Originally Posted by
milepig
I just also saw the interview where the pax repeatedly referred to her suitcase. There's a world of difference between a violin case and a suitcase. I doubt the exception extends to instruments inside anything other than their standard case, which would have easily fit under her seat.
My understanding from piecing together several news reports; the traveller had a suitcase, backpack (personal item), and violin in hard shell case. Three items of luggage; one hold luggage and 2 carry on items.
The musician was travelling for a summer gig with the STL symphony, so probably had a lot of luggage.
The final rule from the US govt is musical instruments have first come first serve and pari passu with other carryons. Unfortunately musicians seem to think they are entitled to priority status to the overhead compartment.