Thank you all so much! Ive enjoyed reading through your comments. Ive been on multiple travel threads and it seems like Parrot Cay's food and accommodations are mediocre for the price and Amanyara hasn't gotten any thumbs up so we may just go back to Cap Juluca or Im also looking into a few others you all mentioned. This is a tough decision!
I've seen every room type here so let me know if you have any questions....
ABG, I'd love to hear what you think is the best accommodation for a couple with the most privacy/beach views?