Originally Posted by xienon

EWR has the same. They've always treated me well as an EE and actually goes the extra mile for EE's.

Originally Posted by funnyfarm299

LGA often has cars set aside for EE members.

That said, in the NY metro, date and time is more important than location. Monday morning is usually great as the weekend renters have all returned and business travelers haven't arrived yet. Weekends are usually slim pickings, especially during summer and holidays as city-dwellers rent a car for the weekend.