Originally Posted by
garykung
In principal, you can try to request delay compensation under the Montreal Convention, given that it is an international booking. I assume that you did not end up returning Fresno but Aruba.
Whether you seek judicial redress is entirely up to you. However, keep in mind that:
1. Small Claims is still a court of law. You will need to explain why you should prevail. This is not something everyone can do.
2. You have to prove your claim. Using points/miles is no issue. How would you prove an equivalent fair value is another story.
3. The majority of Superior Courts of California are experiencing major backlogs, not including any potential unlawful detainer cases prevented by eviction moratorium. It can take as long as a year for your trial.
Send a certified mail to AA HQ demanding compensation citing Montreal and see how they respond.
You can file a small claims case without having any burden of proof. Any claim will do.
You only need to show more likely than not you are owed the compensation you claim (51% wins).
But, since no lawyers can participate in small claims court they will surely request a transfer to civil court.
Good luck with prevailing again AAs attorneys.