Originally Posted by PhilH
1. Is this an OK itinerary? Max 20 flights, max 4 within any continent (except US). Is it OK to pass through hubs multiple times (e.g. LHR, HKG, SYD?)
As already noted, the Europe sectors need to change. Note that the Australia domestic sectors that you have excluded from the OWE may only offer Y service depending on the timing. But if you are paying separately for them, then they can be picked up at a reasonable price in Y anyway.
2. LHR-BKK, BA or QF? Am tempted to try QF First, as I will try BA on IAD-LHR-DXB-LHR and the flights to CAI. But I will get less miles for QF (1.5 times, rather than 2.25 times as Silver). Is it worth it to try out QF?
There's not much difference between the service offered on QF and BA in F. There are some minor differences in the product that come down to personal preference. The layout in the 744 is slightly different, with QF's seats being 4 rows and floowing the outer walls, while BA's layout has 5 rows and the seats are at an angle to the fuselage. but they have the same number of seats (14) with QF having 1x2x1 from row 2 back.
Another decision maker may be the typical wines offered. QF will tend to feature Australian wines which may be of interest to you. But for me, BA offer better scotch

- the wine is less of an issue to me.
You will get the same lounge access with BA and QF.
3. HKG-SYD, QF or CX? What's the First service like on this route for both carriers? Am tempted to try the CX A346, as this will be the only chance to try the longest plane in the world on this itinerary.
What's point on being on the longest aircraft when you are sitting right up the front

. If you choose CX, you will get access to the excellent CX lounges in HKG, and that is probably worth the difference. QF will be a 744, so you enter the aircraft, turn left (always better than turning right) and won't see another non-F passenger for the flight.
PS: Am planning a trip report simlar to Steady-EDI (
www.rtwman.co.uk), can't imagine it will be half as good though!
I will look forward to the report.