Originally Posted by
Confus
Yes, from experience. I had one of the dishes last month in F that was the subject of much derision on this board for having the same description in both F and J. The one I had (in F) looked nothing like the one with pictures posted here from Club. And it was very tasty, again contrary to descriptions here, so I can only assume it was a totally different dish. And the cheeseboard (thankfully) neither looked nor tasted anything like the tiny dish from Club...
For some dishes, you may be correct - first class aged fillet as opposed to short rib beef, for example. But other dishes are surely identical - like the afternoon tea sandwiches and the ploughman’s etc…