Sounds like many of you have had positive experiences with HP recently. I know lots of people who will never give America Worst another chance. I personally don't have much first hand experience but am just passing along strong opinions from co-workers and friends. It sounds like it is hit or miss with HP. It does seem like all roads lead to Phoenix, which may not be the most direct route for many flights. If you are primarily flying to the Southeast, I would think that DL would be your best best. AA would be a runner up.