Surprised I wasn't able to find more about this comparison.

I want to fly to Barcelona from Toronto. Options are Air Canada Rouge direct Premium Economy, Lufthansa via Frankfurt Premium Economy, and Air Transat Club Class direct. I really don't care about the extra stop--in fact, I like FRA airport.

I do know that having flown AC Rouge economy, I'm not a fan of AC Rouge. At all. Never tried their premium economy though.

And I'd like to get a comparison of Lufthansa premium economy vs air transat club class. Seat pitch on Lufthansa premium economy seems to be 2 inches larger, but Air Transat Club has wider seats, a better screen, from what I've read better food and service, and I think priority boarding.

What do you guys think?