Originally Posted by jrl767

23. Is this your lucky trip or what? A quick review of the schedules between St. Thomas and Washington Dulles has revealed a convenient afternoon 1-stop direct flight that ticks all the boxes: It’s more affordable than the traditional airlines flying the route, it offers First Class service and a dinner is served enroute. What airline and aircraft will you be flying upon and where will you stop along the way?

I have been pondering this for far too long, so I will start the wild-a** guessing herewith -- an Air Atlanta 727-100 via the eponymous enroute stop

When it comes to pondering these commercial aviation schedule related questions, you are amongst the very best, Mr. L. And so it is that I am mildly shocked and dismayed to inform you that the airline we're looking for was not Air Atlanta. Nor was the aircraft a 727-100.

Let's toss out a couple more hints: The airline was U.S. based and the enroute stop was in the Caribbean. Good luck! ^