Originally Posted by GradGirl
Copwriter,
I can't help noticing that all of your, "... and then I arrested him after he challeged me" stories involve people who deserved arrest - they were publicly inebriated or were already suspects in a crime. I've never in my life been in either of those unfortunate situations.
If I hadn't done anything to be arrestable, you bet I'd refuse to answer questions. Anything I say can only get me into a worse place than I start if I start out lacking justification for arrest. Actually, I never said I'd actually *say* "Arrest me or leave me the hell alone." I said that was my motto, mostly developed as a result of the warrantless and unjustifiable searches of my body by the TSA. To an officer, I'd be respectful but still not answer any questions other than name, rank and serial number.
You seem to assume that cops regularly arrest people who
don't deserve to be arrested. I don't think this happens very often. There are many, many instances when a cop observes something that appears to be evidence of criminal behavior, but turns out to be perfectly innocent. By refusing to answer any questions, you're denying the officer the information that is the most useful in making this determination. It's your choice, and it's certainly your right, but I don't think it's in your best interest, despite what others here might tell you.
A big part of the job of policing is resolving disputes. These are far more often resolved by mediation than by arrest. When I would encounter someone who had been the subject of a complaint by someone else, and they initially refused to speak to me, I would tell them, "What would you rather have - their word against yours, or their word against nothing?" Granted, if they had been in the wrong, it wouldn't necessarily be in their best interest to talk to me. But, most of the time, there's a little wrong on each side, and the truth of the matter lies somewhere in between the two accounts.
When we completed a call for service, we had to report a "disposition code" over the radio. Examples were "MA-1" (one misdemeanor arrest), "HOJ" (handled other jurisdiction - handed the case off to another agency), or "UTL" (unable to locate). By far, the most common one used was "AC" - advised and complied.