Starwood Lurker, if you don't mind the Times Square area, might I suggest the following location(just a block above the huge Sheraton on 7th):
http://www.facesandnames.com/about/index.html
Dan might remember this place as the bar we were in years ago, when we missed out on the $20 BA deal.
The reason I mention it, is that I already have plans to meet up with
ElmhurstNick there for a quick drink. Would love to see you again, as well.