Originally Posted by
Kiewittravel (Post # 2112)
As promised, I won't post again unless I decided to file for arbitration. Thanks everyone!
Originally Posted by
jsloan (Post # 2113)
On the contrary, please feel free to stay and be part of the community.

Indeed. The more viewpoints and perspectives, the better.
Originally Posted by
Kiewittravel (Post # 2116)
We can agree to disagree whether my paid upgrade qualifies me having a PE ticket, but that's really the only defense that United will have here
And it will be an impregnable one. What you purchased was an economy fare with an upgrade to a premium economy seat. Not a premium economy fare. You did not "upfare". Big difference.
I say that as someone who worked for UA as a Reservation Sales Representative during my first two years of law school, but has never been higher than a Premier Platinum member, and is unlikely to do so. UA also unilaterally took away my contractual right as a life member of the United Club to access the lounge when not flying UA or a Star Alliance partner.
Lifetime Member Edition: UC access changes Nov 1, 2019 (same day BP on UA or partner)
We encourage you to remain a part of the FlyerTalk community, and further learn the intricacies of the UA MileagePlus™ program, as written and as applied.
If you want to go ahead and arbitrate, have at it. It could benefit many of us here. However, based on our collective knowledge, we think your likelihood of success is minuscule.