Great review, Ericka! We had dinner at Rosewood over Christmas, and really enjoyed what we saw of the property (which, albeit, was not much in the dark). Your pictures were fantastic to help us get a better sense of the property in the daytime.

Now debating between Rosewood Mayakoba and Amanyara for a 4 or 5 night mini-moon departing from NYC. I did want to try Las Ventanas based on recommendations, but it's a bit far for such a short trip. Mayakoba and Amanyara are priced quite similarly for our dates when you take into account the full-board + free night offering at Amanyara.