I am not willing to debate the merits of appointing a member who has had at least one lifetime ban, at least 3 suspensions and numerous warnings. To me, those factors should equate to a lifetime ban without parole. NOT, a position as a moderator.
As for forcing moderators to agree on actions, this is a very poor idea. Randy has complete faith in his moderators and there are moderation guidelines in place. There is no need for the inevitable delay associated with such a policy.
In my opinion, the second guessing and personal attacks on the hard working moderators needs to stop.