FlyerTalk Forums - View Single Post - Changes to xONEx Rule Sheet
View Single Post
Old Aug 6, 2016 | 10:33 am
  #396  
pandaperth
100 Countries Visited
All eyes on you!
15 Years on Site
 
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: used to be PER, now it's nowhere/eveywhere
Programs: QFF NB, AA GLD
Posts: 3,684
I've been spending a bit of time in EF looking at what all the airlines have in their fare rules for this clause.

What I have found is:
  • All airlines that have updated their fare rules, have the same wording as QF - except for AA of course
  • the two airlines that have yet to update their rules (BA and MH) have the same wording as AA (!)
  • except for LA which hasn't updated its rules since last year
So, what I think has happened is:
  • When the rules were changed back on April 22nd, the rules that went into the GDS were a poor translation into GDS-speak of the wording in the oneworld.com pdf document (see table reproduced below)
  • None of us picked up on that (I rarely look at the GDS versions of the rules)
  • And AA merely omitted to change its wording in the way the other airlines did
  • I think the poor translation was to think that in column 2 of the table -the first sentence was in the first row and the second sentence in the second row, whereas it is clear to a reader that both sentences pertain to both rows
Wording of the rule in the pdf document on oneworld.com:
IMHO this wording is in turn a poor translation of the actual requirement, which I think is:
3. Two permitted in Europe/Middle East when one is a transfer without stopover. Note only one flight segment permitted between the United Kingdom and South Africa/Mauritius

or maybe (if this was truly the intention)

3. Two permitted in Europe/Middle East when one is a transfer without stopover. Note only one flight segment permitted between Europe and South Africa/Mauritius
Originally Posted by JAXBA


Ugh!

I checked Amadeus to see how QF and AA had it filed and of course QF doesn't have the para 4(h) line, as we knew. I also compared paras 3(a)(b) for differences and, well, spot the difference:

QF filed:

Code:
            3. TWO PERMITTED IN EUROPE/MIDDLE EAST
            A. FOR TRAVEL ORIGINATING IN AFRICA
            //AFRICA-EUROPE/MIDDLE EAST-RTW-EUROPE/MIDDLE
              EAST-AFRICA//
            - ONE OF THE VISITS TO EUROPE/MIDDLE EAST MUST
            BE A TRANSFER WITHOUT STOPOVER BETWEEN AFRICA
            AND THE PREVIOUS/NEXT CONTINENT
            - IF TRAVEL TO/FROM EUROPE IN BOTH DIRECTIONS
             THE ITINERARY MAY NOT INCLUDE MAURITIUS/SOUTH
             AFRICA.
            B. FOR TRAVEL ORIGINATING OTHER THAN AFRICA
            //EUROPE/MIDDLE EAST-AFRICA-EUROPE/MIDDLE EAST//
            - ONE OF THE VISITS TO EUROPE/MIDDLE EAST MUST
             BE A TRANSFER WITHOUT STOPOVER BETWEEN AFRICA
             AND THE PREVIOUS/NEXT CONTINENT
            - IF TRAVEL TO/FROM EUROPE IN BOTH DIRECTIONS
             THE ITINERARY MAY NOT INCLUDE MAURITIUS/SOUTH
             AFRICA.

AA filed:

Code:
3. TWO PERMITTED IN EUROPE/MIDDLE EAST A. FOR TRAVEL ORIGINATING IN AFRICA //AFRICA-EUROPE/MIDDLE EAST-RTW-EUROPE/MIDDLE EAST-AFRICA// - ONE OF THE VISITS TO EUROPE/MIDDLE EAST MUST BE A TRANSFER WITHOUT STOPOVER BETWEEN AFRICA AND THE PREVIOUS/NEXT CONTINENT. B. FOR TRAVEL ORIGINATING OTHER THAN AFRICA //EUROPE/MIDDLE EAST-AFRICA-EUROPE/MIDDLE EAST// - IF TRAVEL TO/FROM EUROPE IN BOTH DIRECTIONS THE ITINERARY MAY NOT INCLUDE MAURITIUS/SOUTH AFRICA.
pandaperth is offline