Originally Posted by
joejones
Departing ORD, the Polaris Lounge that ANA uses is significantly better than the Flagship Lounge that JAL uses, mainly because of its sit-down dining (Flagship only has a buffet). But ANA's ORD-HND flight usually departs from B16, which is the least convenient gate to the Polaris Lounge (you have to go through the tunnel between the B and C concourses twice). JAL also has a very nice security checkpoint right by its check-in counters, which is often empty while the other checkpoints are jammed. So it's a bit of a wash, and JAL is arguably a better ground experience if you don't plan to eat much in the lounge.
But if you depart ORD and need your status for lounge access, then it is AA Flagship vs United Club. So ups and downs depending on the situation.