Compensation for Non-Functioning VX First Cabin
#1
Original Poster
Join Date: Oct 2010
Location: SEA
Programs: BonVoy Titanium, Hilton Gold, Delta Plat, BA Bronze
Posts: 66
Compensation for Non-Functioning VX First Cabin
Last night I flew SFO-SEA on VX1752 and upon takeoff, the 7 of us seated in the first class cabin noted that the seats could not recline and the in-flight entertainment was disabled. The flight attendants worked through their manuals diligently, but couldn't arrive at a solution, so the cabin was essentially 'dark' for the 95 minute flight. There was no impact to MCS or the seats in coach. I tweeted AS customer service and they immediately asked me to DM me, wherein they offered a $100 credit if I booked a flight within 180 days (economy only).
Does this seem like appropriate compensation? I understand that when AS announced that the VX flights originating out of DAL (Love Field) to LGA and DCA would move to Skywest, they compensated ticket holders with a free trip, acknowledging that the E175 first class product was not nearly comparable.
Looking over the loyaltylobby.com's thread on compensation clinics, others have asked/received for much more in similar circumstances, though I'm not sure if it's worth pushing harder on Alaska. Thoughts?
Does this seem like appropriate compensation? I understand that when AS announced that the VX flights originating out of DAL (Love Field) to LGA and DCA would move to Skywest, they compensated ticket holders with a free trip, acknowledging that the E175 first class product was not nearly comparable.
Looking over the loyaltylobby.com's thread on compensation clinics, others have asked/received for much more in similar circumstances, though I'm not sure if it's worth pushing harder on Alaska. Thoughts?
#2
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Jan 2012
Location: Northern Calif./Eastern Ida.
Programs: Amethyst Premier Plutonium Medallion
Posts: 20,646
my 2c is that it is not worth pushing for more, this is a 90 minute flight, and while annoying i'd say your compensation was fair relative to some i've received in the recent past.
#4
Original Poster
Join Date: Oct 2010
Location: SEA
Programs: BonVoy Titanium, Hilton Gold, Delta Plat, BA Bronze
Posts: 66
I don't disagree - it could have been worse, such as this happening on a redeye to JFK/EWR; however, I'm flummoxed that they're offering compensation in the form of an economy-only credit. I think most of my frustration is that I won't have an opportunity to use any credit with my busy work-travel schedule in the next 180 days, so it feels like they're 'getting away with it'.
#6
Join Date: Feb 2015
Location: Seattle
Programs: AS
Posts: 2,293
We had similar experience as OP. Flew LAX / SEA. VX in F. Row2 A/C
Seat 2A tray table totally broken, used blanket to hold tray table level for meal. Entertainment device stopped working after 5 minutes. Unable to reboot device. Gave up and could not watch movie(or anything)
Seat 2C Power recline broken and foot rest was able to raise about 8 inches then totally non responsive. crawled around it during flight then had to do manual reset for seat for landing (by FA)
Contacted AS Listens.....fo seat 2C , so far, nothing. Then, for Seat 2A, online AS Customer Service email with file # attached from auto reply. Indicated we would hear back...
Again, so far, nothing.
Will post if there is any compensation offered.
Seat 2A tray table totally broken, used blanket to hold tray table level for meal. Entertainment device stopped working after 5 minutes. Unable to reboot device. Gave up and could not watch movie(or anything)
Seat 2C Power recline broken and foot rest was able to raise about 8 inches then totally non responsive. crawled around it during flight then had to do manual reset for seat for landing (by FA)
Contacted AS Listens.....fo seat 2C , so far, nothing. Then, for Seat 2A, online AS Customer Service email with file # attached from auto reply. Indicated we would hear back...
Again, so far, nothing.
Will post if there is any compensation offered.
#7
Original Poster
Join Date: Oct 2010
Location: SEA
Programs: BonVoy Titanium, Hilton Gold, Delta Plat, BA Bronze
Posts: 66
We had similar experience as OP. Flew LAX / SEA. VX in F. Row2 A/C
Seat 2A tray table totally broken, used blanket to hold tray table level for meal. Entertainment device stopped working after 5 minutes. Unable to reboot device. Gave up and could not watch movie(or anything)
Seat 2C Power recline broken and foot rest was able to raise about 8 inches then totally non responsive. crawled around it during flight then had to do manual reset for seat for landing (by FA)
Contacted AS Listens.....fo seat 2C , so far, nothing. Then, for Seat 2A, online AS Customer Service email with file # attached from auto reply. Indicated we would hear back...
Again, so far, nothing.
Will post if there is any compensation offered.
Seat 2A tray table totally broken, used blanket to hold tray table level for meal. Entertainment device stopped working after 5 minutes. Unable to reboot device. Gave up and could not watch movie(or anything)
Seat 2C Power recline broken and foot rest was able to raise about 8 inches then totally non responsive. crawled around it during flight then had to do manual reset for seat for landing (by FA)
Contacted AS Listens.....fo seat 2C , so far, nothing. Then, for Seat 2A, online AS Customer Service email with file # attached from auto reply. Indicated we would hear back...
Again, so far, nothing.
Will post if there is any compensation offered.
#8
Join Date: Jun 2016
Programs: DL DM, Marriott Titanium, Hyatt Explorist
Posts: 150
Flew JFK-SFO on VX with a paid upgrade MCS-->F.
Had a similar experience, recliners not working, neither was the red system. I called up the Gold line and asked for them to credit 50% of the upgrade fee ($240 originally), which I felt was fair. They agreed right away.
Had a similar experience, recliners not working, neither was the red system. I called up the Gold line and asked for them to credit 50% of the upgrade fee ($240 originally), which I felt was fair. They agreed right away.
#10
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Jan 2012
Location: Northern Calif./Eastern Ida.
Programs: Amethyst Premier Plutonium Medallion
Posts: 20,646
I don't disagree - it could have been worse, such as this happening on a redeye to JFK/EWR; however, I'm flummoxed that they're offering compensation in the form of an economy-only credit. I think most of my frustration is that I won't have an opportunity to use any credit with my busy work-travel schedule in the next 180 days, so it feels like they're 'getting away with it'.
#11
Join Date: Mar 2017
Location: Anchorage, AK
Programs: MVP Gold
Posts: 215
#12
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: SEA (the REAL Washington); occasionally in the other Washington (DCA area)
Programs: DL PM 1.57MM; AS MVPG 100K
Posts: 21,375
I got a nasty scratch on my thumb from a broken wire near the console cover plate for the IFE screen; emailed a description and pix to VX CS (subject: F Seat on N528VA in need of Maintenance Attention) and got a $100 e-cert within 24 hrs
#13
Join Date: Jan 2017
Location: STL
Posts: 11
Years ago when VX was still VX I was on SEA-LAX in First and the same thing happened. It wasn't discovered until we were already in the air, the captain came out and tried to reset a circuit or something, and said had it been discovered on the ground it would have been a no go for flight until it was fixed. VX offered me $300 e-cert for any travel any cabin (more than I paid for the entire ticket). I would absolutely push for more. Alaska CS has a LOT of leeway. I would at the very least ask for 12.5k miles enough for a one way economy or I would push for more in an e-cert.
#14
FlyerTalk Evangelist
Join Date: Jan 2012
Location: Northern Calif./Eastern Ida.
Programs: Amethyst Premier Plutonium Medallion
Posts: 20,646
#15
Join Date: Feb 2015
Location: Seattle
Programs: AS
Posts: 2,293
We had similar experience as OP. Flew LAX / SEA. VX in F. Row2 A/C
Seat 2A tray table totally broken, used blanket to hold tray table level for meal. Entertainment device stopped working after 5 minutes. Unable to reboot device. Gave up and could not watch movie(or anything)
Seat 2C Power recline broken and foot rest was able to raise about 8 inches then totally non responsive. crawled around it during flight then had to do manual reset for seat for landing (by FA)
Contacted AS Listens.....fo seat 2C , so far, nothing. Then, for Seat 2A, online AS Customer Service email with file # attached from auto reply. Indicated we would hear back...
Again, so far, nothing.
Will post if there is any compensation offered.
Seat 2A tray table totally broken, used blanket to hold tray table level for meal. Entertainment device stopped working after 5 minutes. Unable to reboot device. Gave up and could not watch movie(or anything)
Seat 2C Power recline broken and foot rest was able to raise about 8 inches then totally non responsive. crawled around it during flight then had to do manual reset for seat for landing (by FA)
Contacted AS Listens.....fo seat 2C , so far, nothing. Then, for Seat 2A, online AS Customer Service email with file # attached from auto reply. Indicated we would hear back...
Again, so far, nothing.
Will post if there is any compensation offered.
Not from Alaska Listens. or AS Emailed Customer Service.