Benjh - Where did you end up going, or did COVID ruin your plans? I'm based on the East Coast of the US but thinking through a similar question for a milestone birthday trip this year. I'm considering PH St. Kitts and Andaz Mayacoba along with some of the AI's, but currently have 3 nights booked on points on Calala Island. I'm really hoping we're able to keep that booking (COVID calms down and AA doesn't cancel our flights)!