Originally Posted by acf573
No, what they are saying is that they first redeemed 50k points for their award then called GI to make the booking. You can do this through the ThankYouNetwork.com website or the 877 redemption number.
Of course the better way to do things is to call GI first and confirm availability and GI can pull the TY points directly from your account, get the certificate instantaneously, and then ticket the flight. Unfortunately,
coylerj didn't realize this was an option.

Perhaps. I was told with my initial call that I needed a certificate number to book the travel, so I went and got the certificates. They really did not want to talk to me about it once they realized I didn't have a certificate, and not knowing any better, I didn't push it. I naively didn't expect any problems.
Oh well, live and learn. I've dumped Citi and am happily using a competitor, so the situation will never come up again for me.