Originally Posted by xov91

Does anyone see a good case for keeping the premier over the amex gold? I have both at the moment. Fee for my gold card just posted today and my premier's fee will post shortly. I've made good use of both my TY points and MR, but I don't see a reason to have both cards after all of the changes to the premier.

Pros for the gold: higher earn rates on dining and grocery, MR are a bit more valuable, can easily use the dining credit, can still cashout MR for a few months before I likely cancel my schwab plat

Cons for the gold: airline credit, higher fee, poor downgrade option

Pros for the premier: lower fee, broad categories, portal boost for the next year, better downgrade options

Cons for the premier: lower multipliers, TY points are a bit less valuable, not really a con but I don't have a double cash so no uplift there

I will of course try for a retention offer on my gold. If that's successful, I'll downgrade the premier to a double cash. Otherwise, I'm having a harder time with this decision than I probably should. My spreadsheet points to the gold being a slightly better deal over all. Also, I likely won't use either for prepaid travel expenses as even the no-fee sapphire card has better travel protections. For now I still have a schwab plat and a CSR and will likely keep the CSR as is or downgrade to a CSP at renewal time in December.

Anyway, as I mentioned, the math points to the gold card for my particular situation, but I'm curious if anyone else sees the premier as the better option.