FlyerTalk Forums - View Single Post - Better ua business lax-txl: stop ewr or lhr?
Old Dec 21, 2018, 11:01 am
  #81  
FlyerTalker70
 
Join Date: Nov 2017
Posts: 3,359
Originally Posted by threeoh
Looping back to the train vs plane discussion earlier in this thread, I would almost always prefer to take a train over a plane but this is one case I'd probably take the connecting flight. The last thing I want to do getting off a redeye TATL is to wait around an airport for an hour or two and then get on a cramped A319. A few hours on a train is much more pleasant. Plus, much of the inefficiency of air travel (getting to remote airport, clearing security, etc.) is not applicable for connecting flights.

If I was standing in Frankfurt city center and going to Berlin, I'd take the train every time, even if it were more expensive. If I'm standing airside at FRA and have a protected connection to an hourly flight, the calculus changes.

However, there are times I have (and would again) connect to a train. For example, there are many times when e.g. an LAX-FRA ticket + train ticket is way less than LAX-FRA-TXL ticket. If it's $700 r/t to FRA [in Y] and $1200 r/t to TXL via FRA, to me it's a no-brainer to take the train unless I'm on a super tight schedule. I usually go to Europe for 3-6 weeks at a time so 4 hours on the train vs 1.5 hours boarding, taxiing, and flying doesn't make a huge difference. I can use my phone, use my laptop, eat a sandwich, look out the window, and arrive in the city center.

With the Rail & Fly it's only EUR 33 for an unrestricted train ticket anywhere in Germany:

Rail&fly with United in Germany
Wow, did not know of this programme ... will need to keep it in mind the next time I travel stateside from Europe.

My experience with DB has been mostly positive quick and relatively good experience. However, the time I travelled with them there was a huge re-route involving taking 3 buses and 2 trains but that was caused by a rail bridge collapsing in Germany, something certainly outside their control. The only bad experiences I've had with rail was in Italy where their trains seem to break down like clockwork involving pax having to evacuate the train stand on an adjacent track and wait for the replacement train to arrive. I've certainly been inconvenienced more by air than rail but I suppose YMMV.

-James
FlyerTalker70 is offline