FlyerTalk Forums - View Single Post - Powerbank confiscated in BKK
View Single Post
Old Apr 18, 2018 | 2:27 am
  #18  
Dave Noble
A FlyerTalk Posting Legend
40 Countries Visited
3M
All eyes on you!
20 Years on Site
 
Join Date: Jan 2002
Posts: 46,114
Originally Posted by sam
I bought from ebay http://r.ebay.com/Xdqjmw where it says Amp Hours: 6-8 hours. Using Qantas calculation ("Note: Watt hours (Wh) are determined by multiplying the voltage (V) by the amp hours (Ah). ie. 12V x 5Ah = 60Wh") this makes it 160Wh so within the limit (just). As explained earlier (with link provided) the 50000mAh is meaningless (and Qantas knows this hence the use of Wh). I had never seen the MaxOak website that puts it at 185Wh

The reality is that Qantas were happy to take it but this particular airport was not. Every other airport is happy to take it (I have flown with it ~50 times). Qantas argument was that the airport was liable not them.

Of course, now I know that it is 185Wh I will not try to fly with it again. However, following Qantas guidelines (to determine Wh by multiplying voltage and Amp Hours) it was reasonable of me to assume it was OK and therefore unreasonable of Qantas not to compensate me for its loss (imho - but I realise I'm not getting much support for this view here ).
It doesn't matter what someone on ebay says that it is - the ebay seller listed the mAH and the voltage at a level that would still lead to a Wh that exceeds Qantas's limit - voltage 5V and aH of 50 = 250 -- not sure how it is reasonable to think that it is ok

at 3.7v and 50 Ah , it is 185Wh as listed by the manufacturer - the 50000 is not meaningless , but is exactly what the manufacturer says it is - 50,000 mAh = 50 Ah

50,000 ÷ 1,000 ≠ 5 , which is what would be required for the item to be 5Ah

Any Qantas agent that said that Qantas was ok with it was incorrect since it is listed under dangerous goods

Qantas owed no compensation for refusal to carry goods listed in its dangerous goods list

Last edited by Dave Noble; Apr 18, 2018 at 2:32 am
Dave Noble is offline