Well what do you know... Sometime between 2:00 PM and 4:00 PM EST 12 of my outstanding 20 cards were each credited with $25 leaving me with 8 that have not been credited. The 8 I'm still waiting on are the last 8 that were converted to Vanillas.
All were ran as debit since I have never located a CVS in our area that'll take a credit card for a gift card.
I did not call and received the money as I suspected I eventually would - although I had made the decision to make the call when I had the time and mental energy to deal with it.
If you've been waiting check your cards - maybe they did another batch.
Example 1:
http://imgur.com/a/P3MmI
Example 2:
http://imgur.com/a/gSFye