FlyerTalk Forums - View Single Post - Hotel showing loyalty appreciation by posting names of all elite arrivals
Old Mar 26, 2019, 8:37 am
  #78  
ethernal
 
Join Date: Feb 2017
Programs: DL DM, UA Gold, Alaska MVP, Bonvoy (lol) Ambassador
Posts: 2,994
Originally Posted by hockeyinsider
If you were under surveillance by the police or a private investigator, a spook, an investigative journalist, a rival corporation looking for trade secrets or even your wife's divorce lawyer, it would be easy to determine if you were loyal to a certain rental car company. Once I knew that and your travel patterns I could get there before you, see your name on the rental car board and place a recording device inside the car to monitor your activity.
You're being a bit paranoid. First and foremost this would be illegal. In all scenarios, it doesn't make sense (the only possible exception is investigative journalist):
  • Police would either work directly with the rental car company if they had a warrant, or if they did not have a warrant, this would not be admissible in court
  • Licensed private investigators would likely never do this because it is illegal. If they did collect this evidence with the goal of using it in a legal setting, it would not be admissible in court.
  • If the CIA or similarly equipped intelligence agency is trying to spy on you, they are going to be able to do that regardless of whether your name shows up a rental board
  • An investigative journalist would at best have a civil suit on their hands if they released this information, potentially criminal depending on the jurisdiction and local laws. That said, it is possible it would achieve their objectives - but at a high personal and potentially professional cost.
  • Corporate espionage - while it does happen - probably doesn't happen by spying on rental cars. This is doubly true in the era of the internet and electronically connected devices that are easily hacked.
  • Your wife's divorce lawyer would never do this. Both because it is illegal, would not be admissible in court, and would likely get him/her disbarred if it was clear that they are the ones that requested this happen.
Just to make it clear, putting a recording device in the car without the rental company and renter's consent is no different than placing a video camera in a hotel room. These are not trivial crimes.

There are valid, reasonable reasons to be worried about hotels posting guest names and rental cars posting names on a board. None of the reasons you cited are reasonable concerns.
ethernal is offline