Originally Posted by
wharvey
Considering members have to have 90 posts outside CC to be admitted to that forum, there is no one who ONLY posts in CC.
There are however members who have posted only on CC for a long time. Right now on the first page of CC there's a post by a member from 1999 with less than 110 (counting) posts. All of his/her 2007 posts are in CC.
Originally Posted by
wharvey
How would this be different than someone who ONLY posts in OMNI or SPAM?
You don't get involved in quasi-commercial activities in OMNI or SPAM. Those who, after getting access to CC, stopped posting on FT except for CC, are using FT only for their personal profit (even if they're not acting as brokers), and contrary to the spirit of CC which is a friendly exchange between members of the community.
Originally Posted by
wharvey
Considering members often give stuff away asking for nothing in return (I have given away 7 SWUs over the past few years) why should they not receive post credit for giving to the community?
William
May be they should. I just offered a point against counting posts on CC; I admitted it's a minor point and I didn't even argue that posts on CC shouldn't count.