Originally Posted by Adelphos

IMO, nighttime landings are the best time for having a window shade open, as you can see landmarks, there is no glare, etc. IMO, it shouldn't be controversial. However plenty of people still apparently prefer shades down in these scenarios. I fly into LGA a lot and always enjoy the landing views. It seems like about half of the cabin still keeps shades down on approach here. I guess this begs the question - if you are in an aisle (or middle) seat, would you request your window seat mate to raise the window shade in these situations?