Originally Posted by
jamflyer
I did something similar where family and I stayed in a NJ property for 4 nights. After the 1st night, I did a one night stay in NYC at another Hilton property while the family remained in NJ. Both reservations were made in advance and Honors # included without issue. On check out, I got the NYC property points, but more than a week went by and the points for NJ did not post. However, after a very brief phone call to inquire, I was given the points and they posted while I was on the call.
This is similar to what I told the OP in post no 3. I'm sure I've also read that some agents won't let you have the points for both rooms, on the basis that you can't be in 2 hotels on the same night. Perhaps not and as you state, with a phone call to Hilton Honors, the points may be allocated.