Originally Posted by
Finkface
If you read the Twitter feed the OP linked, it gives some detail. The OP called in to inquire about changing the flights on Oct 2. AA told the OP there was no fee to change the flights and the OP said “okay” but didn’t mean “ok, make the change”. Something else transpired and they asked him what seats he wanted and at that point, his phone disconnected. He assumed no change had actually been made so didn’t check further. But AA claims “We've done an extensive review of your booking. The change of date from Oct 04 to Oct 07 was done upon your call-in request made on Oct 02”. At least that is what I garnered from the Twitter exchange he posted. It seems a case of miscommunication and misunderstanding.
Actually, at the point they asked "what seats do you want" I think that it was 100% on the OP.