Originally Posted by channa
I like this strategy. Out of curiousity, would this approach prevent someone from getting fined if they innocently go up to the checkpoint and ask permission before presenting an item for screening?
"Mr. Screener, is this cheese slicer allowed through, or should I check it?" = NO FINE
Cheese slicer in carryon bag placed on belt = POSSIBLE FINE
Assuming your question is a serious one, the answer is simple: no, you will not be fined. You have not yet entered the checkpoint and the item was not detected as a result of screening. You voluntarily offered it prior to screening for a determination.
The only thing that would make you liable to a fine would be if you had a clearly illegal weapon or item. Not trying to be flippant here, but if you came up to the checkpoint with a pipe bomb, of course you'll be fined. You'll also be arrested immediately and charged. But a cheese slicer? No, all you're doing is trying to find out if it is permitted in carry-on or if it is more appropriate in checked baggage.
Once you pass through the walk-thru metal detector and/or have an item placed in the x-ray machine, all bets are off and you then assume full responsibility for your actions, your property and anything that is found by a security screener in the performance of his or her official duties.
Sound reasonable?