I like the Wingate, for the location, and the hot breakfast buffet! It guess it's not a "10", but I'm not too fussy.
That said, I've been staying there for MANY years. They used to tell you that, while many NYC hotels are remodeled, converted apartment buildings, the Wingate was built from scratch. It has aged a little since way back then, but, it's still my first choice using Wyndham points.
One block from Madison Square Garden / Penn Station and a pleasant short walk to Times Square. Only steps from Macy's.