPM TS" of 7456 makes sense for TYO-HEL-LHR (and possibly TYO-ICN/PVG/PEK-HEL-LHR) though.

Thanks for your insights!

Dave Noble May 19, 2018 12:19 am


Originally Posted by mster (Post 29770274)
Wouldn't the relevant AY MPM for Asia 1 to Europe via Asia 2 be the AY "MPM EH" of 9812 (ie. TYO-HKG/SIN/BKK-HEL-LHR with HKG/SIN/BKK-HEL on AY)? That would make MPM +25 11197 which would even allow for TYO-SIN-HKG-HEL-LHR at 10,892.

The "MPM TS" of 7456 makes sense for TYO-HEL-LHR (and possibly TYO-ICN/PVG/PEK-HEL-LHR) though.

Thanks for your insights!

No - It will be the published allowance for AY
AY does not have an MPM but lists specific permitted routings

1. TYO-AY-FRA-AY-HEL-AY-LON
2. TYO-NU/JL/GK/AY-OSA/NGO/FUK-AY-HEL-AY-LON
3. TYO-AY-HEL-AY-LON
4. TYO-AY-FRA-AY-HEL-BA/AY-LON
5. TYO-NU/JL/GK/AY-OSA/NGO/FUK-AY-HEL-BA/AY-LON
6. TYO-AY-HEL-BA/AY-LON.

On top of that, it may also not be permitted since this is a constructed routing of TYO-HEL with addon to London rather than a published routing

AA's award routings do not generally allow for scenic tours of continents

mster May 19, 2018 4:03 am


Originally Posted by Dave Noble (Post 29770574)
No - It will be the published allowance for AY
AY does not have an MPM but lists specific permitted routings

1. TYO-AY-FRA-AY-HEL-AY-LON
2. TYO-NU/JL/GK/AY-OSA/NGO/FUK-AY-HEL-AY-LON
3. TYO-AY-HEL-AY-LON
4. TYO-AY-FRA-AY-HEL-BA/AY-LON
5. TYO-NU/JL/GK/AY-OSA/NGO/FUK-AY-HEL-BA/AY-LON
6. TYO-AY-HEL-BA/AY-LON.

On top of that, it may also not be permitted since this is a constructed routing of TYO-HEL with addon to London rather than a published routing

AA's award routings do not generally allow for scenic tours of continents

Solid. So Expertflyer is giving incorrect info on AY MPM for the route in question? Where does one find these special AY MPM numbers you mentioned?

Dave Noble May 19, 2018 4:23 am

MPM has no relevance when the airline is listing specific allowed routes

On Expert Flyer , it can be seen that for TYO-LHR , that for AY fares , that they are constructed , rather than published fares - which can knock them out

There is , I must have missed it before, one AY fare that is a mileage based fare, but does have a mileage limit of 7456 miles

mster May 19, 2018 5:08 am


Originally Posted by Dave Noble (Post 29770881)
MPM has no relevance when the airline is listing specific allowed routes

On Expert Flyer , it can be seen that for TYO-LHR , that for AY fares , that they are constructed , rather than published fares - which can knock them out

There is , I must have missed it before, one AY fare that is a mileage based fare, but does have a mileage limit of 7456 miles

Moved less general question (TYO-VIE instead of TYO-EU) to https://www.flyertalk.com/forum/amer...r-thd-154.html . Thanks JDiver.

3Cforme May 19, 2018 7:30 am

I am curious to the OP's interest in this. Are you just interested in maximizing flight distance per 1,000 AAdvantage miles? (Not me - I want shortest total travel time conditioned by sensible departure and arrival times.) Do you expect to assemble a segment-by-segment routing? AA's use of married segment availability may thwart that. More segments over more carriers introduces greater risk of phantom award availability - AA agents just don't see it when you go to book it due to databases being out of sync.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 6:21 pm.


This site is owned, operated, and maintained by MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Designated trademarks are the property of their respective owners.