Originally Posted by
m3red
Maybe an off bottle but to me it felt like it was at its peak - someone who knows a lot more about wine than me actually said similar. The wonderful thing about wine is that everyone has a unique perspective.
Indeed, it is subjective and that is one of the beauties of wine.
While my opinion ultimately matters the most to me, I also like to see what professional tasters who I follow think of wines that I am interested in (and how their opinions change with time). In the case of the 2005 Palmer, they view it as being in its infancy and having decades ahead of it.